2004 Sacagawea Dollar Value Checker: Errors List, “D”, “S” & “P” Mint Mark Worth

2004 Sacagawea Dollar value ranges from $1.00 face value to $4,465. That record was set by a Grade 69 example sold through Heritage Auctions in January 2017. If you’re curious what yours might fetch, upload a photo of your coin below for a quick value range. You can also scroll down to browse recent eBay sales and see what buyers are actually paying today.

 

2004 Sacagawea Dollar Value By Variety

Philadelphia and Denver struck business strikes, San Francisco handled proofs, and values swing based on mint mark and condition.

If you know the grade of your coin, you can find the exact price below in the Value Guides section.

Also Read: Sacagawea Dollar Value (2000 to Present)

Top 10 Most Valuable 2004 Sacagawea Dollar Worth Money

Condition drives everything here, not mintage. The MS69 coins from Philadelphia and Denver brought $4,465 and $1,898 because only about 25 coins total have graded that high across both mints. That’s it. Twenty-five coins.

Why so few? These dollars sat in original Mint rolls for twenty years. Coins rubbing against each other nonstop left microscopic bag marks on virtually every piece. MS68+ is the realistic ceiling for most survivors.

Then there’s that wild $4,440 result for a 2004-P graded ANACS MS64 at Heritage Auctions in August 2024. Typical MS64 examples sell for $10–$50, so this coin brought nearly 100 times the going rate. It almost certainly had perfect golden surfaces, zero carbon spots, and well-placed contact marks — the kind of eye appeal that makes bidders lose their minds. I think it proves that raw visual quality can matter more than the number on the slab.

Proofs follow a more predictable curve. PR70 DCAM examples (frosted devices against mirror fields) bring $805, while PR68 DCAM pieces trade around $480. San Francisco’s controlled striking environment keeps quality more consistent.

History of the 2004 Sacagawea Dollar

The Sacagawea dollar traces back to the United States $1 Coin Act of 1997, which killed off the unpopular Susan B. Anthony dollar. Treasury Secretary Robert Rubin set up the Dollar Coin Design Advisory Committee to run a public design competition.

Picking Sacagawea wasn’t a slam dunk. A General Accounting Office poll commissioned by Representative Michael Castle (R-DE) showed 65% of people actually preferred the Statue of Liberty. The Treasury ignored those results and went with Sacagawea anyway.

The 2000 launch had a $40 million marketing budget and a deal with Walmart to push 100 million coins into shoppers’ hands. Didn’t matter. The public never adopted it. By 2002, the Mint had cranked out over 1.3 billion coins at a cost exceeding $160 million to taxpayers, and the Federal Reserve had stopped ordering them entirely.

By 2004 — the third straight year as a “Not Intended For Circulation” (NIFC) issue — the Mint only made coins for collectors. You could buy rolls of 25 for $35.50 (about $1.42 per coin) or bags of 2,000 for approximately $2,490. During a 2002 Senate hearing, North Dakota Senator Byron Dorgan said he had never received a golden dollar in change anywhere in the country. Federal Reserve spokesman Doug Tillet confirmed the coins “tend not to circulate” and instead “wind up in people’s drawers, jars, and pockets.”

Here’s a fun one: twelve pattern coins were struck in 22-karat gold and flew aboard Space Shuttle Columbia on mission STS-93 in July 1999. In 2025, Stack’s Bowers sold seven of those space-flown coins at auction for a combined $3.28 million. That’s the ceiling for this series when rarity and story collide.

Also Read: Top 80+ Most Valuable Sacagawea Dollar Worth Money (2000-P to Present)

Is Your 2004 Sacagawea Dollar Rare?

Here’s what trips people up: a 2004 Sacagawea dollar isn’t rare by mintage. Nearly all of the original 5.32 million business strikes still exist. But finding one that grades MS68 or above? That’s a completely different kind of rare. Roll storage destroyed surfaces across the board, so the coins that somehow escaped with clean fields are the real prizes. The proof is common in absolute numbers but tough at PR70 DCAM.

Track the rarity rankings of your 2004 Sacagawea Dollars and discover where they stand among the entire series with Coin Identifier and Value App comprehensive database and real-time ranking system.

Key Features of the 2004 Sacagawea Dollar

The 2004 issue falls in the middle of the original eagle-reverse era (2000–2008). That design stayed the same until the Native American $1 Coin Act of 2007 brought rotating reverses starting in 2009.

Business strikes carry a “P” (Philadelphia) or “D” (Denver) mint mark on the obverse below the date. Proofs carry the “S” (San Francisco) mint mark. Every 2004 business strike went straight to collectors — none were released through banks or the Federal Reserve.

The Obverse of the 2004 Sacagawea Dollar

Flip the coin to the portrait side. You’ll see Sacagawea in a three-quarter profile carrying her infant son Jean Baptiste Charbonneau on her back. Sculptor Glenna Goodacre designed it and received a $5,000 commission — but she asked to be paid in Sacagawea dollars. Those coins were specially struck on burnished planchets with polished dies, giving them a proof-like look.

No portraits of the real Sacagawea survive, so Goodacre used Randy’L He-dow Teton, a Shoshone college student, as her model. The baby was partially modeled after one-year-old Adam Scholz. “LIBERTY” arcs across the top, “IN GOD WE TRUST” sits to the left of the portrait.

Look below the portrait on the right — that’s where you’ll find “2004” and the mint mark (P or D) just beneath it. Goodacre’s stylized initials “GG” are on the lower-left portion, right on the cloth holding Jean Baptiste.

The Reverse of the 2004 Sacagawea Dollar

Flip it over and you’ll see a soaring bald eagle designed by U.S. Mint sculptor-engraver Thomas D. Rogers. Count the stars — there are seventeen, representing the states in the Union when Lewis and Clark set out in 1804. “E PLURIBUS UNUM” runs above the eagle, “UNITED STATES OF AMERICA” wraps the outer rim, and “ONE DOLLAR” sits at the bottom. Look at the eagle’s tail feathers for Rogers’ initials “TDR.”

Other Features of the 2004 Sacagawea Dollar

The 2004 Sacagawea Dollar has a composition of 88.5% copper, 6% zinc, 3.5% manganese, and 2% nickel, with a total weight of 8.1 grams. The coin has a diameter of 26.5 millimeters, a thickness of 2 millimeters, and a plain (smooth) edge similar to a nickel’s edge.

Here’s the thing you need to know about storage: that manganese-brass alloy reacts with sulfur and moisture in the air. Even coins in original Mint packaging can develop dark carbon spots called “flyspecks” over time. One visible spot kills your chances of grading MS67 or above. Always check under magnification before you spend money on a grading submission.

Also Read: Top 100 Most Valuable Morgan Silver Dollar Coins Worth Money List

2004 Sacagawea Dollar Mintage & Survival Data

Both Philadelphia and Denver struck exactly 2,660,000 pieces each — tying for the third-lowest mintage in the entire Sacagawea circulation strike series. San Francisco produced 2,965,422 proof specimens.

Physical survival rates sit around 99.6% because these coins went straight to collectors in sealed rolls and bags. Almost nobody spent them. Compare that to the 2000–2001 coins that actually circulated and got beat up in cash registers.

But surviving and grading well are two very different things. Virtually all 2004 business strikes sat in Mint rolls for twenty years, coins banging against each other the whole time. PCGS and NGC census data tell the story: MS68 is genuinely scarce, MS68+ is rare, and the combined MS69 population across both mints totals only about 25 coins. That’s condition rarity at its finest — 5.32 million coins exist, but almost none survived roll storage without damage.

Also Read: Top 100 Rarest Silver Dollar Coins Worth Money (Most Expensive)

The Easy Way to Know Your 2004 Sacagawea Dollar Value

To figure out what your 2004 Sacagawea Dollar is worth, you need three things: the mint mark (P, D, or S), the condition grade, and a close look at the surfaces for carbon spots under magnification.

The Coin Identifier and Value App handles this quickly — snap a photo and it identifies your coin’s specs, then pulls current market values from certified population data and recent auction results. No digging through price guides.

2004 Sacagawea Dollar Value Guides

• 2004-P Sacagawea Dollar
• 2004-D Sacagawea Dollar
• 2004-S Proof DCAM Sacagawea Dollar

Three collecting categories here: Philadelphia business strikes, Denver business strikes, and San Francisco proofs.

The P and D coins were sold exclusively to collectors through mint sets and direct purchases. San Francisco only made proofs — struck with specially prepared, polished dies that create mirror fields with frosted design elements. When that frost-to-mirror contrast is strongest, graders call it “DCAM” (Deep Cameo).

Each variety has its own value curve shaped by mintage, preservation quality, demand, and how badly carbon spotting has affected the manganese-brass surfaces.

2004-P Sacagawea Dollar Value

Most people assume a 2.66 million mintage makes this coin common. They’re right — and completely wrong. Common in a roll? Sure. Common at MS69? About a dozen exist.

Circulated examples are worth face value. Average uncirculated pieces sell for around $1.50, and MS63–MS65 coins bring roughly $3–$10. At MS68 you’re looking at approximately $42, and MS68+ jumps sharply because the population drops off a cliff. Only around 25 MS69 specimens exist across both the 2004-P and 2004-D combined per PCGS and NGC census data.

The headline sale is that ANACS MS64 that brought $4,440 at Heritage Auctions in August 2024. That’s roughly 100 times what a normal MS64 sells for. The coin must have had flawless golden surfaces, zero carbon spots, and perfectly placed contact marks. A separate MS69 example sold for $1,380, confirming strong demand for top-tier pieces.

Before you ship anything off for grading, grab a loupe. Even one tiny carbon spot — caused by the manganese-brass alloy reacting with sulfur — will cap your coin below MS67. Professional grading runs $20–$40 per coin depending on service tier, so make sure the surfaces justify the expense.

To better understand this coin’s performance across different quality levels, you can review the Auction Record Chart below for historical pricing data.

The Market Activity section also provides current information on collector interest and trading patterns.

2004-D Sacagawea Dollar Value

Here’s a question worth asking: if the 2004-P and 2004-D have identical mintages, why does the Denver coin hold the higher auction record? Denver struck exactly 2,660,000 pieces — same as Philadelphia. Yet the top 2004-D result is $4,465 for an MS69, compared to $1,380 for the Philly MS69. Small differences in top-pop counts at the extreme end of the grading spectrum create a huge gap in price.

Circulated coins trade at face value. Average uncirculated pieces bring $3 to $5. MS67 specimens run about $21, and the jump to MS68 and above gets steep fast. Nearly all of these dollars spent two decades in Mint rolls picking up bag marks.

If you’re buying at MS68 or above, only buy slabbed coins from PCGS or NGC. Raw coins listed as “MS68” by online sellers are frequently overgraded MS66 or MS67 pieces. You’ll overpay and have nothing to show for it.

The auction record chart below tracks how this coin has performed across grade levels over time.

Current market activity shows ongoing collector interest and recent transaction patterns for this Denver issue.

2004-S Proof DCAM Sacagawea Dollar Value

Want a certified, high-quality Sacagawea dollar without spending much? This is your coin. San Francisco struck 2,965,422 proof pieces, and standard examples run about $7.

PR69 DCAM specimens typically trade in the $15–$20 range. Even PR70 DCAM — a perfect proof — is achievable at reasonable prices. PCGS CoinFacts notes that the 2004-S is “well struck and can be obtained for a very minimal price.” We think it’s one of the best entry points in the series for new collectors.

The “DCAM” designation means Deep Cameo — heavy frost on the raised design elements against deeply mirrored fields. That contrast is what makes proof coins pop visually. Most 2004-S proofs grade between PR68 DCAM and PR69 DCAM.

Worth noting: if you’re chasing the key date in the proof Sacagawea series, it’s the 2008-S with its lower mintage of 2,169,561 pieces. The 2004-S is common by comparison.

The historical auction chart below shows how this proof issue has performed across grade levels.

Current market activity data covers recent transactions and collector engagement with this affordable proof.

2004-S Proof DCAM Sacagawea Dollar Value（Philip N. Diehl Signature）

Philip N. Diehl served as the 35th Director of the U.S. Mint from June 1994 to March 2000. He oversaw the Sacagawea dollar’s launch and that massive $40 million promotional push. These signature varieties are regular 2004-S proofs housed in special holders with Diehl’s authenticated hand-signed autograph on the insert label.

The coin itself is identical to any other 2004-S proof — same 2,965,422 mintage, same striking quality, same DCAM characteristics. You’re paying for the signature.

PR70 DCAM signature varieties typically sell for $55 to $75. That’s a modest bump over standard proofs. These appeal mostly to collectors building complete sets of Mint Director-signed coins or folks who collect autographed numismatic items. Most specimens fall in the PR68–PR69 DCAM range.

Also Read: 17 Rare Dollar Coin Errors List with Pictures (By Year)

Rare 2004 Sacagawea Dollar Error List

Since 2004 was the third straight NIFC year with lower production volumes, documented errors are scarcer than on the massive 2000–2001 runs. But every type of mint error that can happen still can — and when it shows up on a low-mintage issue like the 2004-P or 2004-D, collectors pay attention.

One error type is specific to this series: improperly annealed planchets. Researcher Ken Potter documented these on early Sacagawea dollars. Overheating during production oxidizes the manganese, shifting the surface from golden to deep brown or even black. NGC calls them “Improperly Annealed Planchets,” PCGS calls them “Sintered Planchets,” and ANACS labels them “Improperly Mixed Alloy.” If your 2004 Sacagawea has unusual dark or streaky coloring, don’t dismiss it as toning — it could be this documented error.

1. 2004 Die Crack Errors

Die cracks form when the steel die fractures during use. Metal flows into that crack during striking, leaving a raised line on the finished coin. You’ll usually see these running from the rim toward the center or crossing design elements like letters and the eagle’s wings.

Bigger is better for value. Minor die cracks on 2004 Sacagawea dollars add $10–$50. Major cracks crossing prominent design areas can reach several hundred dollars, especially in MS65 or higher.

2. 2004 Struck Through Errors

A struck-through error happens when something — grease, debris, cloth fiber, a metal filing — lands between the die and the blank planchet during striking. That area of the design comes out depressed or missing entirely.

Grease-filled dies are pretty common and don’t add much unless the affected area is large and obvious. Struck-through errors with clearly missing design on Sacagawea’s portrait or the eagle can bring $100–$500 or more depending on severity and grade.

3. 2004 Die Chip Errors

When a small fragment breaks off the die surface, it leaves a tiny hole that fills with metal during striking. The result is a small raised bump on the coin. You’ll typically find these on letters, numerals, or fine design details.

Larger, more visible chips are worth more — especially on prominent letters in “LIBERTY” or “UNITED STATES OF AMERICA.” Values range from $50 for minor chips to $300 or more for big ones on major design elements in high grades.

4. 2004 Lamination Errors

Impurities — trapped gas, grease, or dirt — get embedded in the planchet metal during rolling. After striking, those weak spots crack, chip, peel, or separate. The manganese-brass composition makes Sacagawea dollars especially prone to this.

Value depends on how dramatic the damage looks. Minor lamination cracking adds $25–$100. Dramatic peeling or splitting across large portions of the surface can command $200–$1,000 or more.

5. 2004 Rotated Die Errors

Hold your coin by the top edge and flip it like a book. The reverse should appear upside down. If it doesn’t — if it’s rotated to some other angle — you’ve got a rotated die error. The bigger the rotation, the bigger the premium.

Minor rotations under 15 degrees add $50–$150. Hit 90 degrees or more and you’re looking at $300–$800 depending on grade and visual impact.

6. 2004 Improperly Annealed Planchet Errors

This one is unique to the Sacagawea series. Overheating the planchets during annealing oxidizes the manganese, turning the golden surface deep brown, chocolate, copper-red, or near-black.

Researcher Ken Potter and Coin World’s Paul Gilkes (citing metallurgist Chris Pilliod of Carpenter Technology) documented these on early Sacagawea dollars. When authenticated by PCGS, NGC, or ANACS with an official error designation on the label, these coins bring $100–$500+ depending on severity and grade. Don’t confuse this with normal environmental toning — the color shift on a genuine annealing error is far more dramatic.

Where to Sell Your 2004 Sacagawea Dollar?

If you think your coin is MS68 or higher, get it graded by PCGS or NGC first. The $20–$40 grading fee pays for itself quickly at that level. Shop your coin around — compare offers from multiple dealers or auction houses like Heritage Auctions and Stack’s Bowers before committing.

Certified coins at MS68+, proof specimens in PR70 DCAM, and documented error varieties with official labels bring the strongest premiums. Raw coins at common grades typically sell for just slightly above face value.

Check out now: Best Places To Sell Coins Online (Pros & Cons)

FAQ About the 2004 Sacagawea Dollar Value

1. Were 2004 Sacagawea dollars ever released into general circulation?

No. 2004 was the third straight NIFC (“Not Intended For Circulation”) year. The Mint sold them directly to collectors in rolls of 25 for $35.50 and bags of 2,000 for approximately $2,490. They never went through banks or the Federal Reserve. If you find one in pocket change, a collector spent it.

2. What makes the 2004 Sacagawea dollar’s MS69 grade so rare?

Only about 25 coins total have graded MS69 across both the 2004-P and 2004-D per combined PCGS and NGC data. Two decades of roll storage left microscopic bag marks on nearly every coin. MS68+ is the practical ceiling for most survivors. Reaching MS69 requires virtually zero contact marks, no carbon spots, and no toning — a combination that almost never survived intact.

3. How can I tell if my 2004 Sacagawea dollar is worth having graded?

Start by checking for errors — die cracks, laminations, off-center strikes. Then examine the surfaces under strong light and 10x magnification for carbon spots (flyspecks). If the coin looks spot-free with minimal bag marks and strong luster, it might be worth a $20–$40 grading submission to PCGS or NGC. Realistically, only MS67 and above returns enough to cover the fee on a 2004 date.

4. What is the composition of the 2004 Sacagawea dollar?

Three-layer clad construction: pure copper core between outer layers of manganese brass. Overall composition is 88.5% copper, 6% zinc, 3.5% manganese, and 2% nickel. Weighs 8.1 grams, measures 26.5mm in diameter, plain (smooth) edge.

5. Why did an ordinary MS64 example sell for $4,440 at Heritage Auctions in 2024?

Normal MS64 examples of the 2004-P bring $10–$50. That August 2024 Heritage result was nearly 100 times the norm. The ANACS-graded coin almost certainly had extraordinary eye appeal — no carbon spots, exceptional golden luster, minimal contact marks, possibly documented provenance. It shows that what a coin looks like can matter far more than the grade number on the holder.

6. What is the Deep Cameo (DCAM) designation on the 2004-S proof?

DCAM stands for “Deep Cameo.” It means the raised design elements (Sacagawea’s portrait, the eagle, the lettering) have a deep frosty white appearance while the flat background fields are intensely mirror-like. That frost-versus-mirror contrast is the most desirable proof finish and commands a premium over standard proof grades. Most 2004-S proofs grade PR68 DCAM or PR69 DCAM.

7. Are carbon spots on a 2004 Sacagawea dollar permanent?

Yes. Those dark flyspecks come from the manganese-brass alloy reacting with atmospheric sulfur and moisture. You cannot remove them without damaging the surface. Attempting to clean the coin will get you a “Details” holder labeled “Cleaned” from PCGS or NGC, which tanks collector value. Never clean a coin. A single visible spot simply means that piece can’t reach MS67 or above.

8. Does the 2004 Sacagawea dollar contain any silver or gold?

No. Zero precious metals. The golden color comes from the manganese-brass outer cladding over a copper core. Melt value is less than $0.08. The 22-karat gold Sacagawea pattern coins that flew on the Space Shuttle in 1999 are an entirely separate thing — you won’t find those in collector sets.

9. What is the Philip N. Diehl Signature variety, and is it worth collecting?

Philip N. Diehl was the 35th Director of the U.S. Mint from June 1994 to March 2000 and oversaw the Sacagawea dollar’s launch. These are standard 2004-S proofs in special holders with Diehl’s authenticated hand-signed autograph on the label. The coin itself is identical to a regular 2004-S proof. PR70 DCAM signature examples sell for $55–$75. They’re mainly for autograph collectors or people building Mint Director signature sets.

10. How does the 2004 Sacagawea dollar compare to other NIFC years for value?

The 2004-P and 2004-D tie for the third-lowest mintage in the NIFC era at 2.66 million each. The lowest belongs to the 2008-P and 2008-D at approximately 1.82 million each — those are the most condition-scarce business strikes. The 2004 issues sit in solid mid-tier territory: above the more plentiful 2002–2003 coins but below the ultra-low-mintage 2005–2008 dates. For proofs, the key date is the 2008-S with 2,169,561 pieces.