2009 Presidential Dollar Value (2026 Guide): Errors List, “D”, “S” & “P” Mint Mark Worth

Understanding your 2009 Presidential Dollar Value is essential whether you found these golden coins in an old jar, received them as a gift, or are building a serious collection.

Most circulated 2009 Presidential Dollars honoring William Henry Harrison, John Tyler, James K. Polk, and Zachary Taylor are worth their face value of $1. However, high-grade uncirculated examples, Deep Cameo (DCAM) proofs, Satin Finish coins from mint sets, and error varieties can reach from $33 to $1,955 depending on the coin.

This guide covers exact mintage figures, real auction records with dates and auction house names, PCGS and NGC population data, surface type designations, and a full breakdown of every known error variety — so you can confidently identify what you have and what it’s worth in today’s market.

 

2009 Presidential Dollar Value By Variety

This chart shows the values of 2009 Presidential Dollar coins for William Henry Harrison, John Tyler, James K. Polk, and Zachary Taylor across different mint marks (P, D, S) and condition grades (Good through Proof).

If you know the grade of your coin, you can find the exact price below in the Value Guides section.

Also Read: Presidential Dollars Value (2007 to Present)

 

Top 10 Most Valuable 2009 Presidential Dollar Value Worth Money

The 2009 Presidential Dollar series shows dramatic value differences based on grade, surface type, and error status. The absolute top of the market belongs to the William Henry Harrison Satin Finish Missing Edge Lettering error graded SP69, which realized $1,955 at Heritage Auctions on December 2, 2010.

Standard business strike Harrison dollars in MS68 condition achieved $1,840 at Heritage Auctions in December 2010, setting a benchmark that has since declined as more certified examples entered the market. This pattern — where early auction records far exceed current PCGS price guide values — is typical of the Presidential Dollar series as a whole.

The MS67 grade is the critical threshold where 2009 Presidential Dollars begin to generate meaningful premiums above face value. According to PCGS population reports, MS67+ specimens represent less than 1% of all certified submissions for most issues in this series, making them genuine condition rarities despite the large original mintages.

The John Tyler dollar from Philadelphia in MS67 Position A once sold for $1,150 at auction; as more examples were certified, the PCGS value settled to approximately $225. The current top-graded Tyler MS68 is valued by PCGS at $900, demonstrating how a single grade point can represent a dramatic premium in modern coins.

Proof coins with the Deep Cameo (DCAM) designation — meaning heavy white frosting on the portrait devices contrasted against deeply mirrored background fields — maintain steady collector demand. PCGS notes that 2009 proof Presidential Dollars most commonly grade PR68-PR69 DCAM, while PR70 DCAM examples are harder to find but exist in quantities sufficient to meet collector demand.

First Day of Issue (FDI) designations, awarded to coins submitted to PCGS by the official release date of each coin, add a premium by establishing provenance and early strike quality. The 2009-P John Tyler First Day Position B MS67 example achieved $1,900, reflecting strong demand among registry set collectors seeking labeled specimens.

The Satin Finish coins — a third distinct surface type issued exclusively through U.S. Mint sets, different from both standard business strikes and proofs — command separate premiums. They display a matte-like texture distinct from both the bright luster of business strikes and the mirror fields of proof coins.

 

History of the 2009 Presidential Dollar Value Program

The 2009 Presidential Dollar series marked the third year of the United States Mint’s Presidential Dollar Coin Program, a series that began under the Presidential $1 Coin Act of 2005 (Public Law 109-145), signed into law by President George W. Bush on December 22, 2005. That legislation required the U.S. Mint to honor deceased former presidents on circulating one-dollar coins, releasing four new designs per year in the order the presidents served.

The program was modeled after the wildly successful 50 State Quarters Program, which ran from 1999 to 2008, in the hope that rotating designs would stimulate public interest in dollar coin circulation. Unlike the quarters program, however, the Presidential Dollar series never achieved widespread circulation — the coins were largely ignored by the public despite marketing efforts.

The four presidents honored in 2009 were William Henry Harrison (9th, 1841), John Tyler (10th, 1841–1845), James K. Polk (11th, 1845–1849), and Zachary Taylor (12th, 1849–1850). Each coin entered circulation on a staggered schedule: Harrison on February 19, 2009; Tyler on May 21, 2009; Polk on August 20, 2009; and Taylor on November 19, 2009.

The most historically significant aspect of the 2009 series was a mandated design change. Following the Consolidated Appropriations Act of 2008, passed by Congress in December 2007, the inscription “IN GOD WE TRUST” was required to move from the edge of the coin to the obverse face.

This change, implemented starting with the very first 2009 Harrison release, permanently ended the controversial “edge motto” design that had sparked public debate — and the “Godless Dollar” nickname — in 2007 and 2008.

The economic recession of 2008–2009 also played a direct role in the 2009 mintage totals. Reduced demand for dollar coins from the Federal Reserve led to significantly lower production figures compared to 2007–2008 issues, where single coins sometimes exceeded 100 million pieces.

This lower supply, combined with the fact that most 2009 Presidential Dollars never circulated and remained in Federal Reserve vaults or collector holdings, shapes the survival rate and market dynamics collectors encounter today.

Also Read: Top 40+ Most Valuable Presidential Dollar Coins Worth Money

 

Is Your 2009 Presidential Dollar Value Rare?

Discover the true rarity of your Presidential Dollars — check precise rarity rankings and valuations instantly with CoinValueChecker App to know exactly where your coins stand among collectors.

 

Key Features of the 2009 Presidential Dollar Value Series

The 2009 Presidential Dollar series introduced the design change that would define all Presidential Dollars going forward, making it one of the most pivotal transition years in the program’s history. Understanding these key features helps you identify your coin and determine which surface type and variety you hold.

The four presidents honored represent a fascinating mid-19th century era: William Henry Harrison (9th President), John Tyler (10th President), James K. Polk (11th President), and Zachary Taylor (12th President) — all of whom served during one of the most formative and turbulent decades in American history.

The Obverse of the 2009 Presidential Dollar

Each 2009 obverse features a portrait of the honored president drawn from official White House portraits, intaglio prints, and historical medal designs. Notably, each of the four 2009 coins was created by a different U.S. Mint artist — making this year particularly varied from a numismatic art perspective.

The William Henry Harrison dollar was sculpted and designed by U.S. Mint Sculptor-Engraver Joseph Menna. The John Tyler dollar features a portrait by Sculptor-Engraver Phebe Hemphill, the James K. Polk coin was designed by Artistic Infusion Program Master Designer Susan Gamble and sculpted by Charles Vickers, and the Zachary Taylor dollar bears a portrait by Sculptor-Engraver Don Everhart.

Each obverse carries the president’s name arched above the portrait, with the presidential number and years of service below — for example, “9th PRESIDENT 1841” for Harrison, or “11th PRESIDENT 1845–1849” for Polk. The defining feature that sets 2009 coins apart from all prior issues is the placement of “IN GOD WE TRUST” directly on the obverse, positioned to the lower left of the presidential portrait.

This move addressed widespread criticism that the motto was too inconspicuous on the coin’s edge in 2007–2008 issues. It also permanently closed the chapter on true “Godless Dollar” errors — though missing edge lettering errors on 2009 coins do still occur, since “IN GOD WE TRUST” is already safely on the face.

The Reverse of the 2009 Presidential Dollar

The reverse design, shared by all Presidential Dollars throughout the entire program, features an upward-looking view of the Statue of Liberty sculpted and designed by U.S. Mint Sculptor-Engraver Don Everhart. Lady Liberty appears dynamically on the right side, with her extended torch-bearing arm serving as the composition’s focal point and the denomination “$1” placed beneath her arm.

The inscription “UNITED STATES OF AMERICA” encircles the outer rim in capital letters set in the ITC Benguiat font. The designer’s initials “TDR” for Thomas D. Rogers are subtly incorporated into the design — a detail many casual observers miss entirely.

Other Features of the 2009 Presidential Dollar: Surface Types and Composition

Unlike earlier Presidential Dollar series years, the 2009 coins appear in three distinct surface types that significantly affect value. Business strike coins (P and D mint marks) display normal lustrous surfaces, while Satin Finish coins from U.S. Mint sets show a distinctive matte-like texture that collectors and grading services treat as a separate variety.

Proof coins (S mint mark), struck at San Francisco with specially polished dies on hand-selected planchets, produce the Deep Cameo (DCAM) finish — heavy white frost on portrait devices contrasted against deeply mirrored background fields. The DCAM designation, meaning the devices are heavily frosted against mirror-like fields, makes these the most visually striking of the three types.

The composition of all three surface types is identical: a pure copper core clad by manganese brass outer layers, resulting in an overall composition of 88.5% copper, 6% zinc, 3.5% manganese, and 2% nickel. It is this 7% manganese content in the cladding that causes the coin’s greatest enemy in high grades — carbon spotting and flyspecks — as manganese reacts with sulfur compounds in air, cardboard, and storage materials, causing dark spots that can drop an otherwise perfect coin from MS67 to MS65 or lower.

Coin specifications are: weight 8.1 grams, diameter 26.5 millimeters, thickness 2 millimeters. The golden color produced by the manganese brass cladding was intentional, designed to visually distinguish the dollar coin from other circulating denominations.

Also Read: Top 80+ Most Valuable Sacagawea Dollar Worth Money (2000-P to Present)

 

The Easy Way to Know Your 2009 Presidential Dollar Value

Determining your 2009 Presidential Dollar’s value requires a few key steps. First, check the coin’s condition — circulated coins with visible wear on the portrait or high points typically remain at face value, while an MS67 or higher grade can bring significant premiums.

Next, examine the edge carefully under magnification. Check for the mint mark (P or D) and “E PLURIBUS UNUM,” noting whether the lettering is Position A (upside-down when portrait faces up) or Position B (right-side up).

If the edge is completely smooth with no inscriptions at all, measure the coin’s diameter — it must be exactly 26.5mm. A smooth-edged coin meeting that standard could be a missing edge lettering error worth several hundred dollars.

For the fastest and most accurate evaluation, use the CoinValueChecker App — simply photograph your coin to receive professional-grade valuation, error detection, and current market data in seconds.

 

2009 Presidential Dollar Value Guides By Mint and Grade

• 2009 William Henry Harrison Presidential Dollar — The 9th President, known for the shortest presidency in U.S. history at just 31 days; Philadelphia mintage: 43,260,000
• 2009 John Tyler Presidential Dollar — The 10th President, featuring Position A and Position B edge lettering varieties; Philadelphia and Denver mintage: 43,540,000 each
• 2009 James K. Polk Presidential Dollar — The 11th President with the highest 2009 mintage at 46,620,000 (Philadelphia); Denver produced 41,720,000
• 2009 Zachary Taylor Presidential Dollar — The 12th President, who died in office in 1850; a popular choice among collectors for its historical narrative

Each 2009 Presidential Dollar was struck at Philadelphia (P) and Denver (D) for general circulation, with San Francisco (S) producing proof versions for collector sets. The San Francisco proof coins, with a Harrison mintage of 2,809,452, were the rarest of the three finish types in terms of total output.

Circulated examples typically remain at face value, while uncirculated specimens, high-grade proofs, Satin Finish varieties, and error coins command meaningful premiums based on grade and surface quality.

Also Read: Top 100 Most Valuable Morgan Silver Dollar Coins Worth Money List

 

2009 Presidential Dollar Value: William Henry Harrison

The 2009 William Henry Harrison Presidential Dollar commemorates America’s 9th president, who died on April 4, 1841 — just 31 days after his inauguration — making his the shortest presidency in U.S. history. The coin was officially released into circulation on February 19, 2009, and coins submitted to PCGS on or before that date earned the special First Day of Issue label on their holder.

The Philadelphia Mint struck 43,260,000 Harrison business strike coins, with Denver also producing a large quantity for circulation. The San Francisco Mint struck 2,809,452 Harrison proof coins, according to PCGS CoinFacts — all in Deep Cameo (DCAM) quality as part of the 2009 Presidential $1 Coin Proof Set.

Standard business strike mint state examples typically range from $4 to $5, while MS67 specimens — representing less than 1% of all certified submissions according to PCGS population reports — can reach significantly higher premiums. The auction record for a standard business strike Harrison is $1,840 at Heritage Auctions on December 2, 2010, set by an MS68 example — an exceptional grade for this manganese brass issue.

Edge lettering orientation divides Harrison coins into two collecting varieties: Position A, where the edge inscription reads upside-down when the portrait faces up, and Position B, where it reads normally. These orientations occur at random during the edge lettering process and are officially recognized by PCGS and NGC as separate collectibles.

The Auction Record Chart below provides a historical overview of how these coins have performed at public sales across different grades and varieties since their release.

Current Market Activity data reflects ongoing collector interest and trading patterns for this issue in today’s numismatic marketplace.

 

2009 Presidential Dollar Value: John Tyler

The 2009 John Tyler Presidential Dollar honors America’s 10th president, who assumed the office in 1841 after William Henry Harrison’s death — earning him the nickname “His Accidency” from political opponents. Tyler served until 1845, and his coin entered circulation on May 21, 2009 as the second release of the 2009 series.

Philadelphia and Denver each produced 43,540,000 Tyler business strike coins — slightly higher than the Harrison mintage. The Tyler dollar is particularly interesting to collectors because of its well-documented market history: an MS67 Position A example sold for $1,150 at auction early in the coin’s collecting history, but as more examples were certified, PCGS revised its value estimate down to approximately $225. Today, the top-graded Tyler MS68 carries a PCGS value of $900, making it one of the most expensive 2009 Presidential Dollars in standard business strike format.

Circulated Tyler dollars are worth face value, while uncirculated specimens in grades MS60–MS66 range from about $3 to $25. Pristine high-grade examples at MS67 or above can command $225 or more, and error varieties — especially missing edge lettering — add significant premiums.

Market activity for this series remains steady among dedicated Presidential Dollar collectors, reflecting the appeal of building complete, certified sets by president and mint mark.

 

2009 Presidential Dollar Value: James K. Polk

The 2009 James K. Polk Presidential Dollar marks the eleventh release in the Presidential Dollar Program, honoring the 11th president who served a single term from 1845 to 1849 — achieving major territorial expansion but choosing not to seek re-election. The coin was officially released on August 20, 2009, and carries a portrait designed by Susan Gamble of the Artistic Infusion Program and sculpted by Charles Vickers.

The Polk dollar carries the highest mintage among the four 2009 presidents: Philadelphia struck 46,620,000 and Denver produced 41,720,000 business strike coins. Despite the large mintage, the manganese brass composition means that carbon spotting makes MS67+ examples genuine condition rarities — PCGS population data confirms that fewer than 1% of submitted examples achieve MS67 or better.

The San Francisco Mint produced over 2.8 million Polk proof coins in Deep Cameo quality. According to PCGS CoinFacts, these Polk proofs “came in really nice quality from Proof Sets ranging anywhere from about PR67–PR69 Deep Cameo on average,” while PR70 DCAM examples, though harder to find, exist in sufficient quantity to satisfy collector demand.

At the MS67 level, Philadelphia Position B examples command around $70 compared to $25 for Position A — demonstrating that at high grades, edge orientation can meaningfully influence price. Standard proof Polk dollars grade PR60 at face value, rising to $3 at PR63, $4 at PR65, $5 at PR68, and around $35 for a flawless PR70.

Market activity for this series continues to reflect steady interest from collectors focused on assembling complete Presidential Dollar sets and pursuing higher-grade certified examples.

 

2009 Presidential Dollar Value: Zachary Taylor

The 2009 Zachary Taylor Presidential Dollar honors America’s 12th president, a celebrated general who won fame in the Mexican-American War but served only 16 months in office before his death on July 9, 1850. Taylor’s coin entered circulation on November 19, 2009 — the final 2009 release — and features a portrait sculpted by Sculptor-Engraver Don Everhart.

Taylor dollars are available in three mint versions: Philadelphia (P) and Denver (D) for standard circulation strikes, plus San Francisco (S) Deep Cameo proof editions struck for collector sets. Each is also available in both Position A and Position B edge lettering orientation, and Satin Finish examples were issued through the U.S. Mint’s annual Presidential Dollar set.

While standard circulated Taylor examples hold face value, uncirculated specimens range from about $2 to $5 in typical grades. The most dramatic value jump appears at the error level: missing edge lettering Taylor dollars have realized several hundred dollars at auction, and an MS67 Moy Signature example — signed by then-Mint Director Edmund C. Moy — adds a further premium through special provenance.

Market activity for Zachary Taylor dollars shows steady collector interest, especially for error varieties and high-grade certified examples.

Also Read: 17 Rare Dollar Coin Errors List with Pictures (By Year)

 

Rare 2009 Presidential Dollar Value Error List

The 2009 Presidential Dollar series produced several recognized error types, most stemming from the mechanics of the separate edge lettering process used by the U.S. Mint. Because edge lettering is applied after the obverse and reverse are already struck, mechanical failures in the Schuler edge lettering machine create the error categories below.

An important note for 2009 errors specifically: because “IN GOD WE TRUST” was moved from the edge to the obverse starting in 2009, these coins can no longer be called “Godless Dollars.” However, collectors still use the term informally for missing-edge errors across all years of the Presidential Dollar series.

1. 2009 Missing Edge Lettering Error

This error occurs when a coin completely bypasses the Schuler edge lettering machine, resulting in a perfectly smooth edge with no date, mint mark, or “E PLURIBUS UNUM” inscription. The edge should measure exactly 26.5mm in diameter — if it’s smaller, the coin may have had its edge filed, which is an alteration, not a genuine error.

For the 2009 series, PCGS has certified Harrison missing edge lettering errors from MS63 upward, with lower-grade MS63 examples starting at approximately $30. Higher-grade MS67+ examples can reach up to $200.

The finest known Harrison business strike Missing Edge example in MS69 sold for $456 at auction in 2019 and later resold for $1,250 in 2022 — a 174% gain in three years reflecting growing demand for top-grade 2009 error coins.

A special sub-variety known as the Moy Signature variety exists for Harrison missing edge lettering errors — these are coins hand-signed by then-U.S. Mint Director Edmund C. Moy and certified by PCGS, commanding an additional premium over unsigned examples. This variety is separately catalogued by PCGS.

The most valuable missing edge lettering 2009 example is the Harrison Satin Finish SP69, which realized $1,955 at Heritage Auctions on December 2, 2010 — the all-time 2009 series auction record. The Satin Finish version is rarer than the business strike version because the satin coins had a lower starting mintage through the U.S. Mint set (784,614).

2. 2009 Doubled Edge Lettering (Slipped Edge Lettering) Error

This error results when a coin passes through the edge lettering machine twice, creating overlapping or inverted inscriptions on the edge. Variety researcher Ken Potter documented the distinct subtypes: the Overlapped type shows a second set of lettering partially overlapping the first; the Inverted type (also called the double-struck inverted variety) displays two full sets of lettering in opposite directions — one upright and one upside-down.

These errors typically sell for $30 and up in average collector grades, with higher-grade certified examples bringing significantly more. The 2007-P John Adams series established the benchmark for doubled edge lettering values in Presidential Dollars, with MS67 examples from that year having sold for over $3,000 — though 2009 doubled edge examples are rarer and may command comparable premiums in top grades due to the late-series rarity factor.

3. 2009 Obverse Die Scraped Error

A die scrape error occurs when a foreign object — such as metal shavings or debris — drags across the die surface during production or handling, creating raised irregular lines or dotted patterns that transfer to struck coins. Unlike die cracks, which appear as raised lines following the coin’s design contours, scraped die marks appear as irregular dotted or curved raised lines crossing the design at random angles.

Because each die scrape is unique in shape, position, and severity, error coins featuring scrapes near prominent portrait areas are especially desirable to error collectors. Well-documented scrape errors near the presidential portrait on any of the four 2009 coins are particularly sought after as one-of-a-kind pieces.

 

Where to Sell Your 2009 Presidential Dollar Value?

Whether you choose reputable coin dealers, major online auction platforms like Heritage Auctions or Stack’s Bowers, or specialized numismatic marketplaces, always have your 2009 Presidential Dollar authenticated and graded by a trusted third-party service — PCGS, NGC, or ANACS — before selling. Professional certification protects both buyer and seller, establishes value, and can significantly increase the price you achieve for higher-grade or error examples.

Check out now: Best Places To Sell Coins Online (Pros & Cons)

 

FAQ About the 2009 Presidential Dollar Value

1. Are 2009 Presidential Dollars made of real gold?

No, 2009 Presidential Dollars are not made of gold. They consist of a pure copper core clad by manganese brass outer layers, producing an overall composition of 88.5% copper, 6% zinc, 3.5% manganese, and 2% nickel — which creates the golden color designed to distinguish them from other denominations.

2. Why do some people call early Presidential Dollars “Godless Dollars”?

From 2007 to 2008, “IN GOD WE TRUST” appeared on the coin’s edge, and when tens of thousands of coins escaped the edge lettering process entirely, they became known as “Godless Dollars.” Starting in 2009, the motto moved to the obverse face, so while 2009 coins with missing edge lettering do exist as errors, they are technically no longer “godless” since the motto is safely on the front.

3. What is the difference between Position A and Position B on 2009 Presidential Dollars?

Position A means the edge inscription reads upside-down when the presidential portrait faces up; Position B means the lettering reads right-side up in the same orientation. These orientations occur randomly during the edge lettering process and are officially recognized by PCGS and NGC as distinct collecting varieties — though at lower grades, position typically has minimal impact on value.

4. What is a Satin Finish 2009 Presidential Dollar, and is it more valuable?

The Satin Finish is a third surface type exclusive to Presidential Dollars sold through U.S. Mint sets in 2005–2010, distinct from both standard business strikes and San Francisco proofs. Satin Finish coins display a soft, matte-like texture under light rather than the bright luster of a business strike. Because the annual Mint set containing the 2009 Harrison Satin coin had a mintage of only 784,614 — far below the 43 million business strike Harrison coins — Satin Finish examples are genuinely scarcer and can command higher premiums, especially in high grades or with errors.

5. What is the Moy Signature variety on 2009 Presidential Dollar errors?

The Moy Signature variety refers to 2009 Presidential Dollar missing edge lettering error coins personally hand-signed by Edmund C. Moy, who served as U.S. Mint Director from 2006 to 2011. PCGS certifies and separately catalogs these signed examples — for instance, the 2009 Harrison Missing Edge Moy Signature is assigned its own PCGS number. The signature adds provenance and collector interest, typically commanding a premium above unsigned examples of the same error and grade.

6. Why are MS67 and higher grades so rare for 2009 Presidential Dollars?

The manganese brass composition of Presidential Dollars is highly reactive — the 7% manganese content reacts with sulfur compounds in air, cardboard, and PVC storage materials, causing dark brown or black carbon spots and flyspecks. Even a single small spot can drop a coin from MS68 to MS65 or lower. PCGS population reports confirm that MS67+ specimens represent less than 1% of all certified 2009 Presidential Dollar submissions, making them genuine condition rarities despite the tens of millions originally minted.

7. What is the highest auction price ever paid for a 2009 Presidential Dollar?

The all-time auction record for a 2009 Presidential Dollar is $1,955, achieved by a William Henry Harrison Missing Edge Lettering Satin Finish example graded SP69, sold at Heritage Auctions on December 2, 2010. In the standard business strike category, the record is $1,840 for a Harrison MS68 at the same Heritage Auctions sale.

8. Does a First Day of Issue label increase the value of a 2009 Presidential Dollar?

Yes — a First Day of Issue (FDI) designation is awarded by PCGS to coins submitted on or before the official release date of each coin (for example, February 19, 2009 for Harrison). FDI coins can command meaningful premiums, particularly in high grades. The 2009-P John Tyler First Day Position B MS67 achieved $1,900 at auction, illustrating how the combination of a first-day label and high grade can dramatically increase market value over standard examples of the same coin.

9. How do I check if my 2009 Presidential Dollar has a missing edge lettering error?

Start by examining the edge of the coin with a loupe or magnifier. A genuine missing edge lettering error has a completely smooth edge — no letters, no date, no mint mark. Then measure the diameter: it must be exactly 26.5mm. A coin with a smaller diameter may have had its edge artificially filed down, which is an alteration worth nothing. Finally, weigh the coin: it should be exactly 8.1 grams on an accurate scale. If all three criteria are met, have it authenticated by PCGS, NGC, or ANACS before buying or selling, since counterfeits do exist.

10. Is it worth having my 2009 Presidential Dollar professionally graded?

It depends on what you have. Standard circulated 2009 Presidential Dollars worth $1 are not worth the $20–$40 grading fee. However, professional grading makes strong economic sense for: (1) any coin that appears to grade MS67 or higher, since the value jump can be hundreds of dollars; (2) any suspected error coin, especially missing or doubled edge lettering; (3) Satin Finish examples in exceptional condition; or (4) any coin you plan to sell for over $50. Certification from PCGS or NGC not only authenticates the coin but protects its resale value and makes it significantly easier to sell at full market price.