Rare 2004 Dime Errors Worth Money (Full List)

Are 2004 dimes worth anything? Are 2004 Roosevelt dimes rare? If you are considering collecting valuable Roosevelt dimes, you’ve come to the right place! Our 2004 dime errors list will reveal some of the most profitable dimes to add to your collection.

In 2004, the United States Mint produced more than 2 billion Roosevelt dimes at the Philadelphia and Denver mints combined. Due to the sheer number produced, 2004 dimes are very common and easy to find and are only worth their face value. Even at grade MS66, these coins are easily accessible but become scarce at grade MS68 and above.

So, does this mean Roosevelt dimes are not worth collecting? Of course not! With the right strategy, you can build a high-value dimes collection. One such strategy is collecting errors—minting errors are rare but they can be worth a fortune.

If you know what to look for, error coins can significantly boost the value of your dimes collection. Our 2004 dime errors list will reveal some of the most valuable errors worth adding to your collection. Read on for all the details so you can start collecting dime errors worth a premium.

1. 2004-P MS64 Dime Off Struck Error

When collecting 2004 dimes, you might come across examples with an off-struck or off-center strike error. As the name implies, an off-center strike error is one in which the design on the obverse, reverse or both sides of the coin is struck away from the center and more towards the coin’s edge.

An off-center strike occurs when there is a misalignment between the die and planchet resulting in a slight shift in the position of the coin’s design. Usually, when the planchet and die are aligned, the design appears squarely in the middle but a slight misalignment will cause a shift in the design’s position.

An off-center strike may also result in some of the coin’s design elements missing. The value of such an error mostly depends on the extent to which the design is struck away from the center. The greater the extent of off-ness, the more valuable the coin tends to be.

In a 2008 Heritage Auctions sale, a collector paid $1230 for a 2004-P dime graded MS64 with a 45% off-center strike error, making this one of the most valuable dimes to add to your collection.

Also read: Top 17 Most Valuable Roosevelt Dimes Worth Money

 

2. 2004-D MS64 Red Copper Color Improperly Annealed Dime Error

Another error you might encounter in the 2004 dimes series is the improperly annealed, also known as sintered planchet error.

Annealing is the heating and cooling of the planchet to harden and soften it in preparation for striking. Excessive exposure to heat or cold can be detrimental to the alloy used to make the planchet, resulting in significant color changes.

In the case of a Roosevelt dime, which would ordinarily have a silver appearance, improper annealing would change the coin into a different color such as red, black, grey or even purple, yellow and orange.

In one instance, improper annealing changed the dime to a copper red color, resulting in an annealing dime error. So how much can you expect from such an error? Well, collectors are willing to pay a fortune for such a coin especially if it is uncirculated.

For example, in a 2010 Heritage Auctions sale, a collector paid a whopping $830 for a 2004-D dime graded MS64 with an improperly annealed error in which the planchet has turned into a red copper color.

Check More Details

 

3. 2004-D MS65 Roosevelt Dime Doubled Die Errors

A doubled die is one of the most common errors you might encounter in the 2004 dimes series. This error occurs when the die strikes the planchet at different angles multiple times resulting in visible doubling on the devices and inscriptions.

A doubled die error may occur on the obverse, reverse or both sides of the coin. The more intense the doubling the more valuable such an error tends to be.

In 2008, a collector on eBay paid a whopping $990 for a 2004-D dime graded MS65 with an obverse and reverse doubled die error, making this a worthwhile addition to your collection.

 

4. 2004-D MS63 Roosevelt Dime Re-Punched Mint Mark Error

The next error we’ll look at is the re-punched mint mark, which can be worth a premium. As the name implies, a re-punched mint mark error is one in which the mint mark has been punched on the planchet more than once.

Often, the re-punched mint mark will have an overlapping appearance that makes it look like it was struck multiple times at different angles.

A re-punched mintmark is not the same as another related error in which two different mint marks are struck, one on top of another. Still, an RPM is a sought-after error that collectors are willing to pay good money for.

In 2020, the Great Collections auctioned a 2004-D Roosevelt dime graded MS63 with a re-punched mint mark error for a record $780, making this another worthwhile error to add to your Roosevelt dime collection.

Also read: Top 17 Most Valuable Mercury Dimes Worth Money

 

5. 2004-D MS65 Roosevelt Dime “Woodie” Improper Alloy Mix Error

When collecting 2004 dimes, you might encounter a coin with a wood grain look on the obverse or reverse. Collectors often refer to such coins as woodies and they can be worth some good money.

The wooden grain appearance on some dimes comes about due to the alloys used to make the coin not being properly mixed during the planchet-making process. Improper mixing results in the coin developing an uneven texture.

In 2009, a collector at an eBay auction paid an impressive $550 for a 2004-D Roosevelt dime graded MS65 with a Woodie error resulting from an improper alloy mix.

Check More Details

 

6. 2004-P MS65 Roosevelt Dime Double Struck Error

The next error on our list is the double struck. As the name suggests, a double struck error is one in which the die strikes the planchet twice, creating two obverse or reverse designs on the same side of the coin.

Ordinarily, after the planchet is struck, it will eject from the striking hub, allowing the next planchet to enter the hub ready to be struck and so forth. Sometimes, though, the planchet may fail to exit the striking hub so the die strikes more than once, resulting in a planchet with a double design on the same side of the coin.

In the case of the dime, if you come across a coin with two images of the Roosevelt’s profile, it is likely a double struck error.

So, how much can you expect from a double struck error? Well, this depends on the coin’s condition but aside from that, collectors are generally willing to pay a premium for such an error. A good example is a 2004-P Roosevelt dime graded MS65 with a double struck error, which a collector paid $1015 for at a Great Collections auction in 2011.

Also read: 13 Most Valuable Dime Errors Worth Money

 

7. 2004-D MS66 Roosevelt Dime Missing Clad Layer OB/REV Error

An interesting error that occurs in the 2004 Roosevelt dime series is the missing clad layer. As the name implies, this is an error in which the upper clad layer is missing from the coin, exposing the inner copper core.

Lamination issues can result in the upper clad layer of the coin bubbling, lifting and peeling, eventually leaving the inner copper core exposed.

Impurities can contaminate the alloy used to make the planchet and this can weaken the bonds between the laminated clad layers. Weakened clad layers can easily peel off on one or both sides of the coin, resulting in a full or partial missing clad layer error.

In 2012, a collector at a Heritage Auctions sale paid $610 for a full missing clad layer error on a 2004-D Roosevelt dime graded MS66. A full missing clad layer is one in which the upper layer has peeled on both sides of the obverse and reverse sides of the coin.

Check More Details

 

8. 2004-P MS65 Roosevelt Dime Die Clash Observe/ Reverse Error

Another 2004 dime error worth good money is the die clash, which, as the name implies occurs when the dies strike against each other. Usually, a planchet sits between the obverse and reverse dies and is eventually struck, but this isn’t always the case. Sometimes, the dies may strike each other without the planchet in between them.

When the dies hit against each other, they may end up transferring their respective designs onto each other due to the sheer force and pressure. When a planchet is eventually placed between the dies, the amalgamated design is transferred into one or both sides of the planchet.

On a coin with a die clash error, you will notice the primary design, for example, a strong Roosevelt’s portrait on the obverse alongside a subtler image of the reverse design.

In 2006, a collector on eBay paid $840 for a 2004-P Roosevelt dime graded MS65 with a die clash error on the obverse and reverse, making this an excellent addition to your collection.

Check More Details

 

Summary

Roosevelt dimes are plentiful and are therefore only worth their face value. But, by collecting dime errors, you can build an enviable, high-value collection. As our 2004 dime errors list shows, the right errors can be worth a fortune and can significantly improve the value of your Roosevelt dimes collection. Now is a good time to start adding errors to your collection!