2011 Presidential Dollar Coin Value (Errors List, “P”, “D” & “S” Mint Mark Worth)

The 2011 Presidential Dollar series marked a fascinating chapter in American numismatics, featuring Andrew Johnson, Ulysses S. Grant, Rutherford B. Hayes, and James A. Garfield.

While these golden-hued coins circulated widely and most remain at face value, understanding the 2011 Presidential Dollar value requires looking beyond their common appearance.

Certain specimens, particularly those in pristine Mint State condition, can command premiums—with some examples reaching values between $6 and $9 depending on the president featured and the coin’s position variation.

Whether you’ve encountered these coins in everyday transactions or are evaluating pieces for a collection, knowing what separates a dollar coin from a collectible worth several times that amount can make all the difference.

 

2011 Presidential Dollar Value By Variety

The following chart breaks down how 2011 Presidential Dollar values fluctuate based on mint mark, position variety, and coin condition.

If you know the grade of your coin, you can find the exact price below in the Value Guides section.

Also Read: Presidential Dollars Value (2007 to Present)

 

Top 10 Most Valuable 2011 Presidential Dollar Worth Money

The most prominent feature in this chart is that Position A coins (with edge lettering inverted when the obverse faces up) are generally valued 30-90% higher than Position B coins. For example, Hayes President Position A MS69 reaches $575, while Position B MS68 is only $289. This edge lettering orientation difference is not a minting error but rather a normal production variation, yet the collecting market assigns significant premiums to Position A coins.

From MS68 to MS69, coin values can double or even more. Both Philadelphia and Denver minted Grant and Hayes Position A coins maintain the high price of $575, reflecting the extreme scarcity of MS69 grading. Currently, only dozens of these 2011 presidential coins exist at MS68 grade and above, which explains why top-tier grading can create such a significant value gap.

The “Partial Edge Lettering” Hayes error coin is valued at only $195. Although it is an error coin, because its grade is only MS67, its value is actually lower than top-grade normal coins, indicating that in the premium collecting market, grading weight has surpassed error coin premiums.

 

History Of The 2011 Presidential Dollar

The Presidential Dollar series, launched in 2007, aimed to honor deceased U.S. presidents while encouraging dollar coin circulation. In 2011, the program continued its chronological journey, featuring Andrew Johnson, Ulysses S. Grant, Rutherford B. Hayes, and James Garfield.

U.S. Mint sculptor-engravers brought these 19th-century presidents to life, with Don Everhart designing three portraits and Phebe Hemphill creating the Garfield design. However, beneath this artistic achievement, serious problems were mounting.

By mid-2011, the program’s fundamental flaw became undeniable: Americans rejected the coins. Federal Reserve inventories had swollen to over 1.2 billion unused dollars. The stockpile, if laid flat, could stretch from Los Angeles to Chicago.

This crisis demanded action. On December 13, 2011, the Obama Administration announced a dramatic policy shift during the post-recession recovery period. Vice President Biden and Treasury Secretary Geithner suspended production for circulation to reduce wasteful government spending.

Consequently, the 2011 James Garfield Dollar became the last Presidential coin released to the public. From 2012 forward, the series would serve collectors only, marking 2011 as the program’s pivotal transition year from ambitious circulation effort to numismatic-only status.

Also Read: Top 40+ Most Valuable Presidential Dollar Coins Worth Money

 

Is Your 2011 Presidential Dollar Rare?

Wondering if your 2011 Presidential dollars are valuable? Use CoinValueChecker App to instantly verify their rarity, Position type, and grade. Your pocket change could be worth $575—check yours now and discover hidden treasures!

 

Key Features Of The 2011 Presidential Dollar

Understanding the design elements of the 2011 Presidential Dollar helps collectors and enthusiasts appreciate both the artistic craftsmanship and historical significance of these coins. Each 2011 issue featured unique presidential portraits while maintaining consistent design standards across the series.

The Obverse Of The 2011 Presidential Dollar

Each 2011 Presidential Dollar Coin features a portrait of a president. The portraits of Andrew Johnson and Ulysses S. Grant were designed by Don Everhart.

A portrait of Rutherford B. Hayes appears on the third coin designed by Everhart. The portrait of James Garfield was uniquely designed and engraved by Phoebe Hemphill.

All four coins share common inscriptions encircling the portrait: the president’s name, the years of their term in office, a number indicating the order in which they served, and the motto “IN GOD WE TRUST.”

These standardized elements create visual continuity across the series while allowing each president’s individual legacy to shine through their distinct portrait.

The Reverse Of The 2011 Presidential Dollar

The reverse side features a common design across all Presidential Dollars: the iconic Statue of Liberty, formally known as Liberty Enlightening the World, designed by United States Mint Sculptor-Engraver Don Everhart.

This powerful symbol of American freedom appears in striking relief, with Liberty’s torch raised triumphantly skyward. Below the statue, the denomination “$1” is prominently displayed, while the inscription “UNITED STATES OF AMERICA” encircles the design in capital letters using the ITC Benguiat font.

The unified reverse design serves as a visual anchor for the entire Presidential Dollar series, ensuring instant recognition while allowing the obverse to celebrate individual presidents.

This approach mirrors the successful 50 State Quarters program, where a common obverse paired with varying reverses.

Other Features Of The 2011 Presidential Dollar

The 2011 Presidential Dollars measure 26.50 millimeters in diameter and weigh 8.10 grams. The coins feature a distinctive composition of 77% copper, 12% zinc, and 1% other metals over a pure copper core, giving them their characteristic golden color.

A unique feature distinguishing these coins from most modern U.S. currency is their edge lettering, which includes the year of minting, the mint mark (P for Philadelphia, D for Denver, or S for San Francisco), “E PLURIBUS UNUM,” and 13 stars representing the original colonies.

This edge inscription technique, rarely used on U.S. coins since the 19th century, was initially controversial as it placed “IN GOD WE TRUST” on the edge rather than the obverse. However, following public pressure, this motto was moved to the obverse beginning in 2009.

The edge lettering can appear in two positions: Position A, where the inscription reads correctly when the obverse faces down, and Position B, where it reads correctly when the reverse faces down.

Also Read: Top 80+ Most Valuable Sacagawea Dollar Worth Money (2000-P to Present)

 

The Easy Way to Know Your 2011 Presidential Dollar Value

Determining your 2011 Presidential Dollar’s true value requires checking multiple factors—mint mark, Position A or B orientation, grade condition, and specific president.

Rather than searching through price guides or visiting dealers, CoinValueChecker App instantly analyzes these elements in seconds. Simply snap a photo of your coin, and the app identifies its exact variety, current market value, and rarity status.

Whether you’ve inherited a collection or found coins in pocket change, you’ll know immediately if you’re holding a $1 circulation piece or a $575 MS69 Position A treasure. Fast, accurate valuations at your fingertips.

 

2011 Presidential Dollar Value Guides

The 2011 Presidential Dollar series represents the final year of mass circulation production before the program transitioned to collector-only mintage. Four presidents from America’s Reconstruction and Gilded Age were honored this year, each released quarterly throughout 2011.

Each presidential dollar was produced at multiple mint facilities. All four presidents received coins minted at Philadelphia (P), Denver (D), and as proof coins at San Francisco (S).

Collectors can find distinct varieties distinguished by mint marks and edge lettering positions. Both P and D coins feature Position A and Position B edge lettering orientations, where Position A shows the lettering upside down when the obverse faces up, while Position B displays it correctly.

• 2011 Andrew Johnson Presidential Dollar – Released February 17, 2011, honoring the 17th president (1865-1869), designed by Don Everhart
• 2011 Ulysses S. Grant Presidential Dollar – Released May 19, 2011, commemorating the 18th president (1869-1877), designed by Don Everhart
• 2011 Rutherford B. Hayes Presidential Dollar – Released August 18, 2011, honoring the 19th president (1877-1881), designed by Don Everhart
• 2011 James A. Garfield Presidential Dollar – Released November 17, 2011, representing the 20th president (1881), uniquely designed by Phebe Hemphill

Also Read: Top 100 Most Valuable Morgan Silver Dollar Coins Worth Money List

 

2011 Andrew Johnson Presidential Dollar Value

Andrew Johnson became the 17th president following Lincoln’s assassination in 1865, navigating the tumultuous Reconstruction era through 1869.

The 2011 dollar honoring Johnson was released on February 17, 2011, with a launch ceremony at the Andrew Johnson National Historic Site in Greeneville, Tennessee.

With a combined mintage exceeding 72 million pieces, circulated examples trade at face value. The market transforms dramatically in premium grades, where MS67-MS68 represents the practical ceiling for collectors.

Denver Position A coins in MS68 have reached $169 at auction, while Philadelphia Position A examples achieved $130. Position B variants command significantly less—a Philadelphia MS67 brought only $63, demonstrating how edge lettering orientation impacts value.

San Francisco DCAM proofs in PR70 typically trade around $34, with PR69 examples at $8-10. Denver strikes often outperform Philadelphia counterparts in top grades due to superior strike quality and lower census populations.

Check the detailed auction records below to track how Andrew Johnson dollars have performed across different grades and varieties over time.

Market activity data shows the trading activity of this version.

 

2011 Ulysses S. Grant Presidential Dollar Value

The 2011 Ulysses S. Grant Presidential Dollar Coin commemorates the 18th President of the United States, a symbol of the Union Army’s victory in the Civil War.

The obverse of the coin features Grant’s iconic mustache and resolute expression, capturing his leadership qualities on the battlefield and in the White House. During his presidency, Yellowstone became the first national park in the United States, and Congress passed the Equal Pay Act for men and women in federal agencies.

This historical significance has not directly translated into collectible value. Circulated coins are worth only their face value of $1, while uncirculated P and D versions are worth approximately $3.40 at an MS 65 grade. Some grading agencies value them at over $7, but the overall premium is limited.

In contrast, the proof coin market is more stable. A 2011-S proof coin minted in San Francisco is worth approximately $5 at a PR 68 grade. Deep Cameo versions are sought after by collectors for their mirror-like finish; a PR70 grade coin reached $100 at an eBay auction in 2029.

The auction record charts for this coin visually demonstrate its historical price trends and market performance.

Meanwhile, the market activity data for this coin reflects the continued interest collectors have in this series.

 

2011 Rutherford B. Hayes Presidential Dollar Value

Rutherford B. Hayes created a controversial moment in American political history in 1876—winning the presidency by a single Electoral College vote while losing the national popular vote.

This general who was wounded five times in the Civil War later served three terms as Ohio’s governor. He advocated for civil service reform and racial equality, attempting to stabilize the nation during the post-war Reconstruction period. The 2011 Hayes Presidential Dollar commemorates this history.

The Philadelphia mint produced 37.66 million pieces, and the Denver mint 36.82 million, with this massive population suppressing appreciation potential. MS67 grade coins are priced at just $15, MS68 around $65. However, high-grade coins perform reasonably well, with a Philadelphia MS69 reaching $575 at a 2023 eBay auction.

The proof coin market shows slight differences. The San Francisco mint produced 1.97 million pieces, with only 1,255 PR70 DCAM coins, which had an auction record of $80 on eBay in 2018 and currently trade around $35.

The auction record chart for this coin visually demonstrates its historical price trends and market performance.

The market activity data for this coin reflects collectors’ continued interest in this series.

 

2011 James A. Garfield Presidential Dollar Value

The 2011 Garfield Presidential Dollar represents the 20th design in the series and marks the final circulation-release Presidential coin. All subsequent Presidential dollars were produced exclusively for collectors.

Garfield served only 200 days in office in 1881 before his assassination, making him the second U.S. president to be assassinated—this brief and tragic tenure adds profound historical significance to the coin.

From actual market performance, P and D circulation strikes trade around $1, while uncirculated MS+ grades are valued at approximately $14. S mint PR69 DCAM proofs are relatively common at $9-10. Only top-graded specimens command substantial premiums.

High-grade auction records demonstrate the impact of varieties. A D mint MS68 Position B achieved the highest record of $270. By comparison, MS68 Position A specimens have reached a maximum of $68. This disparity reflects the scarcity of specific variety combinations.

The following chart shows the historical auction records and price trends for this coin.

Market activity data reflects the level of collector interest.

Also Read: 17 Rare Dollar Coin Errors List with Pictures (By Year)

 

Rare 2011 Presidential Dollar Error List

The 2011 Presidential Dollar series exhibits several distinctive edge lettering errors resulting from the separate edge inscription process.

These manufacturing anomalies occurred when coins passed through high-speed edge lettering machinery at rates up to 1,000 per minute. The three most collectible error types from 2011 include weak, partial, and doubled overlap edge lettering variations.

1. Weak Edge Lettering

Weak edge lettering errors display faint or shallow inscriptions where portions of letters appear incomplete or barely visible on the coin’s edge. This defect occurs due to loosening components in the edge inscribing equipment or wear on edge segment dies.

The lettering appears ghost-like rather than deeply incused into the metal. This scarce error typically commands values around $50 in collectible grades.

A notable example includes the 2011-P Ulysses S. Grant Weak Edge Lettering Position B graded PCGS MS-67, which represents one of the finest known specimens.

2. Partial Edge Lettering

Partial edge lettering errors feature incomplete inscriptions with one or more letters completely missing from the edge. Unlike weak edge lettering where letters are faint, partial errors show clear gaps where portions of the inscription simply don’t exist.

These errors resulted from coins not fully engaging with the edge lettering mechanism during production. Partial edge lettering dollars generally trade for approximately $30 in the marketplace.

The 2008-D James Monroe Partial Edge Lettering Position B in PCGS MS-67 demonstrated that exceptional preservation can enhance values significantly. Collectors particularly seek examples where the missing portion creates dramatic visual impact.

3. Doubled Edge Lettering, Overlap

Doubled edge lettering overlap errors occur when coins accidentally pass through the edge lettering machinery twice, causing the second set of inscriptions to overlap the first in the same orientation.

These coins should only display edge inscriptions once, making doubled overlapped versions desirable semi-major errors. Depending on date and grade, Presidential Dollar doubled overlap errors typically range from $20 to several hundred dollars.

A documented example is the 2011-P Ulysses S. Grant Doubled Edge Lettering Overlap Position A graded PCGS MS-65, which appeared in specialized error coin auctions.

 

Where To Sell Your 2011 Presidential Dollar?

Armed with knowledge about your coin’s worth, you’re ready to explore selling options. I’ve assembled a comprehensive guide to trusted online marketplaces, detailing each platform’s features, benefits, and potential drawbacks.

Check out now: Best Places To Sell Coins Online (Pros & Cons) 

 

FAQ About The 2011 Presidential Dollar         

1. How much are 2011 Presidential Dollars worth?

Most 2011 Presidential Dollars in circulated condition are worth face value ($1). This includes coins featuring Andrew Johnson, Ulysses S. Grant, Rutherford B. Hayes, and James Garfield.

Uncirculated specimens may fetch $2-5 from collectors. Error coins or special mint versions can be worth significantly more, ranging from $50 to several hundred dollars depending on rarity and condition.

2.  Which 2011 Presidential Dollar is the most valuable?

Error coins command the highest premiums. Missing edge lettering errors can sell for $50-150. Double strikes or off-center strikes may reach $200-500 depending on severity.

Among regular strikes, pristine MS67 or higher grades are most valuable at $20-50 each. The James Garfield dollar slightly edges others in collector demand due to his historical significance.

3. Are 2011 Presidential Dollars rare?

No, 2011 Presidential Dollars are not rare. Millions were minted for each president. Production ended for circulation in 2011, but coins remained widely available through banks and collectors.

Their abundance keeps values low. However, specific errors, high-grade specimens, or proof versions from San Francisco Mint are scarcer and hold premium values among serious numismatists.

4. Should I collect 2011 Presidential Dollars?

Collecting 2011 Presidential Dollars is affordable and educational. Complete sets of all four presidents cost $10-20 in uncirculated condition, making them accessible for beginners.

Focus on high-grade uncirculated or proof specimens for investment potential. Error coins offer the best appreciation prospects. However, don’t expect dramatic value increases given their high mintage numbers.