Rare 2005 Dime Errors Worth Money (Full List With Pictures)

A 2005-D Roosevelt dime with a broad struck error sold through GreatCollections in 2022 for $1,340. The full 2005 dime error list covers mint mistakes valued from $15 minor die varieties all the way up to four-figure striking errors. Over 2.8 billion dimes left Philadelphia and Denver that year, and most are worth exactly ten cents. But a handful escaped the mint with defects that collectors pay real money for — here’s every known error, sorted by value, with auction records and how to spot each one.

1. 2005 Dime Minor Doubled Die Obverse Error (Up to $15)

By 2005, the U.S. Mint used single-squeeze hubbing — one high-pressure pass to create each die. That killed the dramatic doubled dies from earlier decades.

What survived are Class VIII “Tilted Hub” varieties, where the hub shifted slightly mid-squeeze, leaving faint notching at specific design points. These exist only on 2005-P dimes and are cataloged in the Wexler Doubled Die Files (WDDO).

There is no major DDO for this year. The doubling is so subtle that most collectors walk right past it without 20x magnification.

Value: Raw examples trade for $5–$15 on eBay and in online forums. No major auction house has featured a 2005-P minor WDDO as a standalone lot — the buyer pool is simply too thin. You’re selling to die variety specialists who cross-reference Wexler catalog numbers, not general error collectors chasing visual drama. At these prices, the cost of a PCGS or NGC submission exceeds the coin’s market value, so virtually all examples trade raw.

How to Identify: Grab a 20x loupe — that’s the minimum. Examine the date digits (2, 0, 0, 5) and the motto IN GOD WE TRUST on a 2005-P dime only.

The doubling appears as slight thickening or notching at the corners of individual digits or letter serifs. It’s localized to specific points, not spread uniformly across the coin.

The critical trap here is machine doubling, which is extremely common on 2005-P dimes. Machine doubling shows as a flat, shelf-like shadow pushed to one side of all raised lettering — it affects everything in the same direction. A genuine WDDO shows rounded notching at specific diagnostic points only. Compare your coin against listings at doubleddie.com. If the shadow is flat and uniform, it’s machine doubling and worth face value.

Use Our 2005 Dime Value Checker

 

2. 2005 Dime Off-Center Strike Error (Up to $560)

An off-center strike happens when the planchet doesn’t seat properly in the striking chamber. The die comes down, but only part of the blank is in position.

The result is a coin with a crescent of smooth, unstruck metal on one side and the design shifted toward the opposite edge. Off-center errors are measured in percentages — 5% is barely visible, 50% leaves half the coin blank.

The percentage matters enormously for value. A 50% off-center with a readable date is a completely different coin from a 3% shift you need a ruler to notice.

Value: In 2021, Heritage Auctions sold a 2005-D dime graded MS62 with a 15% off-center strike for $560. That’s the high end for this date. Minor off-center strikes under 5% carry little to no premium — a few dollars at most. Coins struck 40%–60% off-center with a visible date typically trade between $100 and $300. Without a readable date, even dramatic off-centers drop sharply.

How to Identify: Look for a crescent-shaped area of blank, featureless metal on one side of the coin. The design will be shifted toward the opposite edge, with part of the lettering or portrait cut off. Both obverse and reverse shift the same direction.

Don’t confuse this with a Misaligned Die (MAD) error. A MAD shows the complete design but slightly off-center within the rim — far less valuable.

Post-mint damage from vises or machinery creates uneven distortion with visible scratches. A genuine off-center strike has a clean, smooth unstruck area with no tooling marks. Check whether the date “2005” is still readable — date visibility is the single biggest factor separating a $50 coin from a $300 one.

Use Our 2005 Dime Value Checker

 

3. 2005 Dime Die Chip Error (Up to $675)

Die chips form when small fragments break off the die’s striking surface during production. The gap left behind fills with metal shavings as the die keeps working.

That buildup transfers onto every planchet the die hits, leaving small raised bumps or blobs on the finished coin. Die chips can appear anywhere — Roosevelt’s face, inside letter loops, along the date.

They’re one of the most common die errors on Roosevelt dimes. Size and location drive the value — a chip inside the “O” of GOD is more collectible than one buried near the rim.

Value: A 2005-P dime graded MS64 with prominent obverse die chips sold at Heritage Auctions in 2021 for $675. That price reflects multiple large, well-placed chips on a higher-grade coin. Smaller chips on circulated coins generally trade for $5–$50. A single small chip near the rim might bring $5 on eBay, while a cluster of chips on Roosevelt’s portrait in MS60+ condition can push past $100.

How to Identify: Use a 5x loupe and scan for small raised lumps that don’t belong to the original design. Die chips look like smooth, rounded bumps sitting on top of the portrait, letters, or field.

Placement matters. Chips on Roosevelt’s face, inside LIBERTY, or overlapping the date attract the most interest. Compare your coin side by side with a normal 2005 dime.

The key distinction is from post-mint damage. Die chips are raised with smooth, rounded edges. Contact marks from circulation look scratched, gouged, or flat. Run your fingernail across the suspected chip — if it catches upward, that’s raised metal from the die, not a hit from another coin.

Use Our 2005 Dime Value Checker

 

4. 2005 Dime Rim Cud Error (Up to $735)

A rim cud is a die crack’s bigger, uglier cousin. It forms when a chunk of the die’s edge breaks away completely — not a hairline fracture, but an actual piece of steel gone missing.

Metal flows into the void during striking and creates a raised, blob-like bump along the coin’s rim. Cuds vary widely in size — some are barely noticeable nubs, others are large enough to eat into nearby letters.

The bigger the cud, the more dramatic the visual. Collectors pay accordingly.

Value: A 2005-D dime graded MS61 with a large rim cud sold on eBay in 2023 for $735. That was a visually striking example with a cud large enough to distort the nearby design. Smaller cuds on circulated coins typically sell for $20–$100 depending on size and location. Cuds that encroach on LIBERTY or the date tend to bring the top of that range.

How to Identify: Run your finger along the rim. A cud feels like a raised bump that disrupts the smooth, even edge — distinctly different from a ding caused by dropping the coin.

Genuine cuds have a smooth, flat top — they formed under thousands of pounds of striking pressure. Post-mint damage looks rough, jagged, and irregular.

Check the design elements near the cud. On a genuine example, the letters or portrait features next to the break may appear weakened or distorted, because the broken die couldn’t apply full pressure in that area. Also examine the opposite side directly behind the cud — a slight depression or weakness in the reverse design at that position helps confirm it. Flat-topped bump at the rim with weakened design nearby is the fastest confirmation.

Use Our 2005 Dime Value Checker

 

5. 2005 Dime Feeder Finger Error (Up to $780)

Feeder fingers are mechanical arms inside the coin press that position each blank planchet onto the collar before striking. After placing the blank, they retract.

When a feeder finger doesn’t pull back fast enough, the die comes down on both the planchet and the lingering finger. The result is a set of parallel horizontal lines or grooves pressed into the coin’s surface.

The pattern looks deliberate and mechanical — nothing like random pocket damage. These errors are under-recognized by casual collectors, which keeps prices somewhat accessible relative to their visual appeal.

Value: A 2005-D dime graded MS66 with a feeder finger error sold through GreatCollections in 2022 for $780. The MS66 grade and dramatic, well-defined finger marks drove that price. Less prominent examples on lower-grade coins generally sell for $20–$100. Feeder finger errors with faint, hard-to-see marks rarely clear $30, so visual intensity is the main value driver here.

How to Identify: Look for a set of parallel, evenly spaced lines running horizontally across the coin’s surface. These are distinct from random circulation scratches, which go in multiple directions with varying depth.

The lines usually appear on one side only, most often the obverse. They may cover a small section or stretch across a wider area.

Check that the lines are uniform in both depth and spacing — random handling scratches will vary in both. Confirm the lines were pressed into the surface during minting rather than scraped on afterward. Post-mint scratches cut through raised and recessed areas unevenly, while feeder finger marks sit at a consistent depth. Fastest visual check: parallel, evenly spaced horizontal lines on one side, with uniform depth across the pattern.

Use Our 2005 Dime Value Checker

 

6. 2005 Dime Partial Collar Strike Error (Up to $810)

During normal striking, a steel collar ring surrounds the planchet to contain the metal and form the reeded edge. A partial collar strike happens when the planchet sits tilted — part inside the collar, part above it.

The portion inside the collar gets normal reeding. The portion above expands freely.

The result is a coin with a visible “step” or “shelf” around part of its edge, where the reeded section abruptly transitions to a smooth, expanded area. You see it best from the side — the coin almost looks like it has a railroad track running along one section of the rim.

Value: A 2005-P dime graded MS65 with a partial collar strike error sold for $810. That was a well-defined example with clearly visible steps on a gem-condition coin. Partial collar strikes on circulated coins with subtle steps are more common and sell for $20–$75. Dramatic steps visible to the naked eye on uncirculated examples consistently push past $200, especially when the transition zone is sharp and photogenic.

How to Identify: Flip the coin on its side and examine the edge. A partial collar strike shows a distinct step where normal reeding abruptly transitions to a smooth or distorted section. This transition is the defining feature.

Use calipers to measure — the expanded section will be slightly wider than the standard 17.91mm, while the collared section stays normal.

Don’t confuse this with a broadstrike, which has a uniformly smooth edge all the way around. A partial collar has both reeded and smooth sections on the same coin. Also rule out dryer damage, which creates uneven distortion and surface scratches absent from genuine partial collars. Fastest check: view the coin edge-on and look for the step between reeded and smooth sections.

Use Our 2005 Dime Value Checker

 

7. 2005 Dime Die Crack Error (Up to $880)

Die cracks form when the steel die develops fractures from repeated stress and heat cycles. Every die eventually cracks — it’s a question of when, not if.

As the cracked die keeps working, metal fills the fracture line and transfers onto each coin as a thin raised line across the surface. Die cracks run in any direction and can appear on either side.

The most valuable examples show cracks on both obverse and reverse, struck by the same cracked die pair. Longer cracks that cross important design elements beat short ones near the rim.

Value: A 2005-P dime graded MS63 with die crack errors on both obverse and reverse sold at GreatCollections in 2023 for $880. The dual-sided cracking drove that price. Single-side die cracks on circulated coins typically sell for $10–$75, depending on length and prominence. A short crack near the rim on a worn coin might fetch $10. A long crack running across Roosevelt’s face on an uncirculated coin pushes well past $75.

How to Identify: Look for thin, raised lines running across the coin’s surface. Unlike scratches, which are recessed, die cracks sit above the surface. Run your fingernail perpendicular across a suspected crack — you should feel it catch upward.

Examine both sides. Coins with cracks on both obverse and reverse bring the highest prices. Use a loupe to trace each crack’s full length.

Cracks through Roosevelt’s face, LIBERTY, or the date are worth more than short ones near the rim. If a crack connects to the rim and a chunk of the die has broken away — leaving a raised blob at the edge — that’s actually a cud error, a different category listed above. Fastest confirmation: a raised line you can feel with your fingernail, running across the design.

Use Our 2005 Dime Value Checker

 

8. 2005 Dime Missing Clad Layer Error (Up to $900)

Roosevelt dimes are three-layer coins — a pure copper core sandwiched between two outer layers of 75% copper / 25% nickel alloy. When contaminants prevent proper bonding at the strip mill, one or both outer layers can peel or separate entirely.

The exposed copper core gives the affected surface a vivid reddish-brown color. It stands out immediately, even in a handful of mixed change.

Denver-minted 2005 dimes are particularly well-documented for this error. A dual missing clad — both sides exposed — is extremely rare and commands the steepest premiums in this category.

Value: A 2005-P dime graded MS64 with a partial missing clad error sold on eBay in 2023 for $900. A 2005-D specimen certified NGC MS64 realized $499.90. Circulated examples with smaller exposed copper areas trade for $20–$100 raw. Certified coins in MS64–MS66 range from $75–$500, depending on the extent of the missing layer and eye appeal. Dual missing clad layers — both sides showing copper — are exceptionally rare and can command $1,000–$5,000.

How to Identify: Start with color. A missing clad dime shows copper — brassy orange to dark brown — on one or both sides. Normal dimes are uniformly silver-toned, so any warm coloring is a flag.

Next, weigh it. This is the make-or-break test. A standard dime weighs 2.27 grams; a coin missing one clad layer comes in around 1.8–2.0 grams. If your copper-colored dime weighs 2.27 grams, it’s almost certainly acid-treated — a post-mint alteration worth face value. Use a digital scale accurate to 0.01g.

Check the rim for an abnormally thin profile or absent cladding band. Examine the side opposite the missing layer — the design should appear weak or mushy, because the thinner planchet couldn’t fill the die cavities fully. Fastest confirmation: copper color plus weight well below 2.27 grams. No exceptions.

Use Our 2005 Dime Value Checker

 

9. 2005 Dime Strike-Through Error (Up to $1,020)

A strike-through happens when a foreign object gets trapped between the die and the planchet at the moment of striking. The object blocks part of the design from fully impressing onto the coin.

Grease, cloth fibers, metal shavings, dust, hair — almost anything can cause it. In most cases, the object falls away after the strike, leaving only its imprint as a weak or blank area.

In rarer cases, the object stays physically embedded in the coin. These “retained strike-throughs” are the ones collectors chase, because the evidence is still sitting right there on the surface.

Value: A 2005-P dime graded MS60 with a retained strike-through sold on eBay in 2023 for $1,020. The retained foreign object was the key — physical proof that something was trapped during striking. Grease-filled strike-throughs, far more common, sell for $5–$50. Non-retained examples with large affected areas can push past $100 in higher grades. Retained examples with identifiable foreign material consistently command the strongest premiums in this category.

How to Identify: Look for an area where the design appears weak, mushy, or completely absent — a smooth patch where detail should be. This flattened zone means something blocked the die during striking.

Use a loupe to examine the affected area. Grease strike-throughs show a smooth blank patch. A solid-object strike-through (cloth, wire, etc.) may show texture — sometimes you can identify the material.

Check whether the foreign object is still on the coin. A retained strike-through will have material physically stuck to the surface, and that’s the premium version. Make sure the weakness isn’t just from wear — strike-throughs affect a specific, localized area, while circulation wear spreads evenly across all high points. Fastest check: a sharply defined weak zone surrounded by otherwise normal strike detail.

Use Our 2005 Dime Value Checker

 

10. 2005 Dime Broad Struck Error (Up to $1,340)

A broad strike occurs when the collar die — the steel ring that contains the planchet during striking — fails or is missing entirely. Without the collar, the planchet spreads outward under pressure like a tiny pancake.

The result is a dime visibly wider than normal with a completely smooth edge. No reeding at all.

What separates a broadstrike from an off-center error: broad struck coins usually retain the full obverse and reverse design, just expanded. The symmetrical spread with complete design detail is what gives this error its visual punch — and its price tag.

Value: A 2005-D dime graded MS64 with a broad struck error sold through GreatCollections in 2022 for $1,340. That’s one of the highest prices on record for any 2005 dime error. The coin had sharp, clear design detail despite the expansion. Less dramatic broadstrikes on circulated coins sell for $50–$200. Minor examples with barely perceptible expansion trade for $10–$25. Grade and visual drama are everything here — a well-struck MS64+ broadstrike and a barely-expanded circulated example live in different price universes.

How to Identify: Size is the first giveaway. Hold a suspected broadstrike next to a normal dime — the broadstrike will be visibly wider. Confirm with calipers: anything over the standard 17.91mm is a flag.

Check the edge. A normal dime has 118 reeds around its circumference. A broad struck dime has a completely smooth edge with zero reeding. This is the fastest visual confirmation.

The design on both sides should be complete — full portrait, full torch — just slightly stretched outward. If parts of the design are missing, you’re looking at an off-center error instead. Weigh the coin: it should still be 2.27 grams. Coins flattened by dryers or vises show uneven spreading, scratches, and damaged detail — a genuine broadstrike expands symmetrically and retains sharp features.

Use Our 2005 Dime Value Checker

 

Conclusion

The 2005 dime error range runs from $15 minor doubled dies that only die variety specialists care about, up to a $1,340 broad struck that made someone’s year at a GreatCollections auction. In between, missing clad layers, strike-throughs, die cracks, and off-center strikes fill out a solid $50–$1,000+ middle tier. A digital scale, a 10x loupe, and a pair of calipers are the only tools you need to start checking your change.