Rare 2009 Dime Errors Worth Money (Full List)

Are you looking to collect high-value Roosevelt dimes? Are dimes even worth collecting? Whether you are a new hobbyist or experienced collector, we wrote this 2009 dime errors list revealing a rewarding and exciting way to collect dimes.

Roosevelt dimes in circulated condition are only worth their face value. Even uncirculated specimens are affordable and will suit most collectors’ budgets. If you are looking for unique dimes worth good money, try collecting dime errors!

Errors can be worth hundreds of dollars but it isn’t surprising to come across others that are worth thousands! That’s right—if you know what to look for, you can significantly increase the value of your collection with the right kind of error coins.

So, without further ado, let’s jump into our 2009 dime errors list and discover Roosevelt dimes worth money.

1. 2009-P MS62 Roosevelt Dime Feeder Finger Scrapes Error

One of the errors you might come across when collecting 2009 dimes is the feeder finger. This error occurs when the feeder fingers are struck between the die and planchet, resulting in scrapes or scratches on the coin’s surface.

Usually, the feeder fingers, which position the planchet in the collar retract automatically. But technical errors may slow down or prevent them from retracting, allowing the die to come down on the fingers.

Feeder fingers will leave scratch-like marks on the coin’s surface. Larger, more visible scratch marks will generally be worth more than faint ones that require a keener eye to notice.

In 2020, the Great Collection sold a 2009-P Roosevelt dime graded MS62 with a feeder finger error for a whopping $615, making this an error worth pursuing.

Check More Details

 

2. 2009-P MS62 Roosevelt Dime Die Clash Error

Another error that comes up in the 2009 dime series is the die clash. As the name suggests, a die clash error is one in which the obverse and reverse dies strike against each other without a planchet in between them.

The two dies clash with great force and might transfer their design onto each other. When a planchet is eventually placed between the dies, it receives an impression of both the obverse and reverse dies. For example, you might notice that the planchet has the primary obverse design and a subtle hint of the reverse design on the obverse side.

A die clash is one of the most dramatic errors you might encounter and can therefore fetch good money. Take for example this 2009-P dime graded MS62 with a reverse die clash error for which an eBay collector paid $390.

Also read: Top 17 Most Valuable Roosevelt Dimes Worth Money

 

3. 2009-D MS65 Roosevelt Dime Struck Through Cloth Error

Next on our list is the struck through, a dramatic error that can also be worth a fortune. There are several types of struck-through errors but all occur the same way.

This error occurs when a stray object is struck between the die and planchet. The object may fall off or stick to the planchet but will leave its impression on the planchet’s surface. When the object sticks to the planchet, the error is known as a retained struck through.

Common objects that may come between the die and planchet include small pieces of cloth, wires, metals, dust, hair strands, strings, grease and other debris.

In 2021, the Great Collection auctioned a 2009-P dime graded MS65 with a cloth struck-through error for an impressive $705. This would definitely make a great addition to your collection.

 

4. 2009-P MS60 Roosevelt Dime Improper Alloy Mix Error

Another interesting error that comes up in the 2009 dime series is the improper alloy mix. This is an error in which the metals making up the alloy that constructs the planchets are disproportionately mixed.

The wrong proportions can result in significant color changes in the planchet. For example, if the zinc component is excessive in a copper-zinc alloy coin, the coin may take on a brassy appearance.

In addition to disproportionate mixing, poor mixing of the metals can result in an error in which the coin has dark and light parts.

An improper alloy mix error coin is quite rare but not impossible to come across. If you are lucky enough to own such a coin, you could sell it for good money. For example, Heritage Auction sold a 2009-P MS60 Roosevelt dime with an improper alloy mix for an enviable $575.

5. 2009-D MS62 Dime Die Adjustment Strike Error

A die adjustment strike is a relatively rare error and will only be worth good money if the coin is uncirculated with a high-grade rating. This error occurs as a result of low pressure when the die strikes the planchet.

During the coin-minting process, the die is adjusted to ensure proper striking. This first strike after the adjustment can result in a weak strike but subsequent strikes may also be weak in case of improper die adjustment. Usually, the edge details or inscriptions are missing on a coin with a die adjustment strike error.

A collector at an online auction paid $315 for a 2009-D Roosevelt dime graded MS62 with a die adjustment strike error.

Also read: Top 17 Most Valuable Mercury Dimes Worth Money

 

6. 2009-D MS64 Roosevelt dime Grease Struck Through Error

A grease struck through error occurs when a layer of grease is struck between the die and planchet. Drops of grease can find their way into the minting press, landing on the planchet or die.

The presence of grease can prevent the die from fully transferring its design onto the planchet, resulting in a weak, smudgy strike. If you come across a dime, especially, one in mint state with a weak strike, it is likely a result of a grease struck-through error.

In 2020, an eBay collector paid a whopping $420 for a 2009-D graded MS64 with an obverse grease struck-through error.

 

7. 2009-P MS62 MS63 Roosevelt Dime Lamination Error

There are various types of lamination errors, with the lamination crack being the most common. Lamination errors generally occur due to impurities in the alloy during the planchet-making process. The impurities may cause peeling, bubbling, or cracking on the planchet’s upper layer.

In the case of a lamination crack, impurities may cause cracking on the planchet’s upper layer with the crack lifting on one or both sides. When the crack lifts on both sides, the result can be a clamshell lamination error.

Lamination errors can be quite valuable. For the example, in 2020 Heritage Auctions sold a 2009-P Roosevelt dime graded MS63 with an obverse lamination crack error for an enviable $865.

 

8. 2009-P MS 60 Roosevelt Dime Struck Off Center 5% Error

Another error you might encounter is the off-center strike. This error occurs when the die strikes the coin away from the center and more toward the edge, usually due to a misalignment between the die and planchet.

Ideally, the dies strike and impress their obverse and reverse designs at the center of the coin. But a slight misalignment can cause the designs to appear more toward the coin’s edge. As a result, coins with an off-center strike will usually have a portion of the design missing.

The value of an off-center strike error will mostly depend on the percentage of the strike. For example, a dime with a 30% off-center strike will generally be worth more than one with a 15% off strike.

At a 2022 sale, the Great Collection auctioned a 2009-P dime graded MS60 with a 5% off-center strike for $450, making this relatively rare error an excellent addition to your collection.

Also read: 13 Most Valuable Dime Errors Worth Money

 

9. 2009-D MS65 Roosevelt Dime With Improperly Annealed Error

The next one on our 2009 dime errors list is the improperly annealed error. If you come across a dime with an unusual color it is probably due to an improperly annealed error.

Annealing is the heating and cooling of the planchet, readying it for minting. Anomalies in the cooling and heating process can cause color changes on the planchet. So instead of the dime taking on its usual silver color, it may appear brownish, black, purplish, grey, or even acquire an orange, yellow, or purplish toning.

In uncirculated condition improperly annealed dimes can be worth a fortune. Take for example this 2009-D Roosevelt dime graded MS65 with improper annealing, which the Great Collection sold for a whopping $978 at a 2021 auction.

 

10. 2009-D MS64 Obverse Doubled Die Error

A doubled die is one of the most common error you will come across when collecting 2009 Roosevelt dimes. This is an error in which the inscriptions and devices on either or both sides show visible doubling.

Doubled die errors occur when the die strikes the planchet at slightly different angles multiple times. Coins with strong doubling will generally be worth more.

In 2023, a collector on eBay paid $703 for a 2009-D dime graded MS64 with an obverse doubled die error.

 

Summary

There are plenty of ways to collect Roosevelt dimes but one of the most rewarding is collecting errors. As our 2009 dime errors list shows, these coins can be worth a fortune if you know what to look for. You will increase the value of your stash by focusing on uncirculated, mint-state specimen with unique errors. What are you waiting for? Start collecting your 2009 dime errors today!