2009 Nickel Value Checker: Errors List, “P”, “D” & “S” Mint Mark Worth

2009 Nickel value ranges from $0.05 face value to $395. That record was a Grade 69 example sold through EA Auctions in January 2023 — a recent sale that shows even near-perfect modern nickels can carry solid collector value. Upload a photo of yours below to get a quick value range on your coin. Then scroll down to see what 2009 Nickels are going for on eBay today.

 

2009 Nickel Value By Variety

Five collectible varieties exist for the 2009 nickel across three mints. Philadelphia and Denver made circulation strikes, San Francisco handled proofs, and both P and D also produced satin finish coins sold only in mint sets.

If you know the grade of your coin, you can find the exact price below in the Value Guides section.

Also Read: Top 100 Most Valuable Jefferson Nickels Worth Money List (1938-Present)

 

Top 10 Most Valuable 2009 Nickel Worth Money

The top spot belongs to a 2009-P MS69 Full Steps that hammered for $395 at auction in January 2023. That’s a nickel — five cents face value — pulling nearly $400 because it hit a grade most collectors didn’t think was possible for this date.

Denver’s best certified piece, an MS66 Full Steps, brought $295 at Heritage Auctions in March 2023. Both results tell you the same thing: collectors are paying real money for well-struck 2009 nickels in top grades.

Satin finish strikes round out the list. The 2009-P satin finish in SP68 sold for $180 in December 2018, and Denver’s equivalent hit $130 in March 2018. A perfect PR70 Deep Cameo proof from San Francisco commands $140, with PR69 examples trading steadily between $40 and $50.

 

History Of The 2009 Nickel

On April 23, 2009, the U.S. Mint dropped a bombshell: nickel and dime production for circulation was done for the year. Paul Gilkes at Coin World broke the story, and collectors immediately started paying attention.

Philadelphia struck just 39,840,000 circulation nickels — the lowest for any circulation strike nickel since 1959. Denver added 46,800,000, bringing the combined total to 86,640,000. The year before? The two mints cranked out 625,440,000 nickels together. That’s an 87.6% drop in a single year, one of the sharpest outside the Great Depression.

The Great Recession was the culprit. Unemployment climbed from 7.7% in January 2009 to 10% by December. People stopped spending and raided their coin jars, flooding banks with old change. The Federal Reserve slashed its orders to the Mint, and production fell off a cliff.

2009-P nickels started showing up in circulation around June 2009. Denver pieces trickled out even later — some didn’t hit pocket change until early 2010. The design itself had been in place since 2006, when the American 5-Cent Coin Design Continuity Act of 2003 brought Monticello back to the reverse and introduced Jamie Franki’s forward-facing Jefferson portrait.

Franki based his obverse on an 1800 portrait study by Rembrandt Peale. Donna Weaver sculpted the final version at the Mint. On the reverse, Felix Schlag’s classic Monticello got freshened up by Mint engravers for the 2006 reintroduction.

By 2010, things bounced back fast. Philadelphia alone struck 260,640,000 nickels — more than six times its 2009 output. The scarcity window slammed shut. If you stashed rolls in 2009, you’re sitting on genuinely scarce modern coins.

Also Read: Top 60+ Most Valuable Buffalo Nickels Worth Money

 

Is Your 2009 Nickel Rare?

Here’s the counterintuitive part: a 2009 nickel you pull from pocket change is scarce but not valuable. It’s still a circulated coin worth face value. But take that same date in MS69 Full Steps, and you’re looking at a tiny certified population that commands serious money. The year alone doesn’t make it rare — the combination of mint mark, grade, and Full Steps designation is what separates a five-cent coin from a $395 coin. Use the Coin Identifier and Value App to quickly assess your 2009 nickel’s rarity level.

 

Key Features Of The 2009 Nickel

The 2009 nickel uses the design introduced in 2006 — the biggest obverse change since the early 1960s. Knowing what to look for helps you grade accurately and spot the details that drive value.

The Obverse Of The 2009 Nickel

Jefferson faces you head-on — no more left-facing profile like the 1938–2003 coins. Jamie Franki designed the portrait based on an 1800 study by Rembrandt Peale, and Donna Weaver sculpted it at the Mint.

“IN GOD WE TRUST” sits on the left. “LIBERTY” appears on the right in Jefferson’s own handwriting. Look at the bottom for “2009” and the mint mark just below it — “P” for Philadelphia, “D” for Denver, “S” for San Francisco proofs.

The Reverse Of The 2009 Nickel

Flip it over and you’ll see Monticello, Jefferson’s Virginia estate. Felix Schlag created this design back in 1938 after winning the Mint’s competition. His initials “FS” appear near Monticello on coins from 2006 onward. Don’t confuse those with the Full Steps grading designation — totally different thing.

“E PLURIBUS UNUM” arcs across the top. “MONTICELLO” sits right below the building. “FIVE CENTS” and “UNITED STATES OF AMERICA” fill out the bottom. The staircase at Monticello’s base is the critical area for Full Steps — more on that below.

Other Features Of The 2009 Nickel

The coin weighs 5 grams with a 21.2-millimeter diameter. It’s 75% copper and 25% nickel — the same alloy used since 1946. Smooth edge, no reeding, 1.95 millimeters thick. Proofs from San Francisco carry an “S” mint mark with mirror-like fields and frosted devices.

Also Read: Top 100 Rarest Nickels Worth Money (Most Expensive)

 

What Is Full Steps (FS) On A 2009 Nickel?

Full Steps — “FS” on the slab label — is the single biggest value driver for 2009 nickels beyond the grade itself. It’s all about those horizontal step lines at the base of Monticello on the reverse.

Monticello has six steps. PCGS awards the FS designation when at least five are fully visible with no nicks, cuts, or weak spots breaking the lines.

Here’s how the count works: four unbroken incuse lines between steps equals five full steps. Five unbroken lines equals six full steps. NGC has split the designation into 5FS and 6FS since 2004. PCGS uses a single “FS” label covering either count.

Most 2009 circulation strikes show softness in the step area from normal die wear and striking pressure. Bill Fivaz has pointed out that even five complete steps is the exception across many Jefferson dates. For 2009, finding anything above MS65 with Full Steps takes real cherrypicking — and the price gap between a standard MS65 and an MS65 Full Steps is dramatic.

 

2009 Nickel Mintage & Survival Data

Philadelphia struck 39,840,000 circulation pieces. Denver made 46,800,000. Combined, that’s 86,640,000 — just 13.9% of the 625 million struck in 2008. To put it another way, for every seven nickels made in 2008, the Mint produced roughly one in 2009.

San Francisco contributed 2,179,867 proof coins in Deep Cameo finish for proof sets only. Both Philadelphia and Denver produced 784,614 satin finish pieces each for annual mint sets. Total collector-issue coins came in under 5% of overall 2009 nickel production.

Production bounced back to 490,560,000 combined circulation nickels by 2010, confirming 2009 was a one-year recession-driven dip. No formal survival data has been published for any 2009 variety — PCGS and NGC population reports are your best proxy for rarity at specific grades.

Also Read: Jefferson Nickel Value (1938-Present)

 

The Easy Way to Know Your 2009 Nickel Value

Start on the obverse. Find the mint mark below “2009” — “P” for Philadelphia, “D” for Denver, “S” for San Francisco proofs. Check overall condition next. Then grab a 10x loupe and examine the reverse staircase for Full Steps. Finally, hunt for any errors or oddities that could push the value way up. Download the Coin Identifier and Value App to instantly evaluate your 2009 nickel’s potential value.

 

2009 Nickel Value Guides

• 2009-P Nickel – Philadelphia circulation strike with 39,840,000 mintage; lowest P-mint nickel since 1959
• 2009-D Nickel – Denver circulation strike with 46,800,000 mintage
• 2009-S DCAM Nickel – San Francisco proof in Deep Cameo (DCAM) finish with 2,179,867 mintage
• 2009-P Satin Finish Special Strike – Philadelphia mint set exclusive with 784,614 mintage
• 2009-D Satin Finish Special Strike – Denver mint set exclusive with 784,614 mintage

Five varieties, three mints. The P and D circulation strikes are the most common but still genuinely scarce next to typical modern Jefferson nickels. San Francisco made proofs only — none went into circulation.

Satin finish special strikes are the niche variety. They were produced exclusively for annual mint sets using higher striking pressure and specially prepared planchets. Grading services give these an “SP” (Specimen) designation instead of the standard “MS.” About 30 pieces from PCGS reached SP69 across both satin varieties combined. None have graded higher.

 

2009-P Nickel Value

How scarce is the 2009-P? Compare its 39,840,000 mintage to the 2000-D nickel at 1.5 billion. According to PCGS CoinFacts, it’s the lowest mintage circulation strike nickel since 1959. That alone makes it a coin worth pulling from every roll you search.

Full Steps is where the money is. That designation means five or six horizontal lines at Monticello’s base are completely clear and uninterrupted under magnification. Most 2009-P strikes show weakness there. Finding sharp Full Steps examples above MS65 takes real effort, and MS65 Full Steps specimens trade for around $22 versus much less without the designation.

The top-pop 2009-P reached MS69 Full Steps and sold for $395 in January 2023. I think that price shows just how hungry registry set collectors are for top-grade modern nickels.

Here’s how recent auction results break down by grade:

 

2009-D Nickel Value

Think the 2009-P is tough with Full Steps? Denver is worse. Most 2009-D circulation strikes show weak staircase detail, and finding anything above MS65 with Full Steps takes serious digging. NGC’s more demanding 6FS designation — requiring all six steps fully visible — is rarely awarded to 2009-D pieces.

Denver produced 46,800,000 nickels, slightly more than Philadelphia but still an 86% drop from Denver’s 2008 output of 345,600,000 pieces. Same recession, same story.

The finest certified 2009-D with Full Steps topped out at MS66, selling for $295 at Heritage Auctions in March 2023. At MS65 Full Steps, you’re looking at roughly $30 — a big jump over the same grade without the step designation.

Here’s what slabbed examples have brought at auction recently:

 

2009-S DCAM Nickel Value

Don’t expect circulation strike money here. The 2009-S was struck exclusively as a proof — 2,179,867 pieces in proof sets, never released into circulation.

Deep Cameo (DCAM) — NGC calls it Ultra Cameo (UCAM) — is the standard for modern proofs. It means strong contrast between mirror fields and frosted devices. Most examples grade PR68 to PR69 DCAM. Perfect PR70 specimens are findable with some patience, since modern proof technology yields high rates of flawless coins.

Standard PR69 DCAM examples trade between $40 and $50. PR70 commands around $140 based on a March 2022 auction. Values stay modest compared to circulation strikes because the mintage is bigger and these coins went straight into collector hands.

Auction results for proof specimens:

 

2009-P Satin Finish Special Strike Nickel Value

Ever held a satin finish nickel next to a regular business strike? The difference is obvious. Philadelphia produced 784,614 of these using specially prepared planchets that give the surface a distinctive matte-like texture — nothing like the shiny luster of a circulation coin or the mirror fields of a proof.

Grading services assign “SP” (Specimen) grades instead of “MS.” Most examples land between SP66 and SP68. Getting to SP69 is tough because even careful handling during mint set packaging leaves microscopic contact marks that pull the grade down.

The auction record sits at $180 for an SP68 Full Steps example sold in December 2018. That combination of a high SP grade plus Full Steps is what you’re looking for.

No valid activity data found

 

2009-D Satin Finish Special Strike Nickel Value

Same deal as the Philadelphia satin finish — 784,614 pieces, mint sets only, same burnished planchet process. Most certified examples fall between SP66 and SP68.

The satin surface looks sharper than a standard Denver circulation strike, but these coins grade lower than proofs because of their different production method and texture. The auction record for this variety is $130 for an SP68 Full Steps example sold in March 2018. We think the satin finish varieties are underappreciated given their low mintages.

No valid activity data found

Also Read: 22 Rare Nickel Errors List with Pictures (By Year)

 

Rare 2009 Nickel Error List

Errors happen during die prep, planchet production, or striking. Despite its low mintage, the 2009 nickel produced a solid range of documented errors with verified auction records from Heritage Auctions and Great Collections.

1. Reverse Die Cap Error

This is the king of 2009 nickel errors. A die cap forms when a planchet sticks to the die and becomes the striking surface itself. More coins get struck against it, and the stuck planchet curls up around the die like a bottle cap. The result is a wildly distorted coin with a raised or domed appearance on one side.

A 2009-D Jefferson nickel graded MS65 with a reverse die cap error sold for $1,010 at a Great Collections auction in 2020 — the highest documented price for any 2009 nickel error. These are extremely rare because quality control usually catches the problem before many coins are affected.

2. Double Curved Clipped Planchet Error

You know those crescent-shaped bites missing from a coin’s edge? That’s a clipped planchet — the blanking punch overlapped a previously cut hole in the metal strip. Now imagine two of those clips on the same coin. That’s significantly rarer and more valuable.

A 2009-D nickel graded MS63 with a double curved clipped planchet error sold for $810 at Heritage Auctions in 2021. Single curved clips on 2009 nickels typically bring $25 to $100 depending on clip size and grade.

3. Die Clash Error

When the obverse and reverse dies slam together with no planchet between them, each die picks up a ghost impression of the other. Coins struck afterward show faint “extra” design elements — like a hint of Monticello ghosting onto Jefferson’s portrait side.

A 2009-P nickel graded MS63 with a reverse die clash error sold for $830 at Heritage Auctions in 2022. Minor clashes bring small premiums, but dramatic examples with strong transferred imagery are where the real money is.

4. Missing Clad Layer Error

Here’s a tricky one. Jefferson nickels aren’t clad coins — they’re a solid copper-nickel alloy. But some 2009 nickels show a “missing clad layer” appearance from improper alloy bonding during planchet production. You’ll see a copper-colored area exposed on one or both sides. A 2009-P Jefferson nickel graded MS61 with this error has been certified by major grading services.

Values vary widely based on how much surface is affected and overall condition. This error type wasn’t in earlier Jefferson nickel error guides, so certified examples are genuinely scarce in the market.

5. Off-Center Strike Error

The planchet wasn’t centered under the dies when it got hit. You’ll see the design shifted toward one edge with a blank crescent of unstruck metal on the opposite side. The bigger the shift, the more valuable the error.

A 2009-P nickel graded MS65 with an off-center strike has been certified. Coins 10–20% off-center typically bring $50–$100, while 50% examples with a complete visible date can exceed $150. An off-metal 2009 nickel struck on a penny or dime planchet would command $300 to $500, but none have been publicly confirmed at auction.

6. Improperly Annealed Planchet Error

Annealing is the controlled heating and cooling that softens planchets before striking. When it goes wrong, the coin can look discolored, show odd surface texture, or display weakly struck details. A 2009-D Jefferson nickel graded MS60 with an improperly annealed planchet error has been documented and certified.

These are conversation pieces more than big-ticket items. Premiums stay modest unless the visual effect is really dramatic or the coin grades high.

7. Broad Strike Error

When a planchet gets struck outside the retaining collar, metal flows outward freely. You end up with a coin wider than normal, with a flattened rim and expanded design elements. A 2009-P Jefferson nickel graded MS62 with a broad struck error has been certified and trades actively among error collectors.

8. Doubled Die Error (DDO / DDR)

Doubled die errors happen when a die gets multiple, slightly misaligned impressions from the hub during production. The doubling shows up raised and rounded on letters, the date, or design elements. Don’t confuse this with mechanical doubling, which looks flat and shelf-like — that’s worth much less.

A 2009-D Jefferson nickel graded MS60 with a doubled die error has been certified. Values range from $10 to several hundred dollars depending on how strong the doubling is and the coin’s grade. Check “LIBERTY,” “IN GOD WE TRUST,” Jefferson’s eye, and Monticello’s architectural details — those are your best spots to look.

9. Grease Strike-Through Error

Grease or oil from machinery sits between the die and planchet during striking. The gunk blocks the impression, leaving weak, missing, or mushy areas on the finished coin. A 2009-P Jefferson nickel graded MS64 with a grease strike-through error has been certified.

Most sell in the $10–$50 range. Large examples with major design elements obliterated can bring more from specialized error collectors.

 

Where To Sell Your 2009 Nickel?

Ready to sell your 2009 nickel? We’ve compiled a comprehensive guide on the best online selling platforms. Each option offers distinct advantages and considerations. Our detailed analysis covers pros and cons to help you choose wisely. Find the right marketplace for your coins below.

Check out now: Best Places To Sell Coins Online (Pros & Cons) 

 

2009 Nickel Market Trend

*Market Trend Chart showing the number of people paying attention to this coin.

 

FAQ About The 2009 Nickel Value

1. How much is a 2009 nickel worth today?

Worn circulated examples? Face value. Uncirculated rolls typically yield $0.50 to $1 per coin. Certified MS65 Full Steps brings around $22 for Philadelphia and $30 for Denver. The top-grade MS69 Full Steps hit $395 at auction in 2023. Proof PR70 DCAM commands $140, and satin finish SP68 pieces sell for $130 to $180 depending on mint.

2. How many 2009-D nickels were minted?

Denver struck 46,800,000 circulation nickels in 2009 — an 86% drop from Denver’s 2008 output of 345,600,000 pieces. Combined with Philadelphia’s 39,840,000, the total 2009 circulation mintage was 86,640,000. That was the lowest combined figure since 1951, triggered by the Great Recession reducing commercial demand for new coins nationwide.

3. Is the 2009 nickel rare?

Yes. The U.S. Mint officially halted production on April 23, 2009, citing drastically reduced demand from the Great Recession. The 2009-P carries the lowest mintage of any circulation strike nickel since 1959. Both varieties remain hard to find in pocket change today, more than 15 years after release.

4. What does Full Steps (FS) mean on a 2009 nickel?

Full Steps refers to the horizontal staircase lines at Monticello’s base on the reverse. PCGS awards the FS designation when at least five of six steps are fully visible with no interruptions. NGC splits this into 5FS and 6FS since 2004. On 2009 nickels, most circulation strikes show weak step detail — an MS65 Full Steps 2009-P is worth around $22 versus much less without the designation. Note: the “FS” initials on the coin itself stand for designer Felix Schlag, not Full Steps.

5. What is the most valuable 2009 nickel error?

The 2009-D Reverse Die Cap at $1,010 from Great Collections in 2020. Next up: the 2009-P Die Clash ($830, Heritage Auctions, 2022) and the 2009-D Double Curved Clipped Planchet ($810, Heritage Auctions, 2021). An off-metal 2009 nickel struck on a cent or dime planchet would potentially top all of these, but no confirmed sale has been publicly recorded.

6. What is a 2009-S nickel worth?

It was produced only as a proof — 2,179,867 pieces with Deep Cameo (DCAM) finish, never struck for circulation. PR69 DCAM examples trade between $40 and $50. Perfect PR70 DCAM commands around $140 based on a March 2022 auction result. At lower grades, premiums are minimal.

7. How do I tell a 2009-P from a 2009-D nickel?

Check just below the date “2009” on the obverse. A small “P” means Philadelphia, a small “D” means Denver. Both are clearly stamped on well-preserved examples. The 2009-P is slightly scarcer at 39,840,000 versus Denver’s 46,800,000. In circulated condition, neither carries a premium over the other, but both are solid additions to a date set.

8. Why did the Mint stop making 2009 nickels?

The U.S. Mint officially announced on April 23, 2009 — as first reported by Paul Gilkes of Coin World — that it was halting nickel and dime production for the rest of the year. The Great Recession caused Americans to spend less and recirculate home savings, flooding bank inventories with old coins. Federal Reserve banks cut their Mint orders accordingly. By year-end 2009, U.S. unemployment had reached 10%, the highest rate since the early 1980s, drastically reducing commercial demand for new coinage.

9. What does “SP” mean on a 2009 satin finish nickel?

“SP” stands for Specimen. PCGS and NGC use it for coins made specifically for collector sets rather than circulation. Satin finish 2009 nickels get SP grades instead of the standard “MS” (Mint State) because they were produced with specially prepared planchets. Most grade SP66 to SP68, with SP69 being rare — roughly 30 pieces certified across both Philadelphia and Denver varieties combined.

10. Will 2009 nickels continue to increase in value?

I’d say cautiously yes for the right coins. As registry set collecting intensifies, the scarcity of MS67+ Full Steps examples should keep pushing prices higher. Circulated examples will likely stay at or near face value forever — millions survive in that condition.

Your best appreciation potential sits in certified MS67 or higher Full Steps examples and rare errors. PCGS and NGC population numbers are tiny in those categories, and demand from top-set competitors stays consistent.