Rare 2009 Penny Errors Worth Money (Full List)

Do you want to collect 2009 pennies but wonder if it is worth it? Are 2009 pennies worth any money? Well, you have come to the right place because our 2009 penny errors list will reveal everything you need to know about collecting high-value 2009 penny errors.

The United States Mint launched the Bicentennial One Cent Program in 2009. The one-year program commemorated the 200th anniversary of President Abraham Lincoln and celebrated the 100th anniversary of the launch of the Lincoln cent, first introduced in 1909.

As part of the program, the Mint launched four pennies each with its own reverse design, representing important themes in Lincoln’s life. The designs include:

  • Lincoln’s Birth and Early Childhood- Kentucky (1809-1816)
  • Lincoln’s Formative Years- Indiana (1816-1830)
  • Lincoln’s Professional- Illinois (1830-1861)
  • Lincoln’s Presidency- Washington, DC (1861-1865)

Despite their popularity and historical significance, 2009 pennies are only worth their face value in circulated condition. Even uncirculated specimens are affordable and easily accessible to any collector.

If you want to add high-value 2009 pennies to your collection, collecting errors is the way to go! Error coins can be worth hundreds and even thousands; they can significantly improve the value of your collection!

Our 2009 penny errors list will come in handy on your journey to collecting Lincoln pennies worth money. Let’s jump in and get started!

1. 2009-P MS62 Lincoln Penny Birth and Early Childhood Re-Punched Mint Mark Error

One of the errors you might come across when collecting 2009 Lincoln pennies is the re-punched mint mark.  As the name suggests, this is an error in which the mint mark on the obverse is struck multiple times at different angles.

A re-punched mint mark error will show visible doubling or overlapping on the mint mark itself. Sometimes, the die might punch the primary mint mark in one direction and the secondary mint mark in a different direction.

 How much you can expect from a re-punched mint mark largely depends on the coin’s condition. Pennies in mint state with a re-punched mint mark error will generally be worth more than their circulated counterparts.

For example, in 2017, Heritage Auctions sold a 2009-P Lincoln penny graded MS62 with a re-punched mint mark error for $312, which is quite impressive for such an error.

 

2. 2009-D MS65 Lincoln Penny Presidency Misaligned Die Penny Error

Another error that comes up in the 2009 penny series is the misaligned die. This is an error in which there is an offset between the obverse and reverse designs on the penny.

Ideally, the obverse and reverse design are centered and aligned. But, sometimes, technical or human faults can cause a misalignment in the dies, resulting in the design on either side being struck at a rotated angle instead of it being upright and centered.

For example, you might find, because of the die misalignment, the obverse design is rotated at an angle in relation to the reverse design. 

The value of a misaligned die error depends on the extent of misalignment. A coin with a large degree of misalignment will generally be worth more than one with a slight misalignment.

Free Coin Appraisal & Sell

In 2019, a collector on eBay paid $620 for a 2009-D Lincoln penny graded MS65 with a misaligned die error, making this a worthwhile addition to your collection.

 

3. 2009-D MS65 Lincoln Presidency Penny Broad-Struck Error

The next error on our 2009 penny errors list is the broad-struck error. This error occurs when the die strikes the planchet outside the collar, resulting in a malformed coin that can be worth a fortune.

Usually, the collar holds the planchet, helping to define its diameter during the striking process. Sometimes, though, part of the planchet might sit outside the collar and when struck, it results in a coin with an extended diameter and thinned out edge on one side.

A broad-struck will still retain all the design details on the obverse and reverse. Without a doubt, this is one of the most dramatic errors you will come across when collecting 2009 pennies.

In 2020, Heritage Auctions sold a 2009-D Lincoln penny graded MS65 with a broad-struck error for an impressive $650.

 

4. 2009-D MS60 Lincoln Penny Formative Years Lamination Crack Error

Another error to look out for is the lamination crack, not to be confused with a die crack error.  A lamination crack error typically occurs during the planchet-making process and involves actual cracking of the planchet’s upper layer.

The presence of impurities in the alloy can create a weakness, causing cracks to appear on the planchet. Lamination cracks can be vertical but most of the time, these cracks are lateral.

Larger, dramatic or peculiar-looking lamination cracks will generally fetch more in the coin market. In 2020, the Great Collection auctioned a 2009-D Lincoln penny with an MS60 grading and an obverse lamination crack error for a whopping $410.

 

5. 2009-P MS63 Off-Center Strike Lincoln Penny Professional Error

An off-center strike is another error worth adding to your collection. This error occurs when the die strikes the design away from the center and more toward the edge.

Slight movements in the die setup or planchet can cause the die to strike away from the center.  Due to the uneven striking, some of the design elements might be cut off from the coin.

How much you can expect from a penny with an off-center strike depends on the off-ness percentage. The greater the percentage, the more valuable the coin will tend to be. For example, a penny with a 45% off-center will generally be worth more than one with a 15% off-center strike.

Find best coin dealer near me

In 2021, an eBay collector paid $812 for a 2009-P Lincoln penny graded MS63 with a 30% off-center strike error, making this a nice addition to your collection.

 

6. 2009-D MS60 Lincoln Presidency Bicentennial Die Gouge Penny Error

2009-D MS60 Lincoln Presidency Bicentennial Die Gouge Penny Error

Die gouges appear like vertical, raised areas on the coin’s surface (sometimes gouges can be lateral). This error occurs when an object digs into the die’s surface and is dragged across the planchet during the striking process.

Larger, more visible die gouges will generally be worth more than smaller ones. Of course, the value will also depend on other factors such as the coin’s condition.

At a 2021 sale, Heritage Auctions sold a 2009-D Lincoln penny graded MS60 with a die gouge error on the obverse for $520. This would definitely be a worthwhile addition to your collection.

Check More Details

 

7. 2009-P MS61 Lincoln Penny Birth and Early Childhood Die Crack Error

2009-P MS61 Lincoln Penny Birth and Early Childhood Die Crack Error

Another error you might come across when collecting 2009 pennies is the die crack. This error occurs like a raised line on the coin’s surface, with larger cracks being more valuable.

A die crack occurs when a crack appears on the coin’s surface and is gradually filled with small metal pieces as the die continues to be put to use.

Eventually, after several strikes, the metal-filled crack will leave its impression on the planchet. As mentioned, a die crack will appear like a raised line on the coin’s surface.

Large, dramatic, or peculiar die cracks—these will tend to fetch more. In 2020, the Great Collection auctioned a 2009-P Lincoln penny graded MS60 with a die crack error on the obverse and reverse for an impressive $630.

Check More Details

 

Free Coin Appraisal & Sell

8. 2009-P MS60 Lincoln Penny Formative Years Clashed Die Error

A die clash is next on our 2009 penny errors list. As the name suggests, this error occurs when the obverse and reverse dies clash against each other without the planchet between them.

Because the dies clash against each other with great force, they may end up transferring their respective designs onto each other and this is then impressed on the planchet. For example, the planchet may show the primary obverse design and a hint of the reverse design on the same side.

This is definitely an error worth adding to your collection as it often fetches good money. For example, in 2020, a collector on eBay paid $615 for a 2009-P Lincoln penny graded MS60 with an obverse side die clash error.

 

9. 2009-P MS64 Lincoln Penny Professional Feeder Finger Error

Another error you might encounter when collecting 2009 pennies is the feeder finger. This error occurs when the feeder fingers are struck between the die and planchet.

Ideally, the feeder fingers should automatically retract after positioning the planchet in the collar. But, technical faults in the minting press can delay the automatic retraction, causing the die to come down on the feeder fingers.

On the final coin, a feeder finger error will appear like lateral scratches on the coin’s surface. The more visible the scratches, the more valuable the coin will tend to be.

At a 2020 sale, the Great Collections sold a 2009-P Lincoln penny graded MS64 with a feeder finger error for a whopping $710, making this an error worth pursuing.

 

Find best coin dealer near me

10. 2009-P Lincoln Cent Formative Years Doubled Die Error

2009-P Lincoln Cent Formative Years Doubled Die Error

Last but not least is the doubled die error, one of the most common and easiest to collect in the 2009 penny series.

This error occurs when the die strikes the planchet multiple times at slightly different angles, causing doubling or overlapping on the inscriptions or devices on the obverse, reverse or both sides.

A doubled die error can be worth good money especially if the doubling is intense and the coin is in mint condition. For example, a formative years 2009-P Lincoln cent graded MS64 with an obverse/reverse doubled die error was auctioned for an impressive $500 at a 2022 Heritage Auctions sale.

Check More Details

 

Summary

Collecting 2009 pennies can be rewarding due to the coin’s commemorative value. But, ordinary circulated pennies might not fetch you much—collecting errors is the way to go if you want to collect high value-pennies. Hopefully, with our 2009 penny errors list you can start collecting popular penny errors worth good money. Happy collecting!

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *