2011 Presidential Dollar Value Checker: Errors List, “P”, “D” & “S” Mint Mark Worth

2011 Presidential Dollar value ranges from $1.00 face value to $575. That record was set by a Grade 68 example sold on eBay in July 2018. If you’re wondering what yours might be worth, upload a photo of your coin below for a quick value range. Then scroll down to browse recent eBay sales and see what buyers are actually paying right now.

 

2011 Presidential Dollar Value By Variety

The following chart breaks down how 2011 Presidential Dollar values fluctuate based on mint mark, position variety, and coin condition.

If you know the grade of your coin, you can find the exact price below in the Value Guides section.

Also Read: Presidential Dollars Value (2007 to Present)

 

Top 10 Most Valuable 2011 Presidential Dollar Worth Money

The most striking pattern in this chart is that Position A coins — those where edge lettering appears inverted when the obverse faces up — are generally valued 30–90% higher than their Position B counterparts. For example, a Hayes Position A MS69 reaches $575, while a Position B MS68 trades for only $289.

This edge orientation difference is not an error; it is a normal production variation caused by how individual coins align during the edge-lettering step. Yet collectors have consistently assigned major premiums to Position A examples, particularly in the top grades. The jump from MS68 to MS69 can double or even triple a coin’s value, reflecting the extreme conditional rarity at the peak of the grading scale — with only dozens of 2011 Presidential Dollars certified at MS68 and above across all varieties.

One important nuance: the Partial Edge Lettering error coin for Hayes grades at MS67 and still sells for only $195 — actually below the value of top-grade normal coins. In today’s premium collecting market, grade outweighs error status once you reach MS68 and above.

 

History Of The 2011 Presidential Dollar

The Presidential Dollar series was born from the Presidential $1 Coin Act of 2005, formally known as Public Law 109-145, which President George W. Bush signed into law on December 22, 2005. The legislation was introduced by Senator John E. Sununu as Senate Bill S. 1047 on May 17, 2005, with over 70 co-sponsors, and passed the House of Representatives 291 to 113.

The law required the U.S. Mint to honor every former president in chronological order, releasing four new designs per year. A key eligibility rule stated that a president must have been deceased for at least two years before being honored. The program was explicitly modeled on the hugely successful 50 State Quarters program, with Congress hoping rotating presidential portraits would generate similar collector enthusiasm.

In 2011, the program’s fifth year, sculptor-engravers brought four 19th-century commanders-in-chief to life. Don Everhart created the portraits of Andrew Johnson, Ulysses S. Grant, and Rutherford B. Hayes, while Phebe Hemphill designed the James Garfield obverse. Each president honored in 2011 also appeared alongside a corresponding First Spouse bullion gold coin, featuring Eliza Johnson, Julia Grant, Lucy Hayes, and Lucretia Garfield.

By mid-2011, the program’s core problem could no longer be ignored: Americans simply did not want to use dollar coins. Federal Reserve vaults had swollen to over 1.4 billion unused Presidential Dollars — a surplus representing years of production going directly into storage rather than commerce. The program’s initial year alone saw nearly one billion coins minted across all four presidents.

On December 13, 2011, the Obama Administration announced a dramatic policy reversal. Vice President Biden and Treasury Secretary Timothy F. Geithner declared that the U.S. Mint would cease producing Presidential Dollars for general circulation starting in 2012. The shift to a collector-only program was estimated to save American taxpayers approximately $50 million per year in unnecessary production costs.

Consequently, the 2011 James A. Garfield Dollar became the last Presidential coin released to the public through Federal Reserve banks. From 2012 onward, the series would serve only collectors — marking 2011 as the pivotal transition year in the program’s history.

Also Read: Top 40+ Most Valuable Presidential Dollar Coins Worth Money

 

Is Your 2011 Presidential Dollar Rare?

Wondering if your 2011 Presidential dollars are valuable? Use Coin Identifier and Value App to instantly verify their rarity, Position type, and grade. Your pocket change could be worth $575—check yours now and discover hidden treasures!

 

Key Features Of The 2011 Presidential Dollar

Understanding the design elements of the 2011 Presidential Dollar helps collectors and enthusiasts appreciate both the artistic craftsmanship and historical significance of these coins. Each 2011 issue featured unique presidential portraits while maintaining consistent design standards across the series.

The Obverse Of The 2011 Presidential Dollar

Each 2011 Presidential Dollar features a distinctive portrait of a single president. Don Everhart — one of the U.S. Mint’s most accomplished sculptor-engravers — designed three of the four obverse portraits: Andrew Johnson, Ulysses S. Grant, and Rutherford B. Hayes.

Phebe Hemphill created the Garfield portrait, making the James Garfield dollar the only 2011 issue with a female designer. All four coins carry standardized obverse inscriptions: the president’s name, the years of their term, their numerical order in the presidency, and the motto “IN GOD WE TRUST,” which moved from the edge to the obverse beginning with the 2009 issues following public controversy over earlier “Godless Dollar” errors.

The Reverse Of The 2011 Presidential Dollar

The reverse of all Presidential Dollars features the Statue of Liberty — formally titled “Liberty Enlightening the World” — designed by sculptor-engraver Don Everhart. Liberty’s torch is raised triumphantly, and the denomination “$1” appears below, while “UNITED STATES OF AMERICA” encircles the design in the ITC Benguiat font.

This unified reverse design mirrors the approach used in the 50 State Quarters program, pairing a consistent shared design with the variety of obverse portraits. The Statue of Liberty reverse was designed to remain constant throughout the entire Presidential Dollar series, giving collectors an easy visual anchor for the program.

Other Features Of The 2011 Presidential Dollar

The 2011 Presidential Dollars measure 26.50 millimeters in diameter and weigh 8.10 grams. Their composition is manganese brass — a cladding of 77% copper, 12% zinc, 7% manganese, and 4% nickel over a pure copper core — chosen specifically to match the electromagnetic signature of the earlier Susan B. Anthony dollar for vending machine compatibility.

The manganese content is particularly important for collectors to understand: manganese reacts chemically with sulfur compounds found in air, cardboard, and PVC plastic. This reaction produces dark brown or black “carbon spots” — sometimes called flyspecks — on the coin’s surface. Because even a few small spots can drop a coin’s grade significantly, finding genuinely pristine MS67 or higher examples is far harder than the large mintage numbers suggest.

A unique feature of the series is edge lettering, which includes the year, the mint mark (P for Philadelphia, D for Denver, S for San Francisco), “E PLURIBUS UNUM,” and 13 stars. This technique — not used on circulating U.S. coins since the early 20th century — creates two natural position varieties.

Position A shows the edge inscription inverted when the obverse faces up; Position B shows it reading correctly. Neither is an error; both are normal production outcomes.

Also Read: Top 80+ Most Valuable Sacagawea Dollar Worth Money (2000-P to Present)

 

The Easy Way to Know Your 2011 Presidential Dollar Value

Determining your 2011 Presidential Dollar’s true value requires checking multiple factors — mint mark, Position A or B orientation, grade condition, and the specific president featured.

Rather than searching through price guides or visiting dealers, Coin Identifier and Value App instantly analyzes these elements in seconds. Simply snap a photo of your coin, and the app identifies its exact variety, current market value, and rarity status.

Whether you’ve inherited a collection or found coins in pocket change, you’ll know immediately if you’re holding a $1 circulation piece or a $575 MS69 Position A treasure. Fast, accurate valuations at your fingertips.

 

2011 Presidential Dollar Value Guides

The 2011 Presidential Dollar series represents the final year of mass circulation production before the program transitioned to collector-only mintage. Four presidents from America’s Reconstruction and Gilded Age were honored this year, each released quarterly throughout 2011.

Each presidential dollar was produced at multiple mint facilities. All four presidents received coins struck at Philadelphia (P) and Denver (D), plus proof coins at San Francisco (S). The San Francisco proof set mintage for 2011 was 299,853 sets — a relatively small number that makes well-preserved proof examples more collectible than their circulation counterparts.

Both P and D coins feature Position A and Position B edge lettering orientations, giving collectors up to 18 distinct base varieties across the 2011 series when proof coins are included.

• 2011 Andrew Johnson Presidential Dollar — Released February 17, 2011, honoring the 17th president (1865–1869), designed by Don Everhart
• 2011 Ulysses S. Grant Presidential Dollar — Released May 19, 2011, commemorating the 18th president (1869–1877), designed by Don Everhart
• 2011 Rutherford B. Hayes Presidential Dollar — Released August 18, 2011, honoring the 19th president (1877–1881), designed by Don Everhart
• 2011 James A. Garfield Presidential Dollar — Released November 17, 2011, representing the 20th president (1881), designed by Phebe Hemphill

Also Read: Top 100 Most Valuable Morgan Silver Dollar Coins Worth Money List

 

2011 Andrew Johnson Presidential Dollar Value

Andrew Johnson became the 17th president following Abraham Lincoln’s assassination on April 14, 1865, navigating the turbulent Reconstruction era through 1869. His presidency was defined by battles with a Radical Republican Congress that ultimately led to his impeachment — the first in U.S. history — though the Senate acquitted him by a single vote.

The 2011 dollar honoring Johnson was released on February 17, 2011, with a launch ceremony held at the Andrew Johnson National Historic Site in Greeneville, Tennessee. The Philadelphia Mint struck 35,560,000 pieces, while Denver produced 34,920,000 — a combined mintage exceeding 70 million that keeps circulated examples at face value.

The market transforms dramatically in premium grades. PCGS records show the 2011-P Andrew Johnson Position A MS68 sold for $130 at Heritage Auctions on December 27, 2016 — a documented auction result. Denver Position A examples in MS68 have reached $169 at auction. Position B variants in the same grades command significantly less: a Philadelphia Position B MS67 has sold for only $63.

San Francisco DCAM (Deep Cameo) proofs — designated “DCAM” because of their mirror-like fields contrasting with frosted designs — in PR70 grade typically trade around $34, with PR69 examples at $8–10. The large proof set mintage means San Francisco pieces are relatively accessible compared to top-grade business strikes.

Check the detailed auction records below to track how Andrew Johnson dollars have performed across different grades and varieties over time.

Market activity data shows the trading activity of this version.

 

2011 Ulysses S. Grant Presidential Dollar Value

Ulysses S. Grant served as the 18th President from 1869 to 1877, riding the wave of his celebrated command of Union forces in the Civil War. His presidency saw landmark achievements: Yellowstone became the first national park in 1872, and Congress passed the Equal Rights Act seeking equal treatment for African Americans in public accommodations. His administration also created the Department of Justice.

The 2011 Ulysses S. Grant Presidential Dollar was released on May 19, 2011. Combined Philadelphia and Denver mintages exceeded 76 million pieces, ensuring circulated examples remain at face value. Uncirculated P and D versions in MS65 are worth approximately $3–$7, depending on grading service and variety.

The grant proof coin market offers a more stable floor. A 2011-S DCAM proof in PR68 grade is worth around $5, and the series’ manganese brass composition — which chemically reacts with sulfur in storage materials — makes finding spot-free PR70 examples genuinely challenging.

A PR70 DCAM Grant dollar has reached $100 at auction, though such examples are rare. Both Philadelphia and Denver Grant Position A coins in MS69 have achieved top auction prices of $575, demonstrating the dramatic premium available at the peak of the grading scale.

The auction record charts for this coin visually demonstrate its historical price trends and market performance.

Meanwhile, the market activity data for this coin reflects the continued interest collectors have in this series.

 

2011 Rutherford B. Hayes Presidential Dollar Value

Rutherford B. Hayes created one of the most controversial moments in American political history: winning the presidency in 1876 by a single Electoral College vote while losing the national popular vote. This outcome was resolved by the Compromise of 1877, which effectively ended federal Reconstruction efforts in the South.

Hayes served as an Ohio governor three times and was wounded five times during the Civil War. He advocated for civil service reform and attempted to use executive power to stabilize the post-war nation. His wife, Lucy Hayes, was the first First Lady with a college degree — a fact that elevated her profile on the concurrent 2011 First Spouse gold bullion coin series.

Philadelphia struck 37,660,000 Hayes dollars and Denver produced 36,820,000, for a massive combined total of over 74 million. This high mintage suppresses appreciation for circulated and mid-grade examples. MS67 grade coins are priced around $15, while MS68 examples trade at approximately $65.

However, the top of the grading scale is a different story. A Philadelphia Hayes Position A MS69 reached $575 at a 2023 eBay auction — one of the highest realized prices in the entire 2011 series.

The San Francisco Mint produced 1,970,000 proof pieces; of these, only 1,255 were certified PR70 DCAM by grading services, establishing genuine rarity at the peak. A PR70 DCAM Hayes dollar reached $80 at an eBay auction in 2018 and currently trades around $35.

The auction record chart for this coin visually demonstrates its historical price trends and market performance.

The market activity data for this coin reflects collectors’ continued interest in this series.

 

2011 James A. Garfield Presidential Dollar Value

The 2011 James A. Garfield Presidential Dollar holds a special place in numismatic history: it is the 20th coin in the Presidential Dollar series and the last ever struck for general circulation. All subsequent Presidential Dollars from 2012 onward were designated “Not Intended for Circulation” (NIFC) and sold only through the U.S. Mint directly to collectors.

Garfield served only 200 days in office in 1881 before dying from complications following an assassination attempt, making his presidency the second shortest in American history. He was also the last U.S. president born in a log cabin, a distinction that speaks to his humble origins in Orange, Ohio. His portrait on the 2011 dollar was designed by Phebe Hemphill — the only female sculptor-engraver to contribute an obverse design in the 2011 series.

From actual market performance, P and D circulation strikes trade around $1 in circulated grades, while uncirculated MS examples are valued at approximately $14. San Francisco proof coins in PR69 DCAM are relatively common at $9–10, reflecting the accessible proof set mintage.

High-grade auction results reveal an interesting variety premium. A Denver Garfield MS68 Position B achieved a record of $270 at auction — considerably higher than the MS68 Position A maximum of $68. This reversal of the usual Position A premium for Garfield specifically suggests that the Denver Position B at the highest grades has a lower certified population, driving scarcity-based premiums.

The following chart shows the historical auction records and price trends for this coin.

Market activity data reflects the level of collector interest.

Also Read: 17 Rare Dollar Coin Errors List with Pictures (By Year)

 

Rare 2011 Presidential Dollar Error List

The 2011 Presidential Dollar series exhibits several distinctive edge lettering errors resulting from the separate edge inscription process. These manufacturing anomalies occurred when coins passed through high-speed edge lettering machinery at rates of up to 1,000 coins per minute.

Because the edge lettering was applied separately from the main strike, coins could pass through the inscribing equipment incorrectly — or be missed entirely. PCGS maintains specific catalog numbers for each recognized error type, and GreatCollections has sold certified examples of multiple 2011 error varieties at documented prices. The three most collectible error types from 2011 include weak, partial, and doubled overlap edge lettering variations.

1. Weak Edge Lettering

Weak edge lettering errors display faint or shallow inscriptions where portions of letters appear incomplete or barely visible on the coin’s edge. This defect occurs due to loosening components in the edge inscribing equipment or wear on edge segment dies, causing insufficient pressure during the lettering step.

The lettering appears ghost-like rather than deeply incused into the metal. PCGS catalogs this error for multiple 2011 president varieties, including the 2011-P Ulysses S. Grant Weak Edge Lettering Position A (PCGS #506660) and the 2011-D Rutherford B. Hayes Weak Edge Lettering Position B (PCGS #506667). This scarce error typically commands values around $50 in collectible grades, with finer certified examples bringing more at specialized auction houses.

2. Partial Edge Lettering

Partial edge lettering errors feature incomplete inscriptions where one or more sections of the edge text are entirely absent. Unlike weak edge lettering — where letters are faint but present — partial errors show clear gaps where the inscription simply does not exist.

These errors resulted from coins not fully engaging with the edge lettering mechanism during production. GreatCollections has auctioned certified examples of partial edge lettering errors for 2011 Hayes (PCGS MS-65, from the “#1 Ranked Mr. MEL Registry Set”) and the 2011-P James Garfield Partial Edge Lettering Position A (PCGS MS-65, Cert #34291094), documenting real market transactions for these varieties. Partial edge lettering dollars generally trade for approximately $30 in mid-grades, though exceptional examples with dramatic visual impact can bring considerably more.

3. Doubled Edge Lettering, Overlap

Doubled edge lettering overlap errors occur when coins accidentally pass through the edge lettering machinery twice, causing the second set of inscriptions to overlap the first. Because these coins should only display edge inscriptions once, doubled overlapped versions are desirable semi-major errors with strong collector interest.

A documented real-world example is the 2011-P Ulysses S. Grant Doubled Edge Lettering Overlap Position A graded PCGS MS-65 (Cert #34291093), which was sold by GreatCollections from the “#1 Ranked Mr. MEL Registry Set of Edge Lettering Errors.” PCGS also catalogs a 2011-P James A. Garfield Doubled Edge Lettering Overlap Position A variety (PCGS #506690).

Depending on date and grade, Presidential Dollar doubled overlap errors typically range from $20 to several hundred dollars at auction.

 

Where To Sell Your 2011 Presidential Dollar?

Armed with knowledge about your coin’s worth, you’re ready to explore selling options. I’ve assembled a comprehensive guide to trusted online marketplaces, detailing each platform’s features, benefits, and potential drawbacks.

Check out now: Best Places To Sell Coins Online (Pros & Cons) 

 

FAQ About The 2011 Presidential Dollar

1. How much is a 2011 Presidential Dollar worth in 2026?

Most 2011 Presidential Dollars in circulated condition are worth their face value of $1. This applies to all four president designs — Andrew Johnson, Ulysses S. Grant, Rutherford B. Hayes, and James Garfield — when found in pocket change or average condition.

Uncirculated examples in MS65 are worth roughly $3–$7. The highest certified grades (MS69) for Position A specimens have reached $575 at auction, and certain edge lettering error coins routinely trade for $30–$195 depending on type and grade.

2. Which 2011 Presidential Dollar is the most valuable?

The most valuable regular-issue 2011 Presidential Dollars are Position A specimens in MS69 grade — both the Philadelphia and Denver Grant and Hayes issues have achieved $575 at auction. For error coins, the Partial Edge Lettering Hayes in MS67 has sold for $195, while Doubled Overlap errors from GreatCollections have documented sale prices in the $50–$150 range.

In general, any 2011 Presidential Dollar graded MS68 or higher by PCGS or NGC (Professional Coin Grading Service or Numismatic Guaranty Company) holds real collector value, because so few survive at those condition levels due to manganese spotting.

3. Are 2011 Presidential Dollars rare?

As a group, 2011 Presidential Dollars are not rare — over 70 million of each president design were struck for circulation. However, conditional rarity is very real: finding a spot-free example in MS67 or higher is genuinely difficult because the coins’ manganese brass composition reacts chemically with air and storage materials to produce dark spots that lower grades.

Proof coins from San Francisco in PR70 DCAM are legitimately scarce, with the Hayes PR70 DCAM population at only 1,255 certified examples. Edge lettering error varieties are also scarce, with PCGS population counts in the dozens for some types.

4. What is the difference between Position A and Position B on 2011 Presidential Dollars?

Position A and Position B refer to how the edge lettering aligns relative to the coin’s faces. On a Position A coin, the edge inscription appears upside down when the obverse (heads side) faces up. On a Position B coin, the inscription reads correctly when the obverse faces up.

Neither is an error — both positions occur naturally during high-speed production. However, the collecting market has historically assigned a 30–90% premium to Position A coins in top grades, possibly because of earlier collector preference trends that became self-reinforcing through auction records.

5. Should I get my 2011 Presidential Dollar graded by PCGS or NGC?

Professional grading makes sense only if your coin is genuinely pristine. Submission fees to PCGS (Professional Coin Grading Service) or NGC (Numismatic Guaranty Company) typically start at $30–$50 per coin plus shipping. For a 2011 Presidential Dollar, grading is only worth the cost if the coin appears flawless under magnification — no spots, no scratches, no contact marks.

If your coin grades MS67 or higher, the graded value ($15–$575 depending on variety) justifies submission costs. Circulated coins, or any coin with visible spots, will not benefit from grading.

6. What is a DCAM proof coin, and how does it affect value?

DCAM stands for Deep Cameo, a designation applied to proof coins that display a dramatic two-tone appearance: mirror-like, highly reflective fields contrasting with frosty, frosted devices (the raised design elements). DCAM coins are the most desirable form of proof coins and command premiums over standard proof or Cameo proof designations.

For 2011-S Presidential Dollars, a PR70 DCAM can be worth $35–$100 depending on the president. Non-DCAM proof coins of the same grade are worth considerably less — often under $10.

7. Why do 2011 Presidential Dollars develop dark spots?

The dark spots — called carbon spots or flyspecks — that appear on Presidential Dollars result from the coins’ manganese brass composition. The 7% manganese content reacts with sulfur compounds found in air, cardboard coin tubes, and PVC plastic flips, producing dark brown or black discoloration.

Even tiny spots can drop a coin’s grade significantly, which is why MS67+ examples are genuinely hard to find despite large mintages. To protect your 2011 Presidential Dollars, store them in inert plastic holders (not cardboard tubes or PVC flips) at 40–50% relative humidity.

8. Was the 2011 Garfield dollar really the last Presidential Dollar made for circulation?

Yes. The 2011 James A. Garfield Presidential Dollar, released November 17, 2011, was the final Presidential Dollar coin distributed through Federal Reserve banks for general circulation. On December 13, 2011, Vice President Biden and Treasury Secretary Geithner announced that production for circulation would end, with the 2012 Chester Arthur dollar becoming the first “Not Intended for Circulation” (NIFC) issue.

This transition dramatically reduced mintages — from 35–70+ million per design in 2011 down to roughly 3–10 million per design from 2012 onward — making later NIFC issues scarcer, though not necessarily more valuable given limited collector demand.

9. What are the exact mintage numbers for each 2011 Presidential Dollar?

Official U.S. Mint production figures for 2011 Presidential Dollars are as follows: Andrew Johnson — 35,560,000 (Philadelphia) and 34,920,000 (Denver); Ulysses S. Grant — approximately 38,080,000 (Philadelphia) and 37,940,000 (Denver); Rutherford B. Hayes — 37,660,000 (Philadelphia) and 36,820,000 (Denver); James A. Garfield — approximately 37,100,000 (Philadelphia) and 37,100,000 (Denver).

The San Francisco proof set mintage for all four 2011 presidents was 299,853 sets, making proof coins meaningfully scarcer than circulation strikes even before considering the grade distribution at the top of the scale.

10. How do I spot a fake or altered 2011 Presidential Dollar edge lettering error?

The most important warning concerns “Missing Edge Lettering” errors. While genuine examples exist from earlier years in the series (2007–2008 saw the most documented cases), unscrupulous sellers have been known to file or grind off the edge lettering of common coins to create fake errors.

Always seek professional authentication from PCGS, NGC, or ANACS before paying a premium for any claimed edge lettering error. Genuine missing edge lettering errors will show no signs of tooling, filing, or abrasion on the edge surface.

The edge of a genuine error will appear smooth and as-struck — not scratched or artificially polished. Buying only authenticated, slabbed coins from reputable auction houses like Heritage Auctions or GreatCollections provides the best protection.