1958 Quarter Coin Value (Errors List, “D” & No Mint Mark Worth)

The 1958 quarter sparked one of numismatics’ most fascinating collector frenzies. When Philadelphia’s dramatically reduced mintage of just 6.36 million became known—an 86% drop from 1957—heavy speculation erupted in the 1960s.

Illinois dealer Ray Kotansky famously offered BU bags for $6,100 in 1965, and thousands of uncirculated rolls were hoarded.

This speculation created today’s distinctive pricing structure: while common Denver quarters reach $22.50 in MS condition, the scarcer Philadelphia issues command only $20.17—a reminder that collector psychology doesn’t always follow traditional rarity patterns.

The proof versions tell a different story entirely, with Deep Cameo examples reaching $280.62.

 

1958 Quarter Value By Variety

The value of your 1958 quarter depends heavily on where it was minted, with some varieties commanding significantly higher prices than others.

If you know the grade of your coin, you can find the exact price below in the Value Guides section.

Also Read: Top 100 Most Valuable Modern Quarter Worth Money (1932 – Present)

 

Top 10 Most Valuable 1958 Quarter Worth Money

Looking at the most valuable 1958 quarters sold since 2005, the results show just how dramatically condition and variety can impact value.

The clear standout is a 1958-D in MS-68 condition that sold for nearly $20,000 – proving that even common Denver quarters can command serious money in exceptional grades.

What’s particularly interesting is how the DCAM proofs perform across different grade levels, with a PR-69 specimen bringing over $8,500. The FS-901 Type B Reverse variety also makes a strong showing at $4,800 in MS-67, demonstrating how specialized varieties attract premium prices from knowledgeable collectors.

These top sales reveal the classic pattern we see throughout numismatics – condition is king, but variety and rarity create their own premium markets. Even business strikes from Philadelphia show impressive values when they achieve superb preservation levels.

 

History Of The 1958 Quarter

The quarter struck in 1958 continued a series that had begun over two decades earlier. It’s known as the Washington quarter, and it gets its name from the image of George Washington that appears on the obverse.

The first Washington quarters were struck in 1932 to commemorate the 200th anniversary of Washington’s birth. They were made from 90 per cent silver and 10 per cent copper. That was a recipe that would remain unchanged until 1965, when rising silver prices necessitated a different approach.

From that year on, everyday quarters were made of copper with a copper and nickel cladding, although some proofs were still struck in silver for collectors.

In recent years, the quarter has gone through a number of different designs on the reverse. These have included the well-known 50 States and America the Beautiful series. But in 1958, the design was unchanged from the very first quarters.

That year saw business strike versions of the quarter struck at the Mint facilities in Philadelphia and Denver. The Philadelphia facility also struck proof coins for collectors. Coins struck at Denver will have a mint mark, a “D” on the reverse. But while modern Philadelphia quarters are marked with a “P”, the Philadelphia facility didn’t use mint marks in 1958.

Also Read: Top 30 Most Valuable State Quarter Worth Money (1999 – 2008)

 

Is Your 1958 Quarter Rare?

You can also quickly verify the rarity level of any quarter you’re considering with our CoinValueChecker App.

 

Key Features Of The 1958 Quarter

The 1958 quarter isn’t just another Washington quarter – it has specific characteristics that set it apart from other years in the series.

I’ve examined hundreds of these coins to identify the key features that collectors should know about. From design elements to mint marks, understanding what makes 1958 quarters unique will help you spot valuable varieties and avoid common mistakes when buying or selling.

Here’s what you need to know about the distinctive features of 1958 quarters.

The Obverse Of The 1958 Quarter

Coin experts refer to the “heads” sides of coins as the obverse. The obverse of the 1958 quarter carries the same portrait of George Washington that appeared on the quarter from 1932 to 2022. It was the work of an artist called John Flanagan. But it wasn’t everyone’s first choice.

At one point, it had been planned to honor Washington with a half dollar that would be produced for a single year. The decision on the design was therefore expected to be for a special committee that had been set up to oversee all aspects of the bicentenary celebrations.

But the plans changed. Instead of appearing on a half dollar, it was decided that Washington should appear on the quarter. And instead of it being a one-off, it should be produced into the future.

As a permanent addition to the nation’s coinage, the decision on the design now fell to the Treasury. But the Bicentennial Committee had already selected a portrait – one by Laura Gardin Fraser. The Committee wrote to the Treasury Secretary, Andrew Mellon, encouraging him to choose the same image. But Mellon preferred a different portrait – the one by John Flanagan.

In the event, Mellon left his post before the coins were issued. But despite pleas from the committee, his successor, Ogden Mills, refused to reopen his decision.

Flanagan’s initials appear on the cut-off at the bottom of the portrait. To its left is the motto “IN GOD WE TRUST”. At the bottom of the coin, curving parallel to its lower edge, is the date. And the word “LIBERTY” curves above the portrait.

The Reverse Of The 1958 Quarter

Like the obverse, the reverse of the 1958 quarter was designed by John Flanagan. It shows an eagle with outstretched wings perched on a bunch of arrows. The stylized form of the bird is reminiscent of heraldic emblems. Below it, an olive branch curves parallel to the lower coin edge. The motif symbolizes peace.

The words “E PLURIBUS UNUM” arch over the eagle’s head. The phrase is Latin for “Out of the many, one”, a reference to the country’s creation as a union of states. The country name itself curves along the top of the design, while the denomination mirrors it at the bottom.

If your coin has a mint mark, it will be found on the reverse. Look for a small letter below the middle of the olive branch and above the “R” of “DOLLAR”.A “D” indicates that your coin was struck in Denver. If there’s no mint mark, that doesn’t mean your coin has an error. Philadelphia was the original Mint facility, and in 1958 it wasn’t adding mint marks to its coins.

Other Features Of The 1958 Quarter

The silver quarters are a little heavier than the clad versions that replaced them from 1965. They weigh 6.3 grams, as opposed to the 5.67 grams of clad quarters.

In both cases, though, the dimensions are the same. All Washington quarters have a diameter of 24.3 millimeters. The 1958 quarter has what is commonly referred to as a “reeded edge”. Turn it on its side, and you’ll see a series of parallel grooves running at right angles to the coin faces. These are the reeds.

They’re not just for decoration. They were originally used in the eighteenth century to combat a practice known as “coin clipping”. This was when unscrupulous traders cut slices of precious metal from the edges of coins, devaluing them.

The presence of reeds meant that anyone offered the coin in payment could see immediately if this had been done.

Also Read: Top 20 Most Valuable 1776-1976 Bicentennial Quarter

 

1958 Quarter Mintage & Survival Data

Looking at the mintage and survival data for 1958 quarters, the numbers tell a compelling story about rarity and collector opportunity.

The Denver mint dominated production with over 78 million quarters, while Philadelphia produced just over 6 million coins without mint marks. What’s fascinating is how survival rates vary dramatically across different types.

This survival data explains why certain 1958 quarters command premium prices. The lower the survival rate, the more scarce these coins become over time. It’s basic supply and demand economics playing out in the numismatic market.

These survival patterns aren’t unique to 1958 quarters though. Similar dynamics affect Washington quarters across different years and mint marks. 

Also Read: Top 100 Most Valuable Washington Quarter Worth Money (1932 – 1998)

 

The Easy Way to Know Your 1958 quarter Value

Grading a 1958 quarter accurately is where collectors make or lose serious money, and the details can be surprisingly tricky.

For 1958 quarters, surface preservation makes all the difference – even minor contact marks on Washington’s cheek or friction on the high points can drop a coin from Mint State to About Uncirculated, significantly affecting value.

What catches many collectors off guard is how subtle the differences between grades can be. When evaluating any 1958 quarter, our CoinValueChecker App can instantly assess grade and current worth.

 

1958 Quarter Value Guides

Looking at the 1958 quarter varieties, collectors need to understand that not all 1958 quarters are created equal – each type has its own market dynamics and value potential.

The five main categories break down into business strikes and collector proofs, with significant rarity and pricing differences between them. Understanding these distinctions is crucial whether you’re building a complete set or looking for investment opportunities.

Here’s the complete breakdown of 1958 quarter varieties:

• 1958 No Mint Mark Quarter– Philadelphia mint production, scarce with 6.36 million minted
• 1958-D Quarter– Denver mint variety, highest mintage at 78.12 million coins
• 1958 Proof Quarter– Special collector strikes with mirror-like surfaces, 875,652 minted
• 1958 CAM Quarter– Cameo proof with frosted devices against mirror fields
• 1958 DCAM Quarter– Deep Cameo proof, the rarest variety with strong contrast between frosted and mirrored surfaces

 

1958 No Mint Mark Quarter Value

The 1958 No Mint Mark quarter stands out as the lowest mintage business strike of the year, with only 6.36 million coins produced at the Philadelphia mint. This makes it significantly scarcer than its Denver counterpart, which had over 78 million strikes.

What’s particularly interesting is the 10% survival rate – meaning 90% of these coins have been lost, damaged, or melted over the decades. For collectors building date sets, this represents one of the key semi-keys in the Washington quarter series, especially in higher grades where the low mintage really shows its impact on availability.

Recent auction results demonstrate how this scarcity translates into strong realized prices across different grade levels.

Current market activity shows sustained collector interest with notable seasonal patterns in trading volume.

1958 Type B Reverse Quarter Value (FS-901)

The 1958 Type B Reverse FS-901 represents a fascinating variety that most collectors overlook, featuring subtle but distinct design differences on the reverse die. This variety was created when the Philadelphia mint modified the reverse hub, resulting in slightly different positioning and detailing of design elements compared to the standard Type A reverse.

What makes FS-901 particularly interesting is that it’s often confused with regular 1958 quarters, meaning many examples likely exist in collections without being properly identified. The variety requires careful examination to authenticate, focusing on specific die markers and design positioning that distinguish it from common strikes.

Auction records show how properly attributed FS-901 specimens perform when collectors recognize their significance.

Market activity reflects the growing awareness among variety specialists seeking these overlooked gems.

 

1958-D Quarter Value

The 1958-D quarter represents the workhorse of the series, with over 78 million coins struck at the Denver mint – making it the highest production quarter of 1958. 

This abundance makes it the most affordable entry point for collectors, but don’t dismiss it entirely – high-grade examples and error varieties can still command respectable premiums. The “D” mint mark appears on the reverse, to the right of the eagle, and is easily identifiable even on worn specimens.

Auction records demonstrate how even high-mintage coins can achieve surprising results when exceptional quality meets collector demand.

Market activity shows consistent trading volume with seasonal peaks reflecting steady collector interest in premium examples.

 

1958 Proof Quarter Value

The 1958 Proof quarter was specially struck for collectors using polished dies and planchets, resulting in mirror-like surfaces that distinguish it from business strikes. With 875,652 coins produced, it represents a significant mintage for proof coinage of this era.

What makes these coins unique is their deliberate collector-focused production – each coin was carefully handled and packaged, leading to a much higher survival rate of nearly 40%.

However, many have suffered from poor storage over the decades, making pristine examples increasingly valuable. The proof finish creates dramatic contrast and detail definition that business strikes simply cannot match.

Auction performance data shows how condition sensitivity drives dramatic price variations in the proof market.

Market activity reflects steady collector demand with notable seasonal fluctuations in trading volume.

 

1958 CAM Quarter Value

The 1958 CAM quarter represents a special subset of proof coins featuring cameo contrast – frosted devices against deeply mirrored fields.

Not all 1958 proofs qualify for CAM designation; only those with sufficient contrast between Washington’s portrait and the mirror-like background earn this classification. With just a 14.8% survival rate from the original proof mintage, CAM specimens are significantly scarcer than regular proofs.

The cameo effect was achieved through careful die preparation and polishing techniques, creating a dramatic visual impact that collectors highly prize. This variety bridges the gap between standard proofs and the ultra-rare DCAM specimens.

Auction records demonstrate how the cameo designation commands substantial premiums over regular proof examples.

Market activity demonstrates strong collector recognition with steady trading volume reflecting this variety’s visual appeal.

 

1958 DCAM Quarter Value

The 1958 DCAM quarter represents the pinnacle of proof coin production, featuring deep cameo contrast with heavily frosted devices against brilliant mirror fields.

Only coins with exceptional contrast quality earn the DCAM designation, making them extraordinarily rare with just a 2.855% survival rate from the original proof mintage. This translates to roughly 25,000 coins that still exist today in DCAM condition.

The deep cameo effect creates a striking three-dimensional appearance that’s immediately recognizable to collectors. These coins rank among the most visually dramatic Washington quarters ever produced, combining technical excellence with aesthetic beauty that commands serious collector attention.

Auction performance reflects the premium market’s recognition of this variety’s exceptional rarity and visual appeal.

Market activity demonstrates how serious collectors compete intensely for these outstanding specimens.

Also Read: What Quarters Are Worth Money

 

Rare 1958 Quarter Errors List

1. 1958 (P) No Mint Mark Quarter, Full First Struck Brockage Of Obverse On Reverse

Sometimes, a planchet sticks to the die as it’s struck. It’s then impressed onto the next planchet, producing a mirror image of itself.

This type of Mint error is known as a brockage error. And it happened with one proof quarter struck in Denver in 1958.

The brockage appeared on the reverse, where a mirror image of the obverse design was produced. As a result, Washington appeared on both sides of the coin, with everything appearing backwards on the reverse.

The highly unusual coin was graded PR62 by the PCGS. And it sold at auction for an astonishing $12,000.

2. 1958 (P) No Mint Mark Quarter, Struck On The Nickel Planchet

Sometimes something other than the correct planchet finds its way into the coin presses. And that can result in a very interesting error coin.

One of the quarters struck in Philadelphia in 1958 was struck on a planchet intended for a Jefferson nickel. The dimensions of the nickel are smaller than those of the quarter, so some of the design was lost. The tips of the word “LIBERTY” and the very bottoms of the numerals in the date were missing.

And instead of weighing 6.3 grams as a standard silver quarter should have, it weighed just 5 grams.

The quarter had been assessed by the NGC and graded at MS64, one point short of gem status. When it was presented at auction, it sold for just under $900.

Also Read: 20 Rare Washington Quarter Errors Worth Money (Full List with Pictures)

 

Where To Sell Your 1958 Quarter?

Now that you know the value of your 1958 quarter, do you know where to sell it for the best price? Don’t worry, I’ve compiled a list of trusted platforms with their pros, cons, and what to expect when selling your coins.

Check out now: Best Places To Sell Coins Online (Pros & Cons) 

 

1958 Quarter Market Trend

*Market Trend Chart showing the number of people paying attention to this coin.

 

FAQ About The 1958 Quarter

1. Is a 1958 quarter all silver?

Not quite. 90 per cent of the weight is accounted for by silver, with the remaining 10 per cent copper.

The Treasury changed the composition of quarters in 1965 to respond to the rising price of silver bullion. Silver was removed from business strike coins – those intended for everyday use – with the new versions made of copper clad in an alloy of copper and nickel.Some years saw proof coins continue to be struck in 90 per cent silver and 10 per cent copper.

2. How do I know if I have a rare quarter?

Two factors usually determine whether a quarter is rare.

The first is the condition of the coin – the very finest examples of each mintage are rare and valuable.The second is whether or not a coin has a Mint error. Doubling on the designs, coins that have been struck more than once, or coins struck on something other than the correct planchet, are just a few examples of such errors. And they’re all rare.

There are plenty of videos online that can help you assess the condition of your Washington quarter. These can help you decide whether it’s worth spending the money required for a professional evaluation.

Mint errors are often easier to spot. Coins that have been double struck or struck on the wrong planchet are usually pretty obvious.

But some types of error, like lamination errors that affect the surface of the coin, can be difficult to distinguish from later damage. Look for coins that have been independently authenticated before paying high prices for errors like these.