2017 Penny Value Checker: Errors List, “P”, “S” & “D” Mint Mark Worth

2017 penny value ranges from $0.01 face value to $4,500. That record was set by a coin graded 1, sold through Heritage Auctions in July 2018. Upload a photo below to get a quick value range for yours. You can also scroll down to check recent eBay sales and see what collectors are paying right now.

 

2017 Penny Value By Variety

If you already know your coin’s grade, jump straight to the price in the **Value Guides** section below. Mint mark and condition make all the difference.

Also Read: Top 100 Most Valuable Modern Pennies Worth Money (1959 – Present)

 

Top 9 Most Valuable 2017 Penny Worth Money

The Denver Mint dominates the top of this list. One pristine specimen brought $1,595 — for a coin with a face value of one cent. Philadelphia issues trail far behind, with top sales of $37 at David Lawrence Rare Coins (DLRC) in January 2023 and $31 at Heritage Auctions in June 2019.

Deep Cameo proofs from San Francisco offer a more affordable entry point, with auction records starting around $95. Philadelphia Red (RD) coins in MS67+ grades have been trading steadily in the $20–$37 range across major platforms through 2024. Demand hasn’t faded.

Also Read: Lincoln Wheat Penny Value (1909-1958)

 

History of the 2017 Penny

The Lincoln cent debuted in 1909, designed by Victor David Brenner — the first widely circulating U.S. coin to show a president’s portrait. The reverse evolved from the Wheat design (1909–1958), to the Lincoln Memorial (1959–2008), to the current Union Shield introduced in 2010.

2017 was a landmark year. The U.S. Mint, founded by Act of Congress on April 2, 1792, turned 225 years old. Mint Director David J. Ryder marked the occasion with a move nobody saw coming.

Philadelphia Mint employees had suggested adding a “P” mintmark to the Lincoln cent as a tribute to the facility’s history. According to Tom Jurkowsky, director of the Mint’s Office of Corporate Communications, leadership loved the idea — and deliberately released the coins with zero public announcement. They wanted to see how long it would take someone to notice.

The coins shipped to Federal Reserve Banks in early January 2017 and entered normal circulation. The first collector to go public was Terry Granstaff, who spotted a 2017-P cent during a gas station transaction in Black Mountain, North Carolina. He posted images on the PCGS — Professional Coin Grading Service — online discussion board, and the hobby lit up overnight.

Plenty of collectors thought the coins were fakes. No Philadelphia-minted Lincoln cent had ever carried a “P” in the coin’s entire 108-year history. According to Numismatic News, Philadelphia production actually ran more than 100 million pieces below normal pace by April 2017, with Denver striking extra coins to compensate while the “P” rollout was still limited.

Matt Crane, marketing director at L&C Coins in Los Alamitos, California, acknowledged the huge mintage would keep values modest. But the surprise gesture, he said, was something “we will be talking about in years to come.” He was right. The 2017-P Lincoln cent remains a permanent one-year type — Philadelphia cents went back to no mintmark starting in 2018.

Also Read: Top 100 Rarest Pennies Worth Money (1787 – Present)

 

Is Your 2017 Penny Rare?

Here’s the counterintuitive part: the Denver coin, not the historic “P,” holds the auction record. That $1,595 sale happened because top-pop Denver specimens are genuinely scarce in MS68+ Red. Billions were struck, but almost none survived in flawless condition. The San Francisco proof is the rarest by mintage — under a million made — yet it’s the most affordable premium option because so many were carefully preserved by buyers. Rarity and value don’t always line up the way you’d expect.

To dig deeper into rarity scores across all Lincoln cent varieties, try our Coin Identifier and Value App for detailed rarity assessments.

 

Key Features of the 2017 Penny

The 2017 penny belongs to the Lincoln Shield cent series, introduced in 2010 to honor Lincoln’s role in preserving the Union during the Civil War. Here’s what to look for when you’re examining one.

The Obverse of the 2017 Penny

Flip to the “heads” side. You’ll see Lincoln’s left-facing portrait by Victor David Brenner. IN GOD WE TRUST runs above his head, LIBERTY sits to the left, and the date 2017 appears on the right.

The mintmark is right below the date — that’s how you tell which facility struck it. Look closely where Lincoln’s shoulder is cut off. You’ll spot the tiny initials VDB for Victor David Brenner, the original sculptor.

The Reverse of the 2017 Penny

Flip it over. The “tails” side shows the Union Shield with ONE CENT on a scroll across its face. Thirteen vertical stripes represent the original colonies, topped by a horizontal bar symbolizing the federal government binding them together.

E PLURIBUS UNUM (“out of many, one”) appears at the top of the shield. UNITED STATES OF AMERICA runs along the upper rim. Check the left and right ends of the scroll — you’ll find the initials LB and JFM, standing for designer Lyndall Bass and sculptor Joseph Francis Menna.

Other Features of the 2017 Penny

The 2017 penny has a plain edge. It’s copper-plated zinc — just 2.5% copper and 97.5% zinc — measuring 19.05 millimeters in diameter and weighing 2.50 grams.

All three active mints produced pennies in 2017: Philadelphia (P), Denver (D), and San Francisco (S). Each coin carries its mintmark on the obverse below the date. The “P” from Philadelphia? First and only time in history.

Also Read: 100 Most Valuable Wheat Pennies Worth Money (1909 to 1958)

 

2017 Penny Mintage & Survival Data

Philadelphia struck roughly 4.36 billion pennies. Denver added about 4.27 billion. That’s over 8.6 billion circulation cents in one year — enough to give every person on Earth one with change left over. That volume is why most 2017 pennies are worth exactly one cent in your pocket.

San Francisco made just 979,477 Deep Cameo proofs — less than 0.01% of total 2017 penny output. As of March 2025, PCGS has certified only 38 examples at MS68RD, and NGC has graded just 12 at the even higher MS69RD level. Even coins that were carefully stored struggle to survive in flawless condition.

Also Read: 100 Most Valuable Indian Head Penny Coins Worth Money (1859 – 1909)

 

The Easy Way to Know Your 2017 Penny Value

The 2017-P is a one-year type — the only Philadelphia Lincoln cent ever to carry a “P” mintmark, struck for the Mint’s 225th anniversary. Worn examples are worth face value. Uncirculated pieces are where the premiums start.

Color designation matters more than most people realize. RD (Red) means the coin kept almost all its original copper luster. RD examples typically bring 20–30% more than RB (Red-Brown) coins and far more than fully toned BN (Brown) specimens. Errors and grade push values even higher.

For a quick estimate without the guesswork, try our Coin Identifier and Value App on your 2017 pennies.

 

2017 Penny Value Guides

Three distinct varieties make up the 2017 penny series, each with a different story for collectors.

• 2017-P Shield Penny — Historic first Philadelphia penny with “P” mintmark
• 2017-D Shield Penny — Denver Mint production with standard “D” mintmark
• 2017-S DCAM Shield Penny — San Francisco Deep Cameo proof with mirror finish

Your best shot at finding a high-grade coin? Look through 2017 Mint Sets and original bank-wrapped rolls. Coins pulled from pocket change almost always show bag marks, spotting, or dulled luster. Always prioritize full Red (RD) color — that single factor can make one slabbed coin worth many times more than an otherwise identical Brown (BN) example.

Also Read: Value Of Old Pennies By Year (1959-Present)

 

2017-P Shield Penny Value

No Philadelphia Lincoln cent had ever carried a mintmark before this coin. Not once in 108 years. The Mint slipped it into circulation without a word, and collectors went wild when they started turning up in January 2017. It’s a one-year type that will never repeat.

As of March 2025, PCGS has certified only 38 examples at MS68RD and NGC has graded just 12 at MS69RD. Those are tiny numbers for a coin with a mintage in the billions. PCGS estimates MS68RD coins at approximately $500, while NGC’s price guide puts the same grade at around $325 — though no confirmed public auction records exist at that level as of this writing.

What has actually sold? MS67+RD coins brought $37 at David Lawrence Rare Coins (DLRC) in January 2023 and $31 at Heritage Auctions in June 2019. MS67RD examples trade on eBay in the $12.50–$31.75 range. MS66RD coins typically bring around $5. Raw ungraded pieces sell for $1–$2 depending on eye appeal.

Red (RD) specimens command the strongest premiums across every grade. Red-Brown (RB) examples fall in between, and fully toned Brown (BN) coins bring the least.

Here’s a look at current market activity for this historic issue.

 

2017-D Shield Penny Value

Most collectors overlook the Denver coin. That’s a mistake. The top auction sale for any 2017 business-strike penny — $1,595 — belongs to a Denver specimen, not a Philadelphia one.

Denver struck approximately 4,272,800,000 pieces, slightly fewer than Philadelphia partly because Denver was picking up extra production early in the year while the “P” mintmark rollout ramped up. Mid-tier Red examples have brought $264 at auction. Brown (BN) coins are more modest — one sold for $19 in 2023. The same 20–30% premium for RD over RB applies here, making color designation one of the biggest factors when you’re pricing a Denver coin.

I think the Denver issue is underappreciated right now. Registry set collectors chasing top-pop coins are the ones driving those four-figure sales.

Here’s how Denver specimens are performing in the current market.

 

2017-S DCAM Shield Penny Value

What does a $95 penny look like? Frosty white devices floating over glass-like mirrored fields. That’s the Deep Cameo effect — DCAM — and it’s what separates these San Francisco proofs from standard proof strikes. They’re the most visually stunning 2017 pennies you’ll find.

Only 979,477 were made. Compare that to 8.6 billion circulation strikes and you see a completely different kind of rare. Auction records show the Deep Cameo variety reached $95 in July 2018. Most certified examples land at PR69 or PR70 Deep Cameo grades because San Francisco’s proof production standards are exceptionally tight.

Collector interest in this proof issue stays consistent.

Also Read: Top 100 Most Valuable Modern Pennies Worth Money (1959 – Present)

 

Rare 2017 Penny Error List

Billions of coins means billions of chances for something to go wrong. Several documented 2017 error varieties can turn a pocket coin into real money. Here’s what to look for.

1. Doubled Die Errors (DDO / DDR)

A Doubled Die Obverse (DDO) or Doubled Die Reverse (DDR) happens during die making. The hub impresses the die at slightly different positions on two separate strikes, leaving part of the design appearing doubled on every coin struck from that die.

Don’t confuse this with machine doubling. That’s a flat, shelf-like distortion from the striking process — worthless to collectors. True doubled dies show clear separation between design elements.

On 2017 pennies, check IN GOD WE TRUST and LIBERTY on the obverse. The bolder and more separated the doubling, the more it’s worth. Dramatic examples are the ones that attract serious money.

2. Strike-Through Errors

Sometimes debris — dust, fabric fibers, grease, metal shavings — lands between the die and the blank planchet during striking. The die can’t fully reach the coin’s surface, leaving a void or impression. The debris usually falls away, but its mark stays permanently.

Bigger and weirder is better here. A large, unusually shaped strike-through in a prominent spot brings strong premiums. Coins showing multiple impressions are especially popular with error collectors who love these accidental minting artifacts.

3. Wrong Planchet Error (Struck on Bronze)

This is the showstopper. A documented 2017-P Lincoln Shield cent was struck on a bronze planchet — approximately 99.1% copper and 0.9% zinc, weighing around 2.87 grams instead of the normal 2.50 grams. PCGS certified it, and it sold through GreatCollections. One of the most exciting 2017 errors known.

Normal post-1982 Lincoln cents use copper-plated zinc planchets (97.5% zinc, 2.5% copper). If your coin feels heavier than it should, weigh it on a precise digital scale. Anything significantly over 2.50 grams is worth investigating. Submit suspected wrong planchet errors to PCGS or NGC for authentication before assuming value.

4. Off-Center Strike

When the blank planchet isn’t centered between the dies at the moment of striking, part of the design gets pushed off the edge. You’ll see a crescent of blank metal where the design should be. These errors are measured by the percentage of missing design.

The sweet spot for cherrypicking? 40–60% off-center with the full date still visible. Those command the highest premiums — anywhere from a few dollars to several hundred for dramatic examples with a complete readable date. Go past 60% off-center and lose the date, and value drops fast.

5. BIE Die Break / Cud Error

This one’s fun. The BIE error is exclusive to Lincoln cents — a small raised blob that appears between the B and E in LIBERTY. It’s caused by a crack in the die that lets metal flow into the gap during striking. Minor examples are common and worth $5–$10. Large, dramatic BIE errors or full cud breaks — where a chunk of the die’s rim breaks away — can bring $25 or more.

Every coin struck from that damaged die shows the same feature. A 2017-P BIE error is especially collectible because it pairs the die break with the already historic one-year “P” mintmark. We think these are great cherrypicking targets in rolls.

Also Read: 42 Rare Penny Errors List with Pictures (By Year)

 

Where to Sell Your 2017 Penny?

Got a high-grade specimen or an error coin you want to move? We’ve researched the best platforms where collectors are successfully selling their Lincoln cents.

Check out now: Best Places To Sell Coins Online (Pros & Cons)

 

2017 Penny Market Trend

*Market Trend Chart showing the number of people paying attention to this coin.

 

FAQ about the 2017 Penny Value

1. How much is a 2017 penny worth in circulated condition?

One cent. Doesn’t matter if it’s a “P,” “D,” or no mintmark — a worn 2017 penny from pocket change is face value. Premiums start with preservation: raw uncirculated examples bring $1–$2, certified MS66RD coins sell for around $5, and MS67RD examples typically go for $10–$20.

2. Why do 2017 pennies have a “P” mintmark?

The “P” mintmark was added to 2017 Philadelphia Lincoln cents to celebrate the U.S. Mint’s 225th anniversary, which fell on April 2, 2017. It was the suggestion of Philadelphia Mint employees and was approved by Mint Director David J. Ryder — making 2017 the only year in the Lincoln cent’s entire history (dating back to 1793) that a Philadelphia-struck one-cent coin bore the “P” mintmark.

3. What is the most valuable 2017 penny ever sold?

The highest verified auction sale for a 2017 Denver penny is $1,595 for a pristine top-pop RD example. For the 2017-P, confirmed sales include $37 at David Lawrence Rare Coins (January 2023) and $31 at Heritage Auctions (June 2019) for MS67+RD certified coins. PCGS estimates that a genuine MS68RD 2017-P could sell for approximately $500 if one came to market.

4. How many 2017-P pennies were made?

Approximately 4,361,220,000 — over four billion. Common in lower grades, obviously. But Philadelphia’s early-year production ran more than 100 million below normal pace, with Denver compensating, before full “P” mintmark output was established.

5. What does PCGS MS68RD mean for a 2017 penny?

MS stands for Mint State — never circulated, original luster intact. The 68 is the grade on the 70-point Sheldon Scale, where 70 is theoretically perfect. RD means Red — nearly all original bright copper color remains. As of March 2025, PCGS has certified only 38 examples of the 2017-P penny at MS68RD. That’s conditionally rare despite billions struck.

6. Is there a 2017 penny worth money on a wrong planchet?

Yes — a documented 2017-P Lincoln Shield cent struck on a bronze planchet (99.1% copper, 0.9% zinc, weighing approximately 2.87 grams) has been certified by PCGS at MS-64 RB and sold through GreatCollections. Normal 2017 cents weigh 2.50 grams, so any coin weighing significantly more could indicate a wrong planchet error. Always submit suspected planchet errors to PCGS or NGC for authentication before placing a value on them.

7. What is the difference between RD, RB, and BN on a 2017 penny?

These are color designations from grading services like PCGS and NGC describing how much original copper luster remains. RD (Red) means nearly all original color is present — typically 20–30% more valuable than an RB (Red-Brown) coin of the same grade. RB shows some red mixed with brown toning. BN (Brown) means fully toned, lowest value of the three.

8. What 2017 penny errors are worth the most money?

Wrong planchet strikes top the list (struck on bronze instead of copper-plated zinc). After that, dramatic Doubled Die Obverse (DDO) errors with bold, easily visible doubling on IN GOD WE TRUST or LIBERTY. Off-center strikes in the 40–60% range with full date visible also bring strong money. Die clash errors with prominent design transfers can bring $50 or more, while BIE die break errors range from $5 to $25+ depending on the size of the break.

9. Should I get my 2017-P penny graded by PCGS or NGC?

Only if you believe the coin can reach MS67RD or higher, or if it has a clear error. Basic grading fees start around $17–$19 per coin, so submitting an MS65 or lower costs more than the coin is worth. For top-pop candidates or verified errors, slabbing protects authenticity and boosts resale value significantly.

10. How does the 2017 penny compare to the 2019-W penny in rarity?

The 2017-P was struck in over four billion examples for general circulation. Common in worn grades. The 2019-W West Point penny, another Ryder-era surprise, was inserted only into Mint Sets and Proof Sets — never released broadly into circulation. That makes it much harder to find in pocket change. Both are celebrated one-year-only “surprise” mintmark issues, but the 2019-W generally commands higher premiums due to its far more limited distribution.