1958 Dime Value Checker: Errors List, “D” & No Mint Mark Worth

1958 Dime value ranges from $0.10 face value to $4,200. That record was a Grade 69 example sold on eBay Auctions in April 2023. Upload a photo of yours below for a quick value range based on condition and mint mark. Scroll down to check recent eBay sales and see what collectors are actually paying right now.

 

1958 Dime Value By Variety

This chart shows what 1958 Roosevelt dimes are worth across mint marks and strike types — Philadelphia, Denver, and proof versions in standard, Cameo (CAM), and Deep Cameo (DCAM) finishes, sorted by condition grade.

If you know the grade of your coin, you can find the exact price below in the Value Guides section.

Also Read: Roosevelt Dime Value (1946-Present)

 

Top 10 Most Valuable 1958 Dime Value Records Worth Money

The top spot belongs to a 1958 Philadelphia dime graded MS69 that brought $4,200. That’s a coin struck from the lowest-mintage facility that year, and it survived nearly seven decades in virtually perfect condition. Good luck finding another one.

Below it, multiple MS68 examples from both Philadelphia and Denver fill out the list. A standout is the 1958-P graded NGC MS67+FB (Full Bands), which sold at Heritage Auctions on May 8, 2022 for $3,120 — the auction record for a Philadelphia Full Bands example at that grade. On the Denver side, the all-time record sits at $4,025 for a 1958-D MS68FB, realized at Stack’s Bowers on November 15, 2011. More recently, a 1958-D regular strike in MS68+ moved on eBay for $3,500 in January 2023, proving demand at the top hasn’t cooled off.

The Full Bands (FB) designation is a huge deal here. Full Bands — also called Full Torch Bands — means the horizontal lines separating the torch’s bands on the reverse are fully and completely separated, with no merging or fuzziness, signifying an exceptionally sharp strike. Registry set collectors chase these hard. A high numeric grade plus FB creates a two-factor scarcity that pushes prices well past non-FB equivalents at the same grade.

 

History of the 1958 Dime Value Coin in American Numismatics

The 1958 Roosevelt dime landed right in the middle of the Eisenhower Recession — a sharp downturn running from August 1957 to April 1958. The Philadelphia Mint cut production in response, striking only 31,910,000 pieces. That’s the third-lowest yearly total of the entire silver Roosevelt dime era (1946–1964).

When word got out about the low Philadelphia mintage, people started hoarding them immediately. Here’s the irony: instead of making the coins rare, all that hoarding preserved huge quantities in Mint State up to MS67. The supply stayed plentiful, and that actually stunted value growth for decades.

Denver picked up the slack with 136,564,600 dimes to keep commerce moving. Those got hoarded too — collectors and silver speculators pulled Denver dimes from rolls just as aggressively.

Fun fact: John R. Sinnock’s initials “JS” appear at the base of Roosevelt’s neck on every Roosevelt dime. In the late 1940s, a rumor spread that the initials stood for Joseph Stalin rather than the designer. The Mint had to publicly clarify the attribution.

Most 1958 dimes saw only 10 to 15 years of actual circulation. Rising silver bullion values during the 1960s triggered widespread hoarding of silver coins across all denominations. Each coin contains 90% silver and 10% copper, with 0.0723 troy ounces of pure silver. When silver peaked near $50 per ounce in January 1980, vast quantities got melted for their metal content.

The Coinage Act of 1965 formally ended the silver dime era, authorizing copper-nickel clad replacements. That makes every 1958 dime a genuine silver artifact from a closed chapter of American coinage. Proof versions totaled approximately 875,652 pieces, all struck at Philadelphia. Despite the lower Philadelphia mintage and melting losses, 1958 dimes remain readily available to collectors in various grades.

Also Read: Top 100 Most Valuable Roosevelt Dimes Worth Money List

 

Is Your 1958 Dime Value Hiding a Rare Coin?

For collectors seeking to determine the true rarity and value of their 1958 Dime based on mint mark, grade, and specific varieties, the Coin Identifier and Value App provides essential tools to identify whether your coin is a common circulation piece or a valuable collectible specimen.

 

Key Features of the 1958 Dime Value Coin

The 1958 Dime is part of the Roosevelt dime series designed by Chief Engraver John R. Sinnock. Philadelphia struck only 31,910,000 pieces that year — the third-lowest mintage of the silver era — thanks to the Eisenhower Recession cutting production. All that public hoarding means well-preserved examples are still easy to find today. The Greysheet (CDN Publishing) Catalog currently lists CPG values for Roosevelt dimes ranging from $8.25 for common circulated examples to $5,750 for the finest specimens.

The Obverse of the 1958 Dime

You’ll see a left-facing profile bust of President Franklin D. Roosevelt, the nation’s 32nd president. Numismatist Mark Benvenuto noted that Roosevelt’s portrait looks more natural than most presidential coin designs — closer to an art medal than a typical die-struck likeness.

“LIBERTY” runs along the left side. “IN GOD WE TRUST” sits in smaller letters near the lower left of the portrait. The date “1958” appears on the right, and designer John R. Sinnock’s initials “JS” show at the base of Roosevelt’s neck — those same initials that got falsely linked to Joseph Stalin back in 1946.

The Reverse of the 1958 Dime

Flip it over and you’ll find a torch in the center representing liberty, flanked by an olive branch (peace) on the left and an oak branch (strength and independence) on the right. Together they symbolize the victorious conclusion of World War II and the values Roosevelt championed.

“UNITED STATES OF AMERICA” circles the upper rim. “E PLURIBUS UNUM” stretches across the field above the torch. Look at the base of the torch on the left side — that’s where you’ll find the mint mark (“D” for Denver). Philadelphia coins have no mint mark. The horizontal bands on the torch’s central section are what you need to examine for the Full Bands (FB) designation.

Other Features of the 1958 Dime

The coin maintains a composition of 90% silver and 10% copper, containing 0.0723 troy ounces of pure silver. It has a diameter of 17.90 millimeters, making it the smallest U.S. coin by diameter, with a weight of 2.50 grams and a traditional reeded edge.

Also Read: Top 100 Rarest Dimes Worth Money (Most Expensive)

 

1958 Dime Value Mintage & Survival Data

Philadelphia struck 31,910,000 pieces. Denver cranked out 136,564,600 — roughly four times more. Both saw a brutal 10% survival rate, leaving about 3,191,000 Philly dimes and 13,656,460 Denver dimes still around today. That means nine out of every ten coins got melted, mostly during the silver crisis of the 1960s and the late-1970s price spike.

Proof production totaled 875,652 pieces, all from Philadelphia. Regular proof specimens show a 38.26% survival rate with approximately 335,000 examples remaining. Cameo (CAM) varieties — frosted devices against mirror fields — account for 165,000 survivors (18.84% survival rate). Deep Cameo (DCAM) specimens are the rarest category at roughly 24,000 surviving examples (2.74% survival rate). To put that in perspective, fewer DCAM proofs survive than the population of a small town.

Business strikes are actually scarcer relative to their original production numbers when you adjust for attrition. Denver dominates by raw volume, but proofs survived at much higher rates because collectors tucked them away from day one.

Also Read: Top 70+ Most Valuable Mercury Dimes Worth Money (Chart By Year)

 

The Easy Way to Know Your 1958 Dime Value

Start by checking the mint mark. Flip your coin to the reverse and look at the base of the torch — a “D” means Denver, no mint mark means Philadelphia. Philadelphia made only 31.9 million versus Denver’s 136.5 million, though both trade at similar prices in circulated condition.

Every 1958 dime contains 90% silver (0.0723 troy ounces), so there’s always a melt value floor that moves with the daily silver spot price. Beyond that, condition is everything. Grading follows the Sheldon scale from 1 (Poor) to 70 (Perfect Mint State), developed by Dr. William H. Sheldon and first published in his 1958 reference book Penny Whimsy.

Average circulated pieces run $2 to $5. Uncirculated examples can hit $12 to $60 or more depending on grade. Look for sharp strike details on Roosevelt’s cheek and hair, full original mint luster with no dullness, and clean focal areas free of bag marks.

The biggest value booster? Full Bands on the reverse torch. You need both horizontal bands fully separated with a visible gap between them. Philadelphia historically struggled with this in 1958 — most 1958-P dimes left the facility with fuzzy bands, so genuine FB examples are a real step up. I think the FB designation is one of the most underappreciated premiums in the Roosevelt series.

Professional grading from PCGS (Professional Coin Grading Service) or NGC (Numismatic Guaranty Company) in tamper-evident holders makes high-value coins far more marketable. Proof versions, especially Deep Cameo (DCAM) specimens, sit at the top of the value ladder thanks to limited survival and that dramatic frosted-on-mirror look.

For a quick, accurate read on your coin’s value, the Coin Identifier and Value App handles the heavy lifting for you.

 

1958 Dime Value Guides

• 1958 No Mint Mark — Philadelphia business strike, 31,910,000 minted
• 1958-D — Denver business strike, 136,564,600 minted
• 1958 Proof — Philadelphia collector issue, 875,652 minted
• 1958 Proof Cameo (CAM) — Enhanced contrast proof with frosted devices against mirror fields
• 1958 Proof Deep Cameo (DCAM) — Premium proof with maximum frosted contrast, rarest survival rate

Five distinct categories here. Business strikes from Philadelphia and Denver are the standard circulation coins. Proofs were made for collectors, with increasing levels of visual pop. CAM requires noticeable frosting on the devices. DCAM demands heavy white frosting against deeply reflective mirror fields — and those are the hardest to find by a wide margin.

 

1958 Dime Value: No Mint Mark Philadelphia Issue

Only 31,910,000 struck — and that’s the number that gets collectors excited. This is the third-lowest mintage of the entire silver Roosevelt dime series, produced after Philadelphia deliberately scaled back from its 1957 overproduction.

Circulated examples run $3 to $5. Uncirculated pieces range from $7 at MS60 up to about $250 at MS68. The auction record belongs to an NGC MS67+FB specimen that sold at Heritage Auctions on May 8, 2022 for $3,120 — far above the estimated value for that grade. That’s the highest Full Bands grade ever awarded by a major service to a 1958-P dime.

Pay close attention to the Full Bands sub-variety. Philadelphia routinely produced 1958 dimes with sloppy torch strikes. Most left the facility with merged or indistinct horizontal bands. Only the well-struck coins showing complete band separation earn the FB designation, and those command real premiums at every grade above MS64.

During the 1980s silver surge to $50 per ounce, plenty of 1958 dimes got melted. Nobody knows exactly how many MS65+ pieces were lost, which makes true population data at top grades a guessing game.

To understand this coin’s price performance, you can reference the auction record chart below.

Additionally, the market activity data can help you gauge current collector interest in this vintage.

 

1958 Dime Value: Denver D Mint Mark Edition

Can a coin with a mintage over 136 million sell for four grand? It already has. The all-time Full Bands record is $4,025 for a 1958-D MS68FB at Stack’s Bowers on November 15, 2011. The top regular strike record stands at $3,500 for an MS68+ example sold on eBay in January 2023.

The “D” mint mark sits on the reverse at the base of the torch, left side. Denver produced 136,564,600 of these — more than four times Philadelphia’s output. Circulated examples trade in the $3 to $4 range. MS60 starts around $7, and MS68 regular strikes jump to about $550. That’s a huge gap between grades.

Like Philadelphia, Denver struggled with consistent Full Bands strikes in 1958. Most 1958-D dimes have partially merged or fuzzy torch bands, so well-struck FB examples are a genuine premium sub-variety worth cherrypicking. At MS65, MS66, and MS67, regular strikes run roughly $15, $25, and $40 respectively.

Each coin holds 0.0723 troy ounces of pure silver, giving you a built-in melt value floor. Specimens graded MS67 and below are easy to find at modest prices today, but the MS68+ tier is thin. We think that’s where the real upside potential sits for patient collectors.

To understand this coin’s historical price performance across different grades, you can reference the auction record chart below.

Additionally, market activity data can help you gauge this coin’s current trading frequency and collector interest level.

 

1958 Dime Value: Proof Collector Edition

What if you never had to worry about circulation wear? That’s the whole point of proof coins. The 1958 Proof Roosevelt Dime was struck using polished dies and hand-selected planchets (blank discs), producing deeply mirrored fields and razor-sharp details you won’t see on business strikes. This coin is part of the proof series that began in 1950 as an annual collector offering sold directly by the U.S. Mint.

Standard proofs trade in the $5 to $9 range for PR60 to PR66 examples. Easy entry point. Above PR67, things get tighter — even carefully stored proofs picked up subtle hairlines from coin-to-coin contact over the decades.

The proof mintage of 875,652 is low by modern standards. Every one of these is a finite, irreplaceable piece of 1950s silver production. Series collectors building complete year sets keep steady demand on this date.

To understand the historical price fluctuations of proof coins across different grades, you can reference the auction record chart below.

Additionally, market activity data can help you track this coin’s trading patterns in the collecting community.

 

1958 Dime Value: Proof Cameo (CAM) Variety

Here’s a common misconception: people assume all 1958 proofs look the same. They don’t. Only specimens with enough contrast between Roosevelt’s frosted portrait and the mirrored background earn the CAM (Cameo) classification. That frosted-on-mirror look gives the coin a three-dimensional, almost photographic quality.

Why are they scarce? In the 1950s, dies were treated with a solution of roughly 95% alcohol and 5% nitric acid to create frosted devices, then the fields were polished for contrast. Problem is, the frosting wore off fast during striking. Only the earliest impressions from each die pair had enough contrast to qualify as CAM.

Making things worse, nobody in 1958 cared about cameo contrast. PCGS and NGC didn’t formally establish Cameo and Deep Cameo designations until the 1990s. Collectors spent or stored these superior strikes alongside regular proofs, completely unaware they were a different tier.

About 130,000 CAM examples survive today — roughly a 14.8% survival rate from the original 875,652 proof mintage. Values range from approximately $8.25 at PR63 to $275 at PR69. That’s an 80–160% premium over non-cameo proofs depending on grade. PR69 examples are genuinely tough to track down.

For collectors tracking this coin’s market performance across different grades, the auction record chart below provides valuable historical price trends.

Additionally, current market activity data reveals ongoing collector interest in this distinctive cameo variety.

 

1958 Dime Value: Proof Deep Cameo (DCAM) Variety

A 0.43% survival rate. Let that sink in. From 875,652 proofs struck, roughly 3,750 survive with the Deep Cameo designation. That’s a completely different kind of rare compared to standard proofs or even CAM varieties.

DCAM demands maximum contrast — heavily frosted devices against brilliant mirror fields. Only the first handful of impressions from a freshly prepared die could produce this effect before the delicate frosting eroded. Mint workers in 1958 had no idea these early strikes were anything special.

Prices reflect the scarcity. Values run from approximately $35 at PR63 to $2,250 at PR69 — a 64x multiplier from bottom to top. A documented 2013 auction saw a PR69DCAM example bring $2,585, confirming what the finest known specimens can reach.

Most survivors grade PR64–PR66. Finding a PR67+ is a real hunt — these rarely show up in routine dealer inventory or auction lots. I consider DCAM proofs the sleeper play of the 1958 Roosevelt series. You’ve got absolute scarcity, dramatic eye appeal, and 90% silver content all working together.

The auction record chart detailed below tracks the performance of various grades and varieties across the marketplace.

Market activity data demonstrates steady collector engagement throughout the year.

Also Read: 16 Rare Dime Errors List with Pictures (By Year)

 

Rare 1958 Dime Value Error List

Error coins are where cherrypicking really pays off. The 1958 Roosevelt Dime — struck in 90% silver at Philadelphia and Denver — occasionally left the mint with manufacturing mistakes that now boost their value well beyond melt or standard grade prices.

These range from dramatic off-center strikes to subtle doubled mint marks. Every one of them documents a moment when something went wrong on the production floor — and in 1958, the process was far more manual and error-prone than today’s automated minting.

1. 1958 Clipped Planchet Error

This happens when the coin blank — the planchet — gets improperly cut from the silver strip. A misaligned or overlapping punch during blanking leaves a missing curved or straight section on the finished coin’s edge. Mint State examples can reach about $30, with bigger, more dramatic clips bringing more.

Where the clip lands matters. A clip that chops into a major design element or removes a big chunk of the rim is more desirable than a tiny edge nibble. Plus you’re getting the error premium on top of the silver content — value on two counts.

2. 1958 Repunched Mint Mark (RPM) Error

This one only shows up on 1958-D dimes since Philadelphia coins had no mint mark. Back then, mint workers hand-punched the “D” onto working dies. If the punch landed twice in slightly different spots, you get a doubled or shadowed appearance around the D.

RPM varieties typically trade for $5 to $30 in circulated grades. Grab at least 5x magnification and examine the reverse at the base of the torch. This variety is a closed chapter — hand-punching of mint marks onto working dies was discontinued in 1990 when the U.S. Mint started hubbing mint marks directly into master dies.

3. 1958-D/D Dime (D Over D) RPM Variety

Think of this as the RPM’s bigger brother. The die received a second “D” punch at a noticeably different angle or position, creating a clearly visible secondary “D” overlapping the primary mint mark. No magnification mystery here — you can often spot it with a basic loupe.

Uncirculated examples sell in the $20 to $45 range. The premium climbs with the visibility and separation of that secondary D. Roosevelt dime specialists building RPM type sets across the silver era actively hunt these.

4. 1958 Off-Center Strike Error

When the planchet isn’t centered between the dies at the moment of striking, the design shifts to one side and leaves a blank crescent on the other. Minor 5–10% off-center examples are common. The real prizes are 50%+ off-center strikes where the date is still readable.

How dramatic can it get? A 1958 dime struck approximately 70% off-center sold at Heritage Auctions in 2022 for $240 in MS63 condition. It showed only partial date digits and about half of Roosevelt’s portrait. No date visible? Much less demand. Always check for legible year digits before getting excited.

5. 1958 Dime Die Clash Error

A die clash happens when the obverse and reverse dies smack into each other with no planchet in between. Each die picks up a mirror image of the other’s design. Coins struck afterward show faint “ghost” outlines — maybe a partial torch on the obverse, or Roosevelt’s profile ghosting onto the reverse.

These add a modest $15 to $50 premium over standard values in circulated grades. Dramatic, clearly visible clashes in Mint State bring stronger premiums. You’ll need magnification to confirm them, but they’re fun to hunt for because each one documents a specific production mishap.

 

Where to Sell Your 1958 Dime Value Coin

Whether you choose online marketplaces, local coin shops, or dedicated auction platforms, always research current market values before selling and consider having high-grade or error specimens professionally authenticated by PCGS or NGC to ensure you receive fair compensation for your 1958 Roosevelt dime’s true worth.

Check out now: Best Places To Sell Coins Online (Pros & Cons)

 

1958 Dime Value Market Trend

*Market Trend Chart showing the number of people paying attention to this coin.

 

FAQ About the 1958 Dime Value

1. What is my 1958 dime value if it’s in average circulated condition?

About $3 to $5, driven mostly by the 90% silver content (0.0723 troy ounces). Both Philadelphia (no mint mark) and Denver (D) varieties trade at similar prices in worn condition since the silver melt value sets the floor.

2. What does “Full Bands” mean and how does it affect 1958 dime value?

Full Bands (FB) refers to the complete separation of the two horizontal bands crossing the torch on the reverse — when both bands are fully separated with a visible gap and no merging, the coin qualifies for the FB designation. This designation can double or triple the value of a 1958 dime compared to a non-FB example at the same numeric grade, since both the Philadelphia and Denver Mints struggled to consistently produce sharp Full Bands strikes in 1958.

3. What is the highest price a 1958 dime has ever sold for?

$4,200 for a Philadelphia specimen graded MS69. For Full Bands, the Philadelphia record is $3,120 for an NGC MS67+FB sold at Heritage Auctions on May 8, 2022. Denver’s record is $4,025 for a PCGS MS68FB sold at Stack’s Bowers on November 15, 2011.

4. What is the difference between a 1958 dime Cameo and Deep Cameo proof?

A Cameo (CAM) proof has noticeable frosting on the design elements (devices) against mirrored fields, creating two-tone contrast. A Deep Cameo (DCAM) proof has maximum, dramatic frosting — described as “white on mirror” — and is significantly rarer, with only about 3,750 surviving examples from the 875,652 total proof mintage (a 0.43% survival rate), compared to roughly 130,000 CAM survivors.

5. Is a 1958 dime with no mint mark rarer than a 1958-D dime?

By production numbers, yes — 31,910,000 versus 136,564,600. But both were heavily hoarded, and both trade at similar prices in circulated condition. Below MS67, there are enough surviving examples of each to keep premiums comparable.

6. How do I identify a 1958-D/D repunched mint mark variety?

Check the “D” on the reverse at the base of the torch under at least 5x to 10x magnification. You’re looking for a second, partially overlapping or offset “D” impression — extra lines or a shadowed second letter at the top, bottom, or sides of the D. This variety adds roughly $20 to $45 in value for uncirculated examples.

7. Why did the Coinage Act of 1965 affect my 1958 dime’s value?

The Coinage Act of 1965 formally ended 90% silver composition in U.S. dimes, replacing them with copper-nickel clad coins. That made every pre-1965 dime — including all 1958 dimes — a silver relic from a closed era, establishing a permanent floor value based on precious metal content and boosting collector interest across the entire 1946–1964 silver Roosevelt dime series.

8. What errors should I look for to increase my 1958 dime value?

The big ones: off-center strikes (the more dramatic the better, with date visible) — a 70% off-center MS63 example sold at Heritage Auctions for $240 in 2022; clipped planchets worth up to $30 in Mint State; repunched mint marks (RPM/D over D) on Denver coins worth $5 to $45; die clash errors showing ghost outlines; and doubled die obverse/reverse (DDO/DDR) varieties showing doubling on letters or numerals.

9. How should I properly store my 1958 silver dime to preserve its value?

Keep it in a cool, dry spot using inert, PVC-free holders, capsules, or hard plastic slabs. Never touch the surfaces directly — skin oils cause permanent spotting on silver. And whatever you do, don’t clean it. Cleaning strips original luster and tanks both the grade and value.

10. Is it worth submitting my 1958 dime to PCGS or NGC for grading?

If your coin looks MS65 or higher with Full Bands, or it’s a proof in PR66+ condition, absolutely. Grading fees run $20 to $40 per coin for standard service. Certified MS67+FB examples can sell for $200 to $3,120 depending on grade and service, so the math works strongly in your favor for any potentially high-grade or notable error specimen.