1958 Quarter Value Checker: Errors List, “D” & No Mint Mark Worth

The 1958 quarter is one of the most fascinating coins in the entire Washington quarter series — and not just because of its silver content. Philadelphia’s strikingly low mintage of just 6.36 million coins triggered one of numismatics’ most memorable collector frenzies, yet paradoxically, the Denver version often commands higher certified prices today.

Understanding why requires a closer look at mintage history, survival data, grading realities, and a handful of rare errors that can push a single coin into five-figure territory.

 

1958 Quarter Value By Variety

The value of your 1958 quarter depends heavily on where it was minted, with some varieties commanding significantly higher prices than others.

If you know the grade of your coin, you can find the exact price below in the Value Guides section.

Also Read: Top 100 Most Valuable Modern Quarter Worth Money (1932 – Present)

 

Top 10 Most Valuable 1958 Quarter Worth Money

Looking at the most valuable 1958 quarters sold since 2005, the results reveal just how dramatically condition and variety can swing a coin’s value.

The standout is a 1958-D graded MS-68 that sold for nearly $20,000 — a reminder that even a high-mintage Denver issue can become extraordinary in superb condition. According to PCGS CoinFacts, the all-time auction record for the 1958 No Mint Mark business strike stands at $4,560 for an MS-68 example sold by Heritage Auctions in July 2025.

The FS-901 Type B Reverse variety reached $4,800 in MS-67, and a PR-69 DCAM proof specimen brought over $8,500, confirming that specialized varieties and deep-cameo proofs attract the most serious collector dollars. These results illustrate the classic numismatic pattern: condition is king, but variety and rarity create their own premium markets.

 

History Of The 1958 Quarter

The 1958 quarter is part of the Washington quarter series, which began in 1932 to mark the 200th anniversary of George Washington’s birth. The coins were struck in 90% silver and 10% copper — a composition that remained unchanged until 1965.

What makes 1958 particularly significant is the economic backdrop. The recession that began in late 1957 caused the U.S. Mint to sharply reduce production forecasts. As a result, the Philadelphia Mint struck only 6,360,000 quarters — an 86% drop from the 1957 Philadelphia mintage of 46,532,000 coins. This makes 1958 the second-lowest mintage Philadelphia Washington quarter from 1941 through 1964, and the 16th lowest in the entire series.

Interestingly, the economic slowdown did not dampen collector enthusiasm. Mint Set sales actually hit a high of 50,314 sets in 1958 — the most sold since 1947. Collectors could purchase each set for $4.43 (about $45.50 in today’s dollars), and many of the finest known 1958 quarters come directly from these sets, often with distinctive toning from the packaging’s sulfur content.

That same low mintage triggered heavy speculation in the 1960s. Ray Kotansky, a coin dealer based in Streator, Illinois, was offering full bags of Brilliant Uncirculated 1958 quarters for $6,100 as early as 1965. Thousands of uncirculated rolls were hoarded as a result, which is why the coin is paradoxically easy to find in Gem condition today despite its low total mintage.

Business strikes were produced at both Philadelphia and Denver. Denver-minted coins carry a “D” mint mark on the reverse. Philadelphia coins from this era carry no mint mark — the Philadelphia facility did not begin adding a “P” mark to quarters until the 1980s. Proof coins for collectors were struck exclusively at Philadelphia.

Also Read: Top 30 Most Valuable State Quarter Worth Money (1999 – 2008)

 

Is Your 1958 Quarter Rare?

The 1958 quarter tells a counterintuitive story about rarity. Despite having a very low total mintage, the Philadelphia issue is actually easy to find in Gem (MS-65 and MS-66) grades — because so many rolls were saved by speculators in the 1960s. In contrast, the 1958-D had over 78 million struck, yet PCGS notes it is about twice as rare in true Gem condition as the Philadelphia issue, because fewer people bothered saving rolls of the higher-mintage coin.

Rarity only truly kicks in above MS-67. At that grade, combined certified populations across PCGS, NGC, and CAC total fewer than 90 coins for the Philadelphia issue — a number that rises slowly each year as existing coins are resubmitted.

You can also quickly verify the rarity level of any quarter you’re considering with our Coin Value Checker App.

 

Key Features Of The 1958 Quarter

The 1958 quarter isn’t just another Washington quarter — it has specific characteristics that set it apart from other years in the series.

Understanding what makes 1958 quarters unique will help you spot valuable varieties and avoid common mistakes when buying or selling. Here’s what you need to know.

The Obverse Of The 1958 Quarter

The “heads” side of a coin is called the obverse by collectors. On the 1958 quarter, you’ll find a portrait of George Washington — a design used continuously from 1932 all the way through 2022.

The portrait was created by artist John Flanagan, but it wasn’t the first choice. A committee overseeing Washington’s 200th birthday celebrations had already selected a portrait by sculptor Laura Gardin Fraser. That committee recommended Fraser’s design to Treasury Secretary Andrew Mellon, but Mellon preferred Flanagan’s version instead.

Mellon left office before the coins were issued, but his successor Ogden Mills upheld the decision, and Flanagan’s portrait became permanent. His initials appear at the base of the portrait. The motto “IN GOD WE TRUST” sits to the left of the portrait, the date curves along the bottom, and “LIBERTY” arches above.

The Reverse Of The 1958 Quarter

The reverse was also designed by Flanagan. It features a heraldic eagle with outstretched wings, perched atop a bundle of arrows. Below the eagle, an olive branch curves along the bottom — symbolizing peace alongside the arrows’ reference to military readiness.

“E PLURIBUS UNUM” (Latin for “Out of the many, one”) arches over the eagle’s head. “UNITED STATES OF AMERICA” runs along the top, while “QUARTER DOLLAR” mirrors it at the bottom. If your coin has a mint mark, look for a small letter beneath the center of the olive branch and just above the “R” in “DOLLAR” — a “D” means Denver; no letter means Philadelphia.

Other Features Of The 1958 Quarter

The silver 1958 quarter weighs 6.3 grams and measures 24.3 millimeters in diameter — the same dimensions used for all Washington quarters. Clad quarters introduced in 1965 are slightly lighter at 5.67 grams, so weighing your coin is one quick way to confirm it’s the genuine silver version.

The edge features parallel ridges called reeds — there are 119 of them on a Washington quarter. Reeds were introduced in the 18th century to combat “coin clipping,” where dishonest traders shaved precious metal from coin edges. The reeds made any clipping immediately obvious to the recipient.

One important composition note: the silver content gives these coins an intrinsic melt value regardless of numismatic condition. Each 1958 quarter contains 0.18084 troy ounces of pure silver, so at current silver prices, even a worn example is worth well above face value purely for its metal content.

Also Read: Top 20 Most Valuable 1776-1976 Bicentennial Quarter

 

1958 Quarter Mintage & Survival Data

The mintage and survival numbers for 1958 quarters reveal a story that defies expectations at every turn.

Philadelphia struck just 6,360,000 business-strike quarters, placing it among the four lowest-mintage Philadelphia issues from the entire 1941–1964 period. Yet because speculators hoarded so many rolls, certified populations in MS-65 and MS-66 are surprisingly deep. The PCGS certified population data shows only 20 examples graded below Mint State — because submitting a worn coin for grading makes no economic sense when its value is just the silver melt.

The Denver Mint struck 78,124,900 quarters in 1958 — more than ten times Philadelphia’s output. Paradoxically, far fewer gem-quality 1958-D coins survive relative to the Philadelphia issue, simply because collectors didn’t save as many rolls of a coin they assumed would always be common.

Survival is also genuinely exceptional once you reach MS-67+. As of April 2025, PCGS had certified just 65 coins in MS-67+ for the Philadelphia issue, while NGC had graded only 5 examples at MS-68. Combined across both services and CAC, only 88 coins carry an MS-67+ designation — making this a legitimately condition-rare coin at the highest grades.

Also Read: Top 100 Most Valuable Washington Quarter Worth Money (1932 – 1998)

 

The Easy Way to Know Your 1958 Quarter Value

Grading a 1958 quarter accurately is where collectors make or lose serious money, and the details can be surprisingly tricky.

Surface preservation is everything on these coins. Even minor contact marks on Washington’s cheek, or the slightest friction on the highest points of the design, can drop a coin from Mint State (MS) to About Uncirculated (AU) — a difference that can mean hundreds of dollars. The key grading areas on the 1958 quarter are Washington’s cheekbone, the hair above his ear, and the eagle’s breast feathers on the reverse.

One insider tip from the PCGS CoinFacts narrative: nearly every 1958 Philadelphia quarter that has achieved MS-67 grade is either a Mint Set toned example or an album-toned specimen. Blazing bright white coins from original rolls almost always cap out at MS-66. If you find a brilliant, untoned 1958 quarter, be cautious about expecting a grade above MS-66.

When evaluating any 1958 quarter, our Coin Value Checker App can instantly assess grade and current worth.

 

1958 Quarter Value Guides

Looking at the 1958 quarter varieties, collectors need to understand that not all 1958 quarters are created equal — each type has its own market dynamics and value potential.

The five main categories break down into business strikes and collector proofs, with significant rarity and pricing differences between them. Understanding these distinctions is crucial whether you’re building a complete set or looking for investment opportunities.

Here’s the complete breakdown of 1958 quarter varieties:

• 1958 No Mint Mark Quarter — Philadelphia mint production; scarce total mintage of 6.36 million, but common in Gem grades due to roll hoarding
• 1958-D Quarter — Denver mint variety; highest mintage at 78.12 million coins, yet genuinely scarce in Gem condition
• 1958 Proof Quarter — Specially struck collector coins with mirror-like surfaces; 875,652 minted
• 1958 CAM Quarter — Cameo proof (CAM) designation: frosted portrait devices against mirror-polished fields; only a subset of proofs qualify
• 1958 DCAM Quarter — Deep Cameo proof (DCAM): the rarest variety, with heavily frosted devices and brilliant mirror fields creating a dramatic three-dimensional effect

 

1958 No Mint Mark Quarter Value

The 1958 No Mint Mark quarter was struck at the Philadelphia Mint, which did not add a mint mark to its coins at this time. With only 6.36 million produced, it ranks as the fourth-lowest mintage Philadelphia Washington quarter from 1941 to 1964.

Despite the low total mintage, collector roll-hoarding in the 1960s created an unusual situation: the coin is relatively easy to find in MS-65 and MS-66 today. The 1958 is, in fact, described by PCGS as “one of the most common in Gem condition” for its era — a direct result of all those saved rolls entering the certified market over the decades.

Values shift dramatically once you enter the upper Mint State grades. In MS-66, examples are fairly plentiful and affordable. In MS-67, the coin becomes genuinely scarce — and virtually every such example owes its top grade to toning from a Mint Set or album. As of April 2025, PCGS had graded zero examples at MS-68 for this Philadelphia issue, while NGC has certified just five examples at that level.

A key auction benchmark: a 1958 No Mint Mark quarter graded MS-68 by NGC sold at Heritage Auctions in November 2023 for $1,080. The current PCGS all-time auction record stands at $4,560 for an MS-68 example sold at Heritage Auctions in July 2025.

Recent auction results demonstrate how this scarcity translates into strong realized prices across different grade levels.

Current market activity shows sustained collector interest with notable seasonal patterns in trading volume.

1958 Type B Reverse Quarter Value (FS-901)

The 1958 Type B Reverse (FS-901) is one of the most intriguing and overlooked varieties in the entire Washington quarter series. This coin features a business-struck obverse paired with a reverse hub normally associated with proof production — creating a distinctive “proof reverse” appearance on a circulation-strike coin.

Dr. Richard S. Appel, writing for CoinWeek, has called the Type B Proof Reverse Washington quarters the “Holy Grails of the entire Washington Quarter series” in high grade. For the 1958 issue specifically, PCGS has graded only 19 regular business-strike coins in MS-67, and in MS-66 the coin is described as “quite rare.” The FS-901 designation comes from the Cherrypickers’ Guide to Rare Die Varieties — a standard reference for variety collectors.

The FS-901 variety requires careful examination to authenticate. The most straightforward approach is to compare the reverse design detail against a known Type A reverse, focusing on die positioning, the shape of the eagle’s tail feathers, and the letter spacing in the legends. Many examples likely sit in collections unidentified, representing an ongoing opportunity for alert cherry-pickers.

The top auction record for the FS-901 variety stands at $4,800 in MS-67, reflecting growing awareness among serious variety collectors.

Auction records show how properly attributed FS-901 specimens perform when collectors recognize their significance.

Market activity reflects the growing awareness among variety specialists seeking these overlooked gems.

 

1958-D Quarter Value

The 1958-D quarter was struck at the Denver Mint, producing over 78 million coins — the highest mintage of any Washington quarter in 1958, and more than ten times the Philadelphia output. The “D” mint mark appears on the reverse, below the center of the olive branch and just above the “R” of “DOLLAR.”

Here’s the counterintuitive twist that surprises many collectors: despite vastly more coins being made, the 1958-D is actually about twice as rare in true Gem condition as the lower-mintage Philadelphia issue. The reason is simple — because the mintage was so large, far fewer people bothered saving rolls in the 1960s. Most 1958-D quarters entered circulation and were spent, lost, or worn down.

This makes high-grade examples of the 1958-D legitimately hard to find. In April 2015, Heritage Auctions sold a PCGS MS-68 example with rainbow toning for $9,987.50. At Stack’s Bowers’ Rarities Night in 2016, another MS-68 with spectacular toning attracted significant bidder interest. These results confirm the 1958-D as a “condition rarity” at the MS-68 level — a term that means the coin is common in circulated grades but genuinely rare when pristine.

Auction records demonstrate how even high-mintage coins can achieve surprising results when exceptional quality meets collector demand.

Market activity shows consistent trading volume with seasonal peaks reflecting steady collector interest in premium examples.

 

1958 Proof Quarter Value

The 1958 Proof quarter was struck exclusively at the Philadelphia Mint using specially polished dies and planchets. Unlike business strikes intended for circulation, proof coins — often abbreviated “PR” or “PF” — were made multiple times with extra care, producing deeply reflective mirror-like fields and sharply defined raised design elements.

With 875,652 proof sets produced in 1958, this issue has a meaningful mintage for its era. The Mint sold each proof set for $4.43, and the protective packaging preserved a high proportion — nearly 40% — in excellent condition. However, decades of improper storage have taken a toll on many specimens, making pristine, undamaged examples increasingly valuable.

A standard proof 1958 quarter in circulated or low-grade proof condition is worth roughly $10–$20. In PR-65, expect values around $13–$30. But the real action begins with cameo and deep cameo designations, where prices can rise sharply into the hundreds.

Auction performance data shows how condition sensitivity drives dramatic price variations in the proof market.

Market activity reflects steady collector demand with notable seasonal fluctuations in trading volume.

 

1958 CAM Quarter Value

The 1958 CAM quarter — CAM is short for Cameo — is a special subset of proof coins featuring a striking visual contrast between the frosted raised devices (Washington’s portrait, the eagle) and the deeply mirrored background fields. Not every 1958 proof qualifies; only coins with sufficient frost-to-mirror contrast earn the CAM designation from grading services like PCGS (Professional Coin Grading Service) or NGC (Numismatic Guaranty Company).

Achieving the cameo effect required careful die preparation and controlled polishing. In 1958, the Mint had not yet perfected the process of maintaining cameo contrast across multiple strikes — so freshly polished dies produced cameo coins at the beginning of a die’s life, before the frost wore off. This natural die-use progression explains why CAM examples account for only about 14.8% of the original proof mintage in certified populations.

CAM specimens bridge the gap between standard proofs and the ultra-rare DCAM variety. They represent an accessible entry point for collectors who want the visual drama of cameo contrast without paying DCAM prices.

Auction records demonstrate how the cameo designation commands substantial premiums over regular proof examples.

Market activity demonstrates strong collector recognition with steady trading volume reflecting this variety’s visual appeal.

 

1958 DCAM Quarter Value

The 1958 DCAM quarter — DCAM stands for Deep Cameo — represents the absolute pinnacle of proof coin production for this year. Only coins with exceptionally heavy frosting on the raised devices, set against virtually flawless mirror fields, earn the DCAM designation. The contrast creates a dramatic near-three-dimensional visual effect that is immediately arresting even to non-collectors.

With a survival rate of just 2.855% from the original proof mintage, roughly 25,000 DCAM examples are estimated to exist. But not all of those are in top grades — the vast majority are PR-64 or PR-65. In PR-68 DCAM, examples are extraordinarily rare. A PR-69 DCAM example sold at auction for over $8,500, confirming the premium that top-grade deep cameo proofs command.

These coins rank among the most visually dramatic Washington quarters ever produced, combining technical excellence with the aesthetic beauty of the frosted cameo effect. Serious collectors compete intensely for finest-known examples at this designation level.

Auction performance reflects the premium market’s recognition of this variety’s exceptional rarity and visual appeal.

Market activity demonstrates how serious collectors compete intensely for these outstanding specimens.

Also Read: What Quarters Are Worth Money

 

Rare 1958 Quarter Errors List

Error coins from 1958 are among the most exciting finds a collector can make. These are coins where something went unexpectedly wrong during the minting process, creating a one-of-a-kind piece that commands major premiums. Here are the known errors for the 1958 quarter.

1. 1958 (P) No Mint Mark Quarter — Full First Struck Brockage Of Obverse On Reverse

Sometimes a planchet sticks to the die after being struck, then gets impressed onto the next planchet entering the press. This creates a mirror image of the previously struck coin’s design — a phenomenon known as a brockage error.

On this particular 1958 proof quarter, the brockage appeared on the reverse, resulting in a backwards mirror image of Washington’s portrait appearing where the eagle design should be. The PCGS graded this extraordinary coin PR-62, and it sold at auction for an astonishing $12,000 — a result that underscores the rarity of first-strike brockage errors on proof coins.

2. 1958 (P) No Mint Mark Quarter — Struck On A Nickel Planchet

Wrong planchet errors occur when a blank intended for a different coin denomination accidentally enters the coin press. In this case, a 1958 Philadelphia quarter was struck on a planchet meant for a Jefferson nickel (a five-cent coin).

Because a nickel planchet is physically smaller than a quarter planchet, portions of the design couldn’t fit — the tips of “LIBERTY” and the bottoms of the date numerals were clipped off. The coin also weighed only 5 grams instead of the standard 6.3 grams for a silver quarter. Graded MS-64 by NGC (Numismatic Guaranty Company), this wrong-planchet error sold at auction for just under $900.

3. 1958-D Quarter — RPM (Repunched Mint Mark) Varieties

In 1958, the Denver Mint still hand-punched the “D” mint mark into each working die individually, using a steel punch and mallet. This manual process sometimes resulted in the punch striking slightly off position — either from an initial misalignment or a repositioning — leaving a secondary “shadow D” behind the primary mark.

These RPM (Repunched Mint Mark) varieties are visible under magnification and are documented in the Cherrypickers’ Guide to Rare Die Varieties. Minor RPM examples on 1958-D quarters typically carry premiums of $25–$75 over standard examples, while more dramatic misalignments with clear separation can command $100 or more in higher grades.

4. 1958 Quarter — Strike-Through Grease Error

In 1958, the Mint used grease and oil to lubricate coin press dies. On rare occasions, too much grease would accumulate and partially fill the recessed areas of a die. When this happened, the metal flowing into those areas was restricted, producing a coin with ghostly or missing design details — often called a “greasy ghost” effect.

Strike-through grease errors on 1958 quarters range from very minor (a slightly soft date or a weak letter in “LIBERTY”) to dramatic (portions of Washington’s face appearing nearly absent). Values depend on how much of the design was affected: minor examples sell for $20–$50, while dramatic pieces affecting major design elements can reach $200–$500 in Mint State.

Also Read: 20 Rare Washington Quarter Errors Worth Money (Full List with Pictures)

 

Where To Sell Your 1958 Quarter?

Now that you know the value of your 1958 quarter, do you know where to sell it for the best price? Don’t worry, I’ve compiled a list of trusted platforms with their pros, cons, and what to expect when selling your coins.

Check out now: Best Places To Sell Coins Online (Pros & Cons) 

 

1958 Quarter Market Trend

*Market Trend Chart showing the number of people paying attention to this coin.

 

FAQ About The 1958 Quarter

1. Is a 1958 quarter all silver?

Not quite — it’s 90% silver and 10% copper by weight. Each coin contains 0.18084 troy ounces of pure silver.

The U.S. Treasury changed the composition of quarters in 1965 in response to rising silver prices. New business-strike quarters were switched to a copper core with a copper-nickel cladding. Some collector proof coins continued to be struck in 90% silver for additional years after that change.

2. How do I know if I have a rare 1958 quarter?

Two factors primarily determine rarity: condition grade and the presence of an error or variety.

In terms of condition, the finest 1958 quarters — those in MS-67 or higher — are genuinely scarce, with combined certified populations of fewer than 90 coins across PCGS, NGC, and CAC as of 2025. For errors, look for signs of brockage, wrong planchet weight, repunched mint marks, or missing design details. These require magnification and ideally professional authentication.

3. Why is the 1958 Philadelphia quarter less expensive than the 1958-D despite having a lower mintage?

This is one of the most surprising aspects of the 1958 quarter market. When Philadelphia’s low mintage became widely known in the early 1960s, speculators hoarded thousands of Uncirculated rolls, ensuring a large supply of gem-quality coins survived.

Denver’s far larger mintage of 78 million meant fewer collectors bothered saving rolls — so far fewer gems exist today. In Gem condition, the 1958-D is roughly twice as rare as the Philadelphia issue, which explains why top-grade Denver examples often command higher prices.

4. What is the silver melt value of a 1958 quarter?

Because each 1958 quarter contains 0.18084 troy ounces of silver, its melt value moves with the silver spot price. At a spot price of approximately $75 per troy ounce, the melt value is around $13.56 per coin.

Even a heavily worn 1958 quarter is worth more than face value simply for its silver content. Check a current silver spot price calculator and multiply by 0.18084 to find today’s exact melt value.

5. What does “MS” mean on a 1958 quarter grade?

MS stands for Mint State — the numismatic term for a coin that has never been circulated and shows no wear. The Mint State scale runs from MS-60 (the lowest uncirculated grade) to MS-70 (theoretically perfect, with no marks visible even under 5x magnification).

For 1958 quarters, MS-65 to MS-66 examples are common and affordable. MS-67 examples are scarce and valuable. MS-68 examples are extraordinarily rare, with only a handful certified by NGC across all 1958 business strike issues combined.

6. Are 1958 proof quarters valuable?

Standard proof 1958 quarters in PR-65 are worth roughly $13–$30 — affordable and attractive. Value rises significantly with the cameo (CAM) designation, where frosted devices contrast with mirrored fields.

The highest-value proofs are Deep Cameo (DCAM) examples, which represent just 2.855% of the proof mintage. A PR-69 DCAM example sold for over $8,500 at auction, demonstrating the strong premium these top-designated pieces command.

7. What is the Type B Reverse (FS-901) 1958 quarter and how do I identify one?

The FS-901 is a business-strike 1958 quarter struck using a reverse die hub normally associated with proof production, giving the reverse a finer, more detailed appearance than a standard circulation quarter.

To identify one, compare the reverse eagle design closely to a standard 1958 quarter using a magnifier. Key differences appear in the tail feathers, the sharpness of the arrow bundle, and the overall crispness of the design. Consult the Cherrypickers’ Guide to Rare Die Varieties (abbreviated CPG) for exact die markers. Confirmed examples have sold for up to $4,800 in MS-67.

8. What 1958 quarter errors are worth the most money?

The most valuable known 1958 quarter error is the Full First Struck Brockage — a proof coin with Washington’s portrait appearing in mirror image on the reverse — which sold for $12,000 graded PR-62.

The wrong planchet error (quarter struck on a nickel blank) reached nearly $900 in MS-64. RPM varieties and strike-through grease errors are more common and typically sell for $25–$500 depending on severity and grade.

9. How many 1958 quarters still exist today?

For the Philadelphia business strike (6.36 million minted), the survival rate is estimated at around 10% — meaning roughly 636,000 examples may still exist in some form. However, the vast majority are in circulated condition and worth primarily silver melt value.

For the proof issue (875,652 minted), survival is estimated at approximately 40%, or about 350,000 coins. Among these, only about 25,000 are estimated to carry the DCAM designation in any grade.

10. Should I clean my 1958 quarter before having it graded?

Never clean a coin you intend to have graded. Cleaning — even gentle polishing — removes the original surface and luster, permanently damaging numismatic value.

PCGS and NGC both flag cleaned coins with a “details” grade (for example, “MS-64 Details — Cleaned”), which dramatically reduces resale value compared to a straight, uncleaned grade. Even toning, which may look unattractive to the untrained eye, is considered original and desirable by serious collectors — many of the finest MS-67 examples of the 1958 quarter owe their top grades to attractive toning from original Mint Sets or albums.