2009 Presidential Dollar Value Checker: Errors List, “D”, “S” & “P” Mint Mark Worth

2009 Missing Edge W. H. Harrison SP value ranges from $1.00 face value to $1,955. That record was set by a Grade 69 example sold at Heritage Auctions in December 2010. If you think yours might be a missing edge variety, upload a photo below and we’ll help you get a quick value range. You can also scroll down to check recent eBay sales and see what these are going for today.

 

2009 Presidential Dollar Value By Variety

Here’s what 2009 Presidential Dollars are worth for Harrison, Tyler, Polk, and Taylor across P, D, and S mint marks from Good through Proof grades.

If you know the grade of your coin, you can find the exact price below in the Value Guides section.

Also Read: Presidential Dollars Value (2007 to Present)

 

Top 10 Most Valuable 2009 Presidential Dollar Value Worth Money

The king of the 2009 series is a Harrison Satin Finish Missing Edge Lettering error graded SP69. It brought $1,955 at Heritage Auctions on December 2, 2010. Everything had to go right — the coin skipped the edge lettering machine, survived without carbon spots, and came from a tiny Satin Finish mintage. That’s a perfect storm for value.

Standard business strike Harrison dollars in MS68 hit $1,840 at Heritage Auctions in December 2010. That number has come down since then as more slabbed examples entered the market. You see this pattern across the whole Presidential Dollar series — early auction records tower over current guide values because the population was still small when bidding wars happened.

MS67 is where the real money starts. PCGS population reports show MS67+ coins make up less than 1% of all certified submissions for most 2009 issues. That makes them legit condition rarities even though tens of millions were originally struck.

Take the John Tyler Philadelphia Position A in MS67. It once sold for $1,150 at auction. As more got certified, the PCGS value dropped to around $225. But bump up one grade point to MS68 and PCGS pegs it at $900. One grade, huge gap.

Proof coins with the Deep Cameo (DCAM) designation — heavy white frost on the portrait against deeply mirrored fields — hold steady collector demand. Most 2009 proof Presidential Dollars grade PR68-PR69 DCAM. PR70 DCAM examples exist but are tougher to find.

First Day of Issue (FDI) labels add real money for registry set collectors. The 2009-P John Tyler First Day Position B MS67 hit $1,900 at auction. That label proves the coin was submitted to PCGS by the official release date, and registry set builders pay up for it.

Satin Finish coins are a completely different kind of rare. They came exclusively through U.S. Mint sets and have a matte-like texture you won’t confuse with business strikes or proofs. Grading services treat them as a separate variety, and they carry their own premiums.

 

History of the 2009 Presidential Dollar Value Program

The 2009 series was year three of the Presidential Dollar Coin Program, created by the Presidential $1 Coin Act of 2005 (Public Law 109-145). President George W. Bush signed it on December 22, 2005. The idea was simple: honor deceased presidents on circulating dollar coins, four new designs per year, in order of service.

Congress hoped to repeat the magic of the 50 State Quarters Program (1999–2008). It didn’t work. The public mostly ignored Presidential Dollars, and the coins piled up in Federal Reserve vaults instead of cash registers.

The four 2009 presidents were William Henry Harrison (9th, 1841), John Tyler (10th, 1841–1845), James K. Polk (11th, 1845–1849), and Zachary Taylor (12th, 1849–1850). Each rolled out on a staggered schedule: Harrison on February 19, 2009; Tyler on May 21, 2009; Polk on August 20, 2009; and Taylor on November 19, 2009.

Here’s the big deal for 2009: the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2008 forced “IN GOD WE TRUST” off the edge and onto the obverse. That change kicked in with the very first Harrison release and killed the controversial “Godless Dollar” era from 2007–2008 for good. Fun fact — Harrison’s 31-day presidency makes him the shortest-serving president on any U.S. coin.

The 2008–2009 recession also hammered mintage numbers. The Federal Reserve wasn’t ordering dollar coins, so production dropped well below the 100-million-plus runs of 2007–2008. Lower supply plus the fact that most 2009 dollars never circulated — they sat in vaults or went straight to collectors — shapes the survival picture you’re dealing with today.

Also Read: Top 40+ Most Valuable Presidential Dollar Coins Worth Money

 

Is Your 2009 Presidential Dollar Value Rare?

Discover the true rarity of your Presidential Dollars — check precise rarity rankings and valuations instantly with Coin Identifier and Value App to know exactly where your coins stand among collectors.

 

Key Features of the 2009 Presidential Dollar Value Series

2009 is a pivotal year in the Presidential Dollar series. The motto moved to the obverse, and that design change stuck for every issue after it. Knowing the key features helps you figure out which surface type and variety you’re holding.

The four presidents cover a wild stretch of the 1840s: William Henry Harrison (9th), John Tyler (10th), James K. Polk (11th), and Zachary Taylor (12th). Two of them died in office. All four served during one of the most turbulent decades in American history.

The Obverse of the 2009 Presidential Dollar

Each obverse shows a portrait based on official White House portraits, intaglio prints, and historical medal designs. What makes 2009 stand out: every single coin was done by a different Mint artist.

The Harrison dollar was sculpted and designed by Joseph Menna. The Tyler portrait is by Phebe Hemphill. The Polk coin was designed by Susan Gamble and sculpted by Charles Vickers. The Taylor dollar is by Don Everhart.

Look at the layout. The president’s name arches above the portrait, with the presidential number and service dates below — “9th PRESIDENT 1841” for Harrison, “11th PRESIDENT 1845–1849” for Polk. The big change? “IN GOD WE TRUST” sits right on the obverse, lower left of the portrait. That’s what separates every 2009 coin from the 2007–2008 issues at a glance.

That move shut down the “Godless Dollar” controversy for good. Missing edge lettering errors still happen on 2009 coins, but since the motto is already on the face, they’re a different animal than the earlier errors.

The Reverse of the 2009 Presidential Dollar

Flip it over and you’ll see the same reverse used on every Presidential Dollar in the series. It’s an upward-looking view of the Statue of Liberty sculpted by Don Everhart. Lady Liberty’s torch arm is the focal point, with “$1” placed beneath it.

“UNITED STATES OF AMERICA” runs around the outer rim in ITC Benguiat font. Look closely and you’ll spot the initials “TDR” for Thomas D. Rogers — most people miss them entirely.

Other Features of the 2009 Presidential Dollar: Surface Types and Composition

You’ve got three distinct surface types to know about. Business strikes (P and D) have normal luster. Satin Finish coins from Mint sets show a soft, matte-like texture that grading services treat as a separate variety. Proofs (S mint mark) from San Francisco get the Deep Cameo (DCAM) treatment — heavy white frost on the portrait against deeply mirrored fields. They’re the most eye-catching of the three.

All three types share the same composition: a pure copper core clad by manganese brass. The breakdown is 88.5% copper, 6% zinc, 3.5% manganese, and 2% nickel. That 7% manganese content in the cladding is the enemy. Manganese reacts with sulfur in air, cardboard, and storage materials, causing carbon spots and flyspecks. One tiny spot can knock an otherwise perfect coin from MS67 down to MS65. I’ve seen it happen more times than I can count.

Specs: weight 8.1 grams, diameter 26.5 millimeters, thickness 2 millimeters. The golden color comes from the manganese brass cladding — it was designed to make the dollar coin visually distinct from quarters and other denominations.

Also Read: Top 80+ Most Valuable Sacagawea Dollar Worth Money (2000-P to Present)

 

The Easy Way to Know Your 2009 Presidential Dollar Value

Start with condition. If you see wear on the portrait or high points, you’re looking at face value. An MS67 or higher grade is where premiums kick in.

Next, grab a loupe and check the edge. Look for the mint mark (P or D) and “E PLURIBUS UNUM.” Note the lettering orientation — Position A reads upside-down when the portrait faces up, Position B reads right-side up.

Completely smooth edge with nothing on it? Measure the diameter. It must be exactly 26.5mm. If it checks out, you might have a missing edge lettering error worth several hundred dollars.

For the fastest and most accurate evaluation, use the Coin Identifier and Value App — simply photograph your coin to receive professional-grade valuation, error detection, and current market data in seconds.

 

2009 Presidential Dollar Value Guides By Mint and Grade

• 2009 William Henry Harrison Presidential Dollar — The 9th President, known for the shortest presidency in U.S. history at just 31 days; Philadelphia mintage: 43,260,000
• 2009 John Tyler Presidential Dollar — The 10th President, featuring Position A and Position B edge lettering varieties; Philadelphia and Denver mintage: 43,540,000 each
• 2009 James K. Polk Presidential Dollar — The 11th President with the highest 2009 mintage at 46,620,000 (Philadelphia); Denver produced 41,720,000
• 2009 Zachary Taylor Presidential Dollar — The 12th President, who died in office in 1850; a popular choice among collectors for its historical narrative

All four were struck at Philadelphia (P) and Denver (D) for circulation, with San Francisco (S) handling proof editions. The San Francisco Harrison proof mintage of 2,809,452 was the lowest output of the three finish types.

Circulated examples sit at face value. Uncirculated coins, high-grade proofs, Satin Finish varieties, and errors are where the premiums live.

Also Read: Top 100 Most Valuable Morgan Silver Dollar Coins Worth Money List

 

2009 Presidential Dollar Value: William Henry Harrison

Harrison gave the longest inauguration speech in history and then died 31 days later. That’s the kind of trivia that makes this coin a conversation starter. It hit circulation on February 19, 2009, and coins submitted to PCGS on or before that date got the First Day of Issue label.

Philadelphia struck 43,260,000 business strike Harrison dollars, with Denver producing a large run as well. San Francisco turned out 2,809,452 proof coins in Deep Cameo (DCAM) quality for the 2009 Presidential $1 Coin Proof Set.

Most mint state examples trade for $4 to $5. MS67 is where things get interesting — less than 1% of certified submissions reach that level per PCGS population reports. The auction record for a standard business strike Harrison is $1,840 at Heritage Auctions on December 2, 2010, set by an MS68. That’s an exceptional grade for manganese brass.

Edge lettering splits Harrison coins into two varieties. Position A reads upside-down when the portrait faces up. Position B reads right-side up. The orientation is random during production, and both PCGS and NGC recognize them as separate collectibles.

The Auction Record Chart below shows how these coins have performed at public sales across grades and varieties since release.

Current Market Activity data shows ongoing collector interest and trading patterns for this issue.

 

2009 Presidential Dollar Value: John Tyler

Did you know Tyler’s political opponents called him “His Accidency”? He took over after Harrison’s death in 1841, served until 1845, and his coin entered circulation on May 21, 2009.

Philadelphia and Denver each struck 43,540,000 Tyler business strikes — slightly more than Harrison. The Tyler dollar has one of the best-documented price drops in the series. An MS67 Position A sold for $1,150 early on. As more coins got slabbed, PCGS dropped the value to around $225. The top-graded MS68 still carries a PCGS value of $900, though. One grade point makes a huge difference.

Circulated Tylers are worth face value. MS60–MS66 examples run $3 to $25. At MS67 and above, you’re looking at $225 or more. Missing edge lettering errors add serious money on top of that.

Market activity stays steady among dedicated Presidential Dollar collectors building complete certified sets by president and mint mark.

 

2009 Presidential Dollar Value: James K. Polk

Polk has the highest mintage of any 2009 president, yet MS67+ examples are just as scarce as the others. That’s the manganese brass paradox — big mintage means nothing when carbon spots wipe out high-grade survivors. The coin was released on August 20, 2009, with a portrait designed by Susan Gamble and sculpted by Charles Vickers.

The numbers: Philadelphia struck 46,620,000 and Denver produced 41,720,000 business strikes. PCGS population data confirms fewer than 1% of submitted examples hit MS67 or better. San Francisco made over 2.8 million proof coins in Deep Cameo quality. Per PCGS CoinFacts, those proofs “came in really nice quality from Proof Sets ranging anywhere from about PR67–PR69 Deep Cameo on average.” PR70 DCAM examples are tougher but available.

Here’s a cherrypicking tip: at MS67, Philadelphia Position B examples bring around $70 versus $25 for Position A. Edge orientation actually matters at high grades. Proof Polk dollars start at face value in PR60, climb to $3 at PR63, $4 at PR65, $5 at PR68, and around $35 for a flawless PR70.

Collector interest remains solid for those chasing complete Presidential Dollar sets and top-pop certified examples.

 

2009 Presidential Dollar Value: Zachary Taylor

Taylor was a war hero who won the presidency and then died 16 months into the job on July 9, 1850. His coin was the last 2009 release, entering circulation on November 19, 2009, with a portrait by Don Everhart.

You’ll find three mint versions: Philadelphia (P) and Denver (D) business strikes, plus San Francisco (S) Deep Cameo proofs. Both Position A and Position B edge lettering exist, and Satin Finish examples came through the annual Mint set.

Standard circulated Taylor dollars are worth a buck. Uncirculated examples run $2 to $5 in typical grades. The big jumps come with errors — missing edge lettering Taylors have brought several hundred dollars at auction. An MS67 Moy Signature example, signed by then-Mint Director Edmund C. Moy, adds even more through that special provenance.

Collector interest stays strong for Taylor dollars, especially error varieties and high-grade certified pieces.

Also Read: 17 Rare Dollar Coin Errors List with Pictures (By Year)

 

Rare 2009 Presidential Dollar Value Error List

Most 2009 Presidential Dollar errors trace back to one thing: the separate edge lettering step. The obverse and reverse get struck first, then the coin goes through a Schuler edge lettering machine. When that machine hiccups, you get errors.

One thing to keep straight: since “IN GOD WE TRUST” moved to the obverse starting in 2009, these coins technically can’t be “Godless Dollars.” But collectors still use the nickname loosely for missing-edge errors across all years.

1. 2009 Missing Edge Lettering Error

This is the big one. The coin completely skips the Schuler machine, leaving a perfectly smooth edge — no date, no mint mark, no “E PLURIBUS UNUM.” Check the diameter first: it must be exactly 26.5mm. Anything smaller might be a filed coin, which is worthless as an error.

PCGS has certified Harrison missing edge lettering errors from MS63 up. Lower-grade MS63 examples start around $30. MS67+ pieces can reach $200.

The finest known Harrison business strike Missing Edge example in MS69 sold for $456 at auction in 2019, then resold for $1,250 in 2022. That’s a 174% gain in three years. Top-grade 2009 errors are getting harder to find.

A special sub-variety called the Moy Signature variety exists — these are missing edge lettering coins hand-signed by then-U.S. Mint Director Edmund C. Moy and certified by PCGS. They get their own PCGS catalog number and carry a premium over unsigned examples.

The all-time record holder is the Harrison Satin Finish SP69, which brought $1,955 at Heritage Auctions on December 2, 2010. The Satin Finish version is rarer than the business strike because only 784,614 satin coins were made through the Mint set. That’s a tiny fraction of the 43 million business strikes.

2. 2009 Doubled Edge Lettering (Slipped Edge Lettering) Error

This happens when a coin runs through the edge lettering machine twice. Variety researcher Ken Potter documented two distinct subtypes: the Overlapped type shows a second set of lettering partially on top of the first. The Inverted type (double-struck inverted) shows two full sets of lettering running in opposite directions — one upright, one upside-down.

These typically sell for $30 and up in average grades. Higher-grade slabbed examples bring significantly more. For context, the 2007-P John Adams doubled edge lettering in MS67 has sold for over $3,000. The 2009 versions are rarer and could hit comparable numbers in top grades as more collectors chase them.

3. 2009 Obverse Die Scraped Error

A die scrape happens when debris — metal shavings, grit, whatever — drags across the die surface during production. That creates raised irregular lines or dotted patterns on the struck coin. Don’t confuse these with die cracks. Cracks follow the design contours. Scrapes cut across the design at random angles.

Every die scrape is unique in shape and position. The ones near the presidential portrait get the most attention from error collectors. If you spot raised dotted or curved lines crossing Harrison’s, Tyler’s, Polk’s, or Taylor’s face at odd angles, you might have something worth a closer look.

 

Where to Sell Your 2009 Presidential Dollar Value?

Whether you choose reputable coin dealers, major online auction platforms like Heritage Auctions or Stack’s Bowers, or specialized numismatic marketplaces, always have your 2009 Presidential Dollar authenticated and graded by a trusted third-party service — PCGS, NGC, or ANACS — before selling. Professional certification protects both buyer and seller, establishes value, and can significantly increase the price you achieve for higher-grade or error examples.

Check out now: Best Places To Sell Coins Online (Pros & Cons)

 

FAQ About the 2009 Presidential Dollar Value

1. Are 2009 Presidential Dollars made of real gold?

No. They’re manganese brass over a copper core — 88.5% copper, 6% zinc, 3.5% manganese, and 2% nickel. The golden color is just the cladding doing its job.

2. Why do some people call early Presidential Dollars “Godless Dollars”?

In 2007–2008, “IN GOD WE TRUST” was on the edge. Tens of thousands of coins skipped the edge lettering step entirely, so the motto was completely missing. Starting in 2009, the motto moved to the obverse. Missing edge lettering errors still exist on 2009 coins, but they’re not technically “godless” since the motto is right there on the face.

3. What is the difference between Position A and Position B on 2009 Presidential Dollars?

Hold the coin with the portrait facing up. If the edge lettering reads upside-down, that’s Position A. If it reads right-side up, that’s Position B. It’s random during production, and both PCGS and NGC list them as separate varieties. At lower grades, position barely affects value. At MS67+, it can matter.

4. What is a Satin Finish 2009 Presidential Dollar, and is it more valuable?

Satin Finish coins came exclusively in U.S. Mint sets from 2005–2010. They have a soft, matte-like look — totally different from business strike luster or proof mirrors. The 2009 Harrison Satin Finish mintage was only 784,614 versus 43 million business strikes. That scarcity drives higher premiums, especially in top grades or with errors.

5. What is the Moy Signature variety on 2009 Presidential Dollar errors?

These are missing edge lettering errors personally hand-signed by Edmund C. Moy, U.S. Mint Director from 2006 to 2011. PCGS gives them their own catalog number. The signature adds provenance and collector appeal, so they trade at a premium over unsigned examples of the same error and grade.

6. Why are MS67 and higher grades so rare for 2009 Presidential Dollars?

Blame the manganese. That 7% manganese content reacts with sulfur in air, cardboard, and PVC holders, creating carbon spots and flyspecks. One small spot can drop a coin from MS68 to MS65. PCGS population reports show MS67+ specimens make up less than 1% of all certified 2009 submissions. We’re talking about tens of millions minted, but almost none surviving spot-free at the top grades.

7. What is the highest auction price ever paid for a 2009 Presidential Dollar?

$1,955 — a Harrison Missing Edge Lettering Satin Finish graded SP69, sold at Heritage Auctions on December 2, 2010. For standard business strikes, the record is $1,840 for a Harrison MS68 at the same sale.

8. Does a First Day of Issue label increase the value of a 2009 Presidential Dollar?

Yes. PCGS awards the FDI label to coins submitted on or before the official release date (February 19, 2009 for Harrison, for example). In high grades, the premium is real. The 2009-P John Tyler First Day Position B MS67 hit $1,900 at auction. Registry set collectors pay up for that label.

9. How do I check if my 2009 Presidential Dollar has a missing edge lettering error?

Three steps. First, examine the edge with a loupe — a genuine error has a completely smooth edge with no lettering at all. Second, measure the diameter: exactly 26.5mm. A smaller coin may have been filed down, which is an alteration worth nothing. Third, weigh it: 8.1 grams on an accurate scale. If all three check out, get it authenticated by PCGS, NGC, or ANACS before buying or selling. Counterfeits do exist.

10. Is it worth having my 2009 Presidential Dollar professionally graded?

For a standard circulated dollar worth $1? No — the grading fee alone runs $20–$40. But it makes total sense if you have a coin that looks MS67 or higher, a suspected error (especially missing or doubled edge lettering), a Satin Finish in great shape, or anything you plan to sell for over $50. A PCGS or NGC slab authenticates the coin, locks in the grade, and makes it far easier to sell at full market price.